Plehn's Bakery

3940 Shelbyville Rd, St Matthews
(502) 896-4438

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Stan Rummel

$100 to deliver 7 min up the road according to google maps. They are inflexible and not very friendly. So sad as they could be so much better than they are. Will never use them.

Tom Leeson

SOOOOOOO GOOD. like. Stupidly good. Ordered a baby shower cake. Staff VERY helpful. Can’t wait to go back again !!!!

Nick Wheatley

Ordered a wedding cake with cream cheese icing. It was delivered with butter cream and the bakery told us we were wrong. It was very clearly butter cream and we paid an upcharge for cream cheese. Really disappointed with not only the mixup but the failure to take responsibility for their mistake.

Urva patel

Best bakery in all of Kentucky!!!! They literally have everything and all the food is so delicious!!!!

Brittany Manis

First time customer, I ordered a custom cake for my twin’s birthday. Quick turn around and good communication from staff. The cake was beautifully decorated and so DELICIOUS!!! Hands down the best buttercream icing I’ve ever tasted. Looking forward to trying more of their menu items.

Jim Warren

Everything tastes artificial. Very disappointing

Marisa Jaggers

Everything here is AMAZING! So moist and soft!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jeremy Gallas

This bakery is wonderful in every possible way. But I'm only posting so that you go and buy a Coconut Kuchen. It is a coconut custard pie that is the 8th wonder of the world. This thing makes the grey days brighter, girls weak in the knees, and children experience their first love. The one problem? Bliss like this sells out almost every day by noon. So, what I need is for you to ramp up the requests for the Coconut Kuchen. Then they'll make more each day, and when I stroll in around 2 pm on a random Wednesday, they'll be ready for me. Do yourself a favor; buy two each time you go. Hide one way back in the fridge and tell the family about the other one. Now, you have the best midnight snack of all time. You're welcome.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lacy Robinson

Best cookies!!!! We love going here.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

David Lowell

Such a wonderful bakery and deli. The employees are super friendly and the atmosphere is welcoming. Came to buy one doughnut and bought four!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Doughnut, Bakery

Nicholas Howard

Terrible customer service. The lady called out my number I told her I had it then she skipped me and went to someone else and then I bought a pie and it was all mushy and not all the way done. I asked if I could have a refund and she said no in a very rude manor I asked to speak to a manager and she’s like I am the manager. She needs to work on her attitude especially with working in customer service.

Thomas heating cooling

Took my on a 2 day notice thanks life saver

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Creekmore Marketing and Web Design

A Louisville staple! Everything here is delicious, and the people working behind the counter are always friendly and ready to offer suggestions. The thumbprint cookies and cheese straws are incredible. I hope everyone who visits Louisville stops to pick up a few treats!

L J

Happy 100 to Phlen’s AND my Mom, JoCleta Wilson 10/4/1924. The cake(s) were absolutely outstanding! Just beautiful!!

ME STA

Freshest best tasting bakery cake I have ever tasted! Beautifully decorated too!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...