facebook instagram facebook instagram

New Haven's Pizza Shoppe

$$ • Pizza

137 S Main St, New Haven
(502) 549-3000

Take-Out/Delivery Options

New Haven's Pizza Shoppe Reviews

4.7 - 81 reviews

The owner of New Haven pizza is a national treasure. Genuine hardworking honest guy. Always good service. Good food. I believe in supporting local hardworking people that deserve it , not big corporations or chains. This food is much better than big pizza chain stores. Go in and try it.

We called after 11pm they close at 11pm but the owner took my order and had it ready in 20 minutes when we got there to pick it up he welcomed us in to his kitchen played us a recording of a song he wrote about his house that had burned down which he sang and play a awesome drum solo in made us feel like friends not just customers the pizza was great the owener was more then cool I give the hole experience 5 stars thank you forthe A1 service Blaine you went above and beyond for...read full review

We were in town for a concert and stopped by to eat dinner beforehand. Pizza and calzones were great! Love the fresh, handmade dough! Couldn’t believe the owner runs it all himself with no help. Super impressive! Will stop by again if we’re ever in town! :)

More Reviews(81)


View all photos


Monday Closed
Tuesday 4 - 10PM
Wednesday 4 - 10PM
Thursday 4 - 10PM
Friday 4 - 10PM
Saturday 3 - 11PM
Sunday 3 - 10PM