9 Best Pizza Restaurants near Mayfield

“Ordered Snappy Tomato pizza for supper for most of our crew and it was good. Thanks Regina and staff for a job well done.“

“Oh my gosh, I’ve searched for real Chicago style pizza since I moved and haven’t found it until now. I had the deep dish and it was amazing! My mom who is also from Chicago had pizza too and said it was the best. Definitely go here! I met the owner and he was so nice, as well as his wife. The interior of the pizzeria is Chicago themed which I loved. I plan to get more pizza when I visit again in a few weeks. I can’t wait! Thanks!!“

“Great customer service and very respectful employees. 10/10“

“For what these are they are great! Slightly glorified gas station. But sandwiches are pretty good, pizza is even better, bathroom is always clean, cashier is always friendly. But actually my favorite thing is how friend the people that work in the idk what to call it, I suppose deli? Are always very friendly and ready to help customize whatever food I am buying. Honestly this is a convience store not a 5 star restaurant however they are. Better that expected and have good people. So they ear the 5 stars.“

“The pizza today was so amazing. Made fresh and hot. Keep it up little ceasers! They also asked if we wanted crushed red pepper, handed us plenty of napkins, and some more seasoning without us having to ask. Awesome crew. Had everything at the window ready to go.“

“the Chinese food was excellent and would get the tacos again“

“So it's July 30th, 2025. I had to make a new rating. Mind you, dominos is SWAMPED today. Me and my husband did takeout. I went in there and all of the workers were lazer focused making sure that everything they cooked was spot on, hot, and fresh! They've never disappointed us. Food is top of the line as always! Thank yall. (Cough, cough... way better than papa John's and little ceasers)“

“Amazing pizza and service! Best Pizza In Graves County!“