Mitchell's Fish Market

The food is good however the manager needs to be fired because the food comes out too slow. We are at happy hour and there are only five tables and only six tables in the restaurant. You should not have to wait 20 minutes for food. Ridiculous. Don't eat here

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 2

Delicious!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Seafood

Our server Alex mostly ignored us while continuously checking with her other table right by us. I ordered a raspberry Arnold Palmer and it was so sour I think they forgot the tea. When I tried asking for a peach sweet tea in replacement the server rang up some other non-alcoholic concoction with mint and lemon that was also way too sour. By the time she checked on us for me to tell her about the second drink not being good we'd been there an hour so when the manager offered to get me a different tea I wasn't interested. It also took 50 minutes for our meals to come out when there was plenty of staff to be seen and not many tables - we considered leaving and going somewhere else. We hadn't been to this restaurant in years and after tonight will never return.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 2

Our server Alex mostly ignored us while continuously checking with her other table right by us. I ordered a raspberry Arnold Palmer and it was so sour I think they forgot the tea. When I tried asking for a peach sweet tea in replacement the server rang up some other non-alcoholic concoction with mint and lemon that was also way too sour. By the time she checked on us for me to tell her about the second drink not being good we'd been there an hour so when the manager offered to get me a different tea I wasn't interested. It also took 50 minutes for our meals to come out when there was plenty of staff to be seen and not many tables - we considered leaving and going somewhere else. We hadn't been to this restaurant in years and after tonight will never return.

Our server provided exceptional service to our table. We were a large group (10) and we later learned it was her first table. She was great. Service was prompt, courteous, and fun!

One of my favorite seafood places! The cedar plank salmon is the best I have had anywhere! Highly recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cedar Planked Salmon, Crispy Calamari, Vanilla Bean Crème Brûlée, Seafood

I would have given everything 5 stars but it was SO uncomfortably cold in the restaurant my wife and I ate quickly so we could leave. It's disappointing to spend over $100 on a meal and not be able to relax and enjoy it.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 3

The service was slow, and when one of the guests at our table found 4 gnats in his drink and pointed it out to the server he sent the manager to the table. She was very rude and tried to normalize it by blaming the high temperature outside. We canceled our food order and ask for the bill. The manager refused to take the drink with the gnats off and tried to tell us we would have to take the food to go. I put a $50 bill on the table for a draft beer, 2 ice tea and the drink with the gnats and we left.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 1

Thoroughly enjoyed ourselves. Great food. All four of us enjoyed our dinners. Key lime pie was authentic and excellent. Josh our waiter was was both young and new, but helpful and attentive.chef was willing to accommodate dietary restrictions easily and pleasantly.

We both enjoyed our dinners. I had salmon on cedar plank which was delicious. The amount of salmon was generous and the visual presentation was beautiful. I also had a salad that was very good. . It had dates which was a nice addition to the salad. My friend ordered a pasta dish with seafood. She has ordered this before and she was happy with it again.

My husband and I ordered wedge salads. I don't know what we got but they were not wedge salads. They were all chopped up had red purple cabbage. No bacon and no blue cheese dressing. If we had not been with another couple we would have sent them back. Very disappointed as they were not even good.

I love the twin-tails-Tuesday. Great value and plenty to eat. This trip my tails were a touch too salty for me and I don't care for big asparagus with reedy stems, but overall those were very minor issues. Love this place!

Very poor service. Food was left in the servers window for at least 15 minutes before being served. Potatoes were cold and grilled fish was hard due to being under heat lamp so long. Server did not bring condiments requested. Drinks were empty several times for several minutes.

This will go down as one of the best dining experiences my husband and I had ! We drove an hour and a half , under a recommendation. Now I know why they made the best in Kentucky sea food restaurant list . Food was fantastic! Served hot and did not take long from ordering to table . Shout out to our waiter CHRIS. He was very attentive and helpful but most of all fun and pleasant . Would definitely make that trip for this restaurant again

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Seafood Americana, Fisherman’S Lunch Catch, Seafood

I'm not sure if there was a new cook or what, but the fish n chips were not that great at all. Past time eating this lunch it was great.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Fisherman’S Lunch Catch