Old School NY Pizza - Norton Commons
10600 Meeting St, Prospect
(502) 882-3000
Customers' Favorites
Tomato Basil Pizza by the Slice
Whitestone Loaded with Veggies
PBR Potato Bacon Ranch
Large Brooklyn Pizza
Chicken Caesar Pizza
Large Cheese Pizza
Side of Marinara
Pepperoni Pizza
All Meat Pizza
Cinnamon Knots
Menu
Photos
+22 photos
+21 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Hello , just wanted to share my experience. This visit was my second time coming here and the food was absolutely amazing, I took a guy that’s never been before and he loved it as well. Thank you guys so much
Great pizza however, the waiting for the food is ridiculous. Called in an order for my family and they told us 20 minutes.that was 530. My daughter is still waiting for our order and it’s 630. Just don’t tell people 20 minutes when you are busy with standing room only. I think Norton Commons needs less Mexican food, restaurants, and maybe another pizza joint and Chinese food. Compensating a disappointed customer usually smooths things over. At least have manager say sorry.
Ordered pie slices for the family and I. Very impressed by the quality of food, more authentic than most NYC pizza varieties I've had in the Louisville area. Still looking for garlic rolls myself, but family and I enjoyed the garlic knots as was served. All around worth trying and revisting! Not an option below to recommend but the Hawaiian pizza was amazing!
Parking: Located on the corner with a covered, enclosed outside dining area.
Kid-friendliness:...
Parking: Located on the corner with a covered, enclosed outside dining area.
Kid-friendliness:...
You May Also Like
Alchemy Restaurant - 10640 Meeting Street
![]()
Venezuelan, Bakery, Vegan, Vegetarian
Con Huevos! - 10639 Meeting St
![]()
Breakfast, New Mexican Cuisine, Tacos
Karem's Grill & Pub - 9424 Norton Commons Blvd
![]()
Bar & Grill, American, Vegetarian