I had a large custom cheeseburger pizza made with mayo added it was phenomenal.
Inside you'll find a great air conditioned atmosphere reminiscent of a local tavern. Staff for super courteous and prompt.
The walls were decorated with various memorabilia from prior decades.
It's also a unique building with different rooms to explore.
Definitely an amazing restaurant.
Karen Brann-Finch
Although the pizza was pretty good, the Philly Steak sandwich didn’t have much flavor. Our service was not that great. We ran out of drinks and couldn’t get waitress to look our way. It was ok but I wouldn’t go out of my way to eat here again.
don griffith
Excellent pizza, good service. More of a bar atmosphere.
Micah Tolbert
Gotta get the deep dish and lather the honey on that crust!!
Luke Pickle
Got a traditional chef combo pizza, it was incredible. We saw someone else get appetizer onion rings and they looked incredible but didn’t try them. Very reasonable price for a medium pizza for how good it was, would LOVE to come again if I’m ever in Paducah again
Elisa Farris
I just LOVE this place. It's got a great vibe. The Food is fantastic! The staff is friendly and enthusiastic. I'm so lucky to live very close so we walk to pick up takeout from there frequently.
Tammy Day
Great food, amazing drinks and SUPER friendly staff! Excellent value A+++
Jarrod Woley
Pizza is always awesome. Atmosphere is loud but it Always feels like a neighborhood bar and I love that.
Waitress was great, but took forever to take order, it took so long, she had to go check on our pizza and pay tab. They were just under staffed. I would’ve ordered an appetizer, but she was so busy I never got the chance.
My other complaint is that the mushrooms and pepperoni were almost non existent. I wish I’d have taken a pic, but by the time we got it, we were so hungry.
Matt Valentine
PBTP is a great little slice of Paducah with some of the very best pizzas in town! The other food & beer specials are worth the trip as well! The atmosphere and staff are welcoming & the service is top-notch! Great for family or dining alone. Overall, it's one of the best places to treat yourself or take a friend 🧡
Tyler Wilson
Some of the best pizza I've had.
UPDATE: 27 January 2025 Once again pizza was fantastic but unlike last time it took forever to get service. We literally sat there for 15 to 20 minutes, if not longer, to have our order taken. That includes the drink order.
Service is good and food comes out quick and is still amazing quality.
Reggie Huff
My wife and and I went there on the day before I had to have surgery and where like this is some of the best pizza we have had. So when we went back for my follow up we where like where going again so wet got the large this time the waitress said you know that’s 8lbs I was like great Iam taking it back to Owensboro for left overs and again it was amazing. Just a lil place that makes amazing pizzas
Pixel Kitty
Best pizza! The crust is so good, and we love the cheese they use. Sandwiches, salads, appetizers all very tasty.
Roy
A unique restaurant with friendly staff and great pizza.
I had a large custom cheeseburger pizza made with mayo added it was phenomenal.
Inside you'll find a great air conditioned atmosphere reminiscent of a local tavern. Staff for super courteous and prompt.
The walls were decorated with various memorabilia from prior decades.
It's also a unique building with different rooms to explore.
Definitely an amazing restaurant.
Although the pizza was pretty good, the Philly Steak sandwich didn’t have much flavor. Our service was not that great. We ran out of drinks and couldn’t get waitress to look our way. It was ok but I wouldn’t go out of my way to eat here again.
Excellent pizza, good service. More of a bar atmosphere.
Gotta get the deep dish and lather the honey on that crust!!
Got a traditional chef combo pizza, it was incredible. We saw someone else get appetizer onion rings and they looked incredible but didn’t try them. Very reasonable price for a medium pizza for how good it was, would LOVE to come again if I’m ever in Paducah again
I just LOVE this place. It's got a great vibe. The Food is fantastic! The staff is friendly and enthusiastic. I'm so lucky to live very close so we walk to pick up takeout from there frequently.
Great food, amazing drinks and SUPER friendly staff! Excellent value A+++
Pizza is always awesome. Atmosphere is loud but it Always feels like a neighborhood bar and I love that.
Waitress was great, but took forever to take order, it took so long, she had to go check on our pizza and pay tab. They were just under staffed. I would’ve ordered an appetizer, but she was so busy I never got the chance.
My other complaint is that the mushrooms and pepperoni were almost non existent. I wish I’d have taken a pic, but by the time we got it, we were so hungry.
PBTP is a great little slice of Paducah with some of the very best pizzas in town! The other food & beer specials are worth the trip as well! The atmosphere and staff are welcoming & the service is top-notch! Great for family or dining alone. Overall, it's one of the best places to treat yourself or take a friend 🧡
Some of the best pizza I've had.
UPDATE: 27 January 2025
Once again pizza was fantastic but unlike last time it took forever to get service. We literally sat there for 15 to 20 minutes, if not longer, to have our order taken. That includes the drink order.
Restaurantji Recommends
Service is good and food comes out quick and is still amazing quality.
My wife and and I went there on the day before I had to have surgery and where like this is some of the best pizza we have had. So when we went back for my follow up we where like where going again so wet got the large this time the waitress said you know that’s 8lbs I was like great Iam taking it back to Owensboro for left overs and again it was amazing. Just a lil place that makes amazing pizzas
Best pizza! The crust is so good, and we love the cheese they use. Sandwiches, salads, appetizers all very tasty.
A unique restaurant with friendly staff and great pizza.
My favorite place.
Loading...