We could not have been more pleased with the way our daughter’s second birthday cake and cookies looked and tasted! From the start, the communication and customer service was top notch. The communication was speedy, friendly, and detailed from start to finish. I gave the cake artist a theme (Bluey) and a lot of creative freedom. She did not disappoint!The appearance of the cake and cookies was stunning and received so many compliments. My daughter loved it. We chose almond cake with raspberry filling. The cake was decadent with just the perfect amount of almond and the raspberry filling was fresh and delicious. The cookies were very intricate and delicious.To note, we picked up our order on Thursday morning for a party on Saturday and both the cake and cookies tasted like they had been baked Saturday morning, which was amazing.Thank you for a wonderful first experience! We will be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
tanya a.
I thought I'd completed this review months ago so I'm terribly sorry. My son's bday cake was the literal cutest. It was so easy ordering and communicating the design to the staff. Thank y'all so much!
Matt Hack
We used Sweets by Millie for our wedding cake and we could not have been happier. The design was exactly what we wanted and the flavors were amazing. My wife and I were dreaming of coming home to eat the rest of the cake while we were on our honeymoon.
Bethany Williams
She gave us the most beautiful and timeless wedding cake. Exactly what we wanted and it tasted amazing!!
Angela Staudigel
I ordered a two-tier Harry Potter cake. It was absolutely beautiful! I'm only leaving 4 stars because the cake was a little dry. That could have been because we didn't get to use the cake for two days after we picked it up. It was a great cake overall.
Stephanie Milby
We were very impressed with the graduation cookies we ordered from Millie’s. Not only were they beautiful but they were also delicious! We will definitely use this shop again for our next event.
Beth Bosco
Ordered a two tiered cake & two dozen cookies for our son’s graduation. Ordering, paying, & picking up were super easy. The shop was responsive & everything just went so smoothly. The cake was absolutely delicious on top of being gorgeous. The cookies were freaking amazing & presented beautifully. I recommended them to everyone, as our guests were all blown away by the beauty & deliciousness of it all! ✨Will be using the bakery whenever the need arises!
Eduard C Hanganu
Business housed in The Old Hook and Ladder Company #2 building.
worm_99
Sweets by Millie made me a custom cake for my other halfs birthday and it was spectacular! Like she pulled it right out of my imagination and made it and the strawberry cake tasted amazing as well! 10/10 will come back for weird cakes and would recommend highly!
Aaron Schoenman
I see you got reviewed by Kathy Perry. Don't apologize. She goes around creating issues with restaurants and then slams them for "not being accommodating." As a pastry chef, it was very nice of you to cram in a very labor intensive cake last minute for her to then have her turn around and complain for not going over the top with more time intensive decorations. I see what did and am giving you a 5 star rating just to off-set this deranged Google Guide going around giving us all a bad name. Oh, and she won't give you the chance of making up the "bad experience" she self-made here. Just look at the reviews she hands out. She's a very unhappy person that chooses to take it out in negative reviews against anyone rather than actually deal with the problems in life like an adult.
We’ve used Sweets by Millie to order custom UofL cookies and a cake for the celebrations we’ve had in our family. The cookies were delicious and so meticulously done. The cake was a crowd favorite. It was so impressive and absolutely delicious.Maggie is so easy to work with, very responsive, and reasonably priced. I’d highly recommend for anyone in search of cookies and cake!
Cody Nunn
My first introduction to Sweets by Millie was with my wedding cake. I can firmly say that it was probably the best cake I have ever had. The experience with picking out the flavor choices by having mini cupcakes in multiple different combinations was ingenious, not to mention every cake and icing were perfectly flavored. Recently when planning my wife’s birthday party I knew I only had one choice in the cake and by only giving instructions of “coffin shaped with black and gold color scheme” a magnificent cake was made that exceeded my expectations and tasted delicious. I will continue to use Sweets by Millie any chance I get to celebrate for any reason. Thank you Maggie!
Bridgette McDaniel
I was able to easily let them know what I need and wanted for the wedding and show pictures and it was perfect and delicious! The easiest vendor I dealt with for the whole Wedding!
Liz M.
Overall I would recommend SBM. I got a cake made a few months back and it was beautiful! The details were really nice and worth the money. On the flip side this cake did not taste good. It was dry and was not a hit at the party. Their cupcakes and cookies look delicious and beautiful. I will go that route next time.
We could not have been more pleased with the way our daughter’s second birthday cake and cookies looked and tasted! From the start, the communication and customer service was top notch. The communication was speedy, friendly, and detailed from start to finish. I gave the cake artist a theme (Bluey) and a lot of creative freedom. She did not disappoint!The appearance of the cake and cookies was stunning and received so many compliments. My daughter loved it. We chose almond cake with raspberry filling. The cake was decadent with just the perfect amount of almond and the raspberry filling was fresh and delicious. The cookies were very intricate and delicious.To note, we picked up our order on Thursday morning for a party on Saturday and both the cake and cookies tasted like they had been baked Saturday morning, which was amazing.Thank you for a wonderful first experience! We will be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I thought I'd completed this review months ago so I'm terribly sorry. My son's bday cake was the literal cutest. It was so easy ordering and communicating the design to the staff. Thank y'all so much!
We used Sweets by Millie for our wedding cake and we could not have been happier. The design was exactly what we wanted and the flavors were amazing. My wife and I were dreaming of coming home to eat the rest of the cake while we were on our honeymoon.
She gave us the most beautiful and timeless wedding cake. Exactly what we wanted and it tasted amazing!!
I ordered a two-tier Harry Potter cake. It was absolutely beautiful! I'm only leaving 4 stars because the cake was a little dry. That could have been because we didn't get to use the cake for two days after we picked it up. It was a great cake overall.
We were very impressed with the graduation cookies we ordered from Millie’s. Not only were they beautiful but they were also delicious! We will definitely use this shop again for our next event.
Ordered a two tiered cake & two dozen cookies for our son’s graduation. Ordering, paying, & picking up were super easy. The shop was responsive & everything just went so smoothly. The cake was absolutely delicious on top of being gorgeous. The cookies were freaking amazing & presented beautifully. I recommended them to everyone, as our guests were all blown away by the beauty & deliciousness of it all! ✨Will be using the bakery whenever the need arises!
Business housed in The Old Hook and Ladder Company #2 building.
Sweets by Millie made me a custom cake for my other halfs birthday and it was spectacular! Like she pulled it right out of my imagination and made it and the strawberry cake tasted amazing as well! 10/10 will come back for weird cakes and would recommend highly!
I see you got reviewed by Kathy Perry. Don't apologize. She goes around creating issues with restaurants and then slams them for "not being accommodating." As a pastry chef, it was very nice of you to cram in a very labor intensive cake last minute for her to then have her turn around and complain for not going over the top with more time intensive decorations. I see what did and am giving you a 5 star rating just to off-set this deranged Google Guide going around giving us all a bad name. Oh, and she won't give you the chance of making up the "bad experience" she self-made here. Just look at the reviews she hands out. She's a very unhappy person that chooses to take it out in negative reviews against anyone rather than actually deal with the problems in life like an adult.
Restaurantji Recommends
We’ve used Sweets by Millie to order custom UofL cookies and a cake for the celebrations we’ve had in our family. The cookies were delicious and so meticulously done. The cake was a crowd favorite. It was so impressive and absolutely delicious.Maggie is so easy to work with, very responsive, and reasonably priced. I’d highly recommend for anyone in search of cookies and cake!
My first introduction to Sweets by Millie was with my wedding cake. I can firmly say that it was probably the best cake I have ever had. The experience with picking out the flavor choices by having mini cupcakes in multiple different combinations was ingenious, not to mention every cake and icing were perfectly flavored. Recently when planning my wife’s birthday party I knew I only had one choice in the cake and by only giving instructions of “coffin shaped with black and gold color scheme” a magnificent cake was made that exceeded my expectations and tasted delicious. I will continue to use Sweets by Millie any chance I get to celebrate for any reason. Thank you Maggie!
I was able to easily let them know what I need and wanted for the wedding and show pictures and it was perfect and delicious! The easiest vendor I dealt with for the whole Wedding!
Overall I would recommend SBM. I got a cake made a few months back and it was beautiful! The details were really nice and worth the money. On the flip side this cake did not taste good. It was dry and was not a hit at the party. Their cupcakes and cookies look delicious and beautiful. I will go that route next time.
The absolute best for custom cakes in Louisville!