Quaint 50s vibe sandwich shop with an East coast flair.
Loren Sutton
I was seated by a woman in her 90s. Which was fine. Until her son was incredibly rude, insinuating I should have seated myself and gotten my own high chair for my daughter. His demeanor and attitude was so rude I just left immediately. Do NOT go here. The seating area was also musty, 10 degrees too warm, and SILENT. Worst 2 minutes I’ve ever spent in a restaurant.
Josh Moreau
Whoever the waitress is that was working 5/23 is rude and I will not be coming back
Dave graichen
A visit to critics choice was way overdue so we made a stop in on Thursday night. My friend got an Italian grinder and I got a meatball sub. I gotta tell you probably one of the best sandwiches I’ve had in a long time and I’m a big eater, but I couldn’t finish it. I brought it home and took it to work this morning And enjoyed it again for lunch. If you haven’t been there in a while, you need to check it out.
Brian Wallis
First time to eat here. Have to say, it was a very nice small mom n pop restaurant. The waiter treats you like family (super nice) and the food...hands down best philly cheese steak sandwich I've had in 30 years. I will definitely be coming back
Shane Wenger
Owners were on site and very friendly. Explained everything on the menu and was extremely proud of their food, which was great.
Toccara Freeman
The service was horrible. I witnessed one of the servers be blatantly racist to a group of African American students that tried to get food. She was upset because a student did not want to pay for a pizza she touched with her bare hands. She was rude and unsanitary. She referred to the students as “You people “. Even though the situation did not happen to me personally it still reflected horribly on the business. I did not get to order my food. I will never go to that place again.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Tom Poole
Fantastic food and great hospitality.
Very polite and friendly staff
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chopped Steak Dinner
Brianna Perkins
Genuinely some of the best food I've had in a while, the atmosphere is amazing and the people that work there are very sweet, it's a bit more expensive than what I normally get (on a budget atm) but the quality of the food definitely makes it worth every penny and I'm glad I indulged into going there, I definitely will be going back there again! (The sloppy Joe is AMAZING as well as the cheese fries, and their soda's are, oddly enough, more refreshing than what you'd get at most other restaurants)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Fries, Sandwich, Critics Club Sandwich Turkey Ham Bacon & Cheese
Kristi Kor
This is a great neighborhood gem in downtown Alexandria. Service was excellent, menu offers a variety. We had the Philly Cheesesteak Sandwich and Italian Grinder. Philly Steak was thinly sliced with peppers, onions, mushrooms, provolone and mayo. Great flavor and oh so tender. The roll was deliciously toasted. The Grinder was the standout today. A generous selection of Italian meats, cheeses, lettuce, tomato and sweet banana peppers dressed with a flavorful, homemade vinaigrette on a delicious roll and finished in the oven. It was excellent! This family owned business is inviting and feels like home with very good food. We will be back!
Parking: 12
Kid-friendliness: A great, relaxed atmosphere to bring the family. Plenty of food options for children.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Grinder, Cheese Steak Done Right
Place was good. I liked that they toasted my hot hogie just enough to melt the cheese and make the crispy which I liked. Waiter told us that they used peanut oil to cook with and the difference’s between the hot and cold items which was nice to know.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Grinder
Robert Park
Tasty sandwiches and thoughtful service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Grinder, Sandwich
Digital Sparks
Critics Choice, located in the heart of Downtown Alexandria, Louisiana, is a culinary gem offering a delightful array of hors d'oeuvres, sandwiches, dinners, and desserts that cater to every taste and preference.One of the standout features of Critics Choice is its commitment to quality and health-conscious cooking. They fry their delectable offerings in 100% cholesterol-free peanut oil, ensuring a guilt-free indulgence for patrons.The hors d'oeuvres menu boasts a variety of battered delights, from crispy string beans and beer-battered onion rings to broccoli cheese balls and mozzarella cheese sticks. Each bite is bursting with flavor and served with a side of nostalgia.For those craving a hearty sandwich, Critics Choice delivers with their Philadelphia steak sandwiches and hoagies. The thinly sliced beef cooked to perfection is served on an Italian roll with sautéed onions, mushrooms, and hot or banana peppers, creating a symphony of flavors that's sure to satisfy any appetite.Diners can also indulge in a variety of other mouthwatering options, including the Parmigiana sandwiches topped with Mom's Italian tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese, and the signature Philly burger served on a NY Kaiser roll with center-cut bacon, lettuce, and tomato.In addition to sandwiches, Critics Choice offers a tempting selection of dinners, from classic Chicken Parmigiana and Spaghetti to savory Chopped Steak and Open-Faced Hot Beef. Each dish is lovingly prepared to order and served with a side of nostalgia.No meal is complete without dessert, and Critics Choice does not disappoint. Indulge in traditional Italian cannoli, New York cheesecake, or decadent chocolate layer cake, each bite a perfect ending to a memorable dining experience.Whether you're dining in or taking out, Critics Choice offers a culinary journey that delights the senses and leaves you craving more. With its diverse menu, friendly service, and commitment to quality, Critics Choice is a must-visit destination for food enthusiasts in Downtown Alexandria.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
K. S.
I highly recommend the Italian Grinder sandwich, it was the absolute best! Calm atmosphere and friendly welcoming staff. Will definitely come back again!
Quaint 50s vibe sandwich shop with an East coast flair.
I was seated by a woman in her 90s. Which was fine. Until her son was incredibly rude, insinuating I should have seated myself and gotten my own high chair for my daughter. His demeanor and attitude was so rude I just left immediately. Do NOT go here. The seating area was also musty, 10 degrees too warm, and SILENT. Worst 2 minutes I’ve ever spent in a restaurant.
Whoever the waitress is that was working 5/23 is rude and I will not be coming back
A visit to critics choice was way overdue so we made a stop in on Thursday night. My friend got an Italian grinder and I got a meatball sub. I gotta tell you probably one of the best sandwiches I’ve had in a long time and I’m a big eater, but I couldn’t finish it. I brought it home and took it to work this morning And enjoyed it again for lunch. If you haven’t been there in a while, you need to check it out.
First time to eat here. Have to say, it was a very nice small mom n pop restaurant. The waiter treats you like family (super nice) and the food...hands down best philly cheese steak sandwich I've had in 30 years. I will definitely be coming back
Owners were on site and very friendly. Explained everything on the menu and was extremely proud of their food, which was great.
The service was horrible. I witnessed one of the servers be blatantly racist to a group of African American students that tried to get food. She was upset because a student did not want to pay for a pizza she touched with her bare hands. She was rude and unsanitary. She referred to the students as “You people “. Even though the situation did not happen to me personally it still reflected horribly on the business. I did not get to order my food. I will never go to that place again.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Fantastic food and great hospitality.
Very polite and friendly staff
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chopped Steak Dinner
Genuinely some of the best food I've had in a while, the atmosphere is amazing and the people that work there are very sweet, it's a bit more expensive than what I normally get (on a budget atm) but the quality of the food definitely makes it worth every penny and I'm glad I indulged into going there, I definitely will be going back there again! (The sloppy Joe is AMAZING as well as the cheese fries, and their soda's are, oddly enough, more refreshing than what you'd get at most other restaurants)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Fries, Sandwich, Critics Club Sandwich Turkey Ham Bacon & Cheese
This is a great neighborhood gem in downtown Alexandria. Service was excellent, menu offers a variety. We had the Philly Cheesesteak Sandwich and Italian Grinder. Philly Steak was thinly sliced with peppers, onions, mushrooms, provolone and mayo. Great flavor and oh so tender. The roll was deliciously toasted. The Grinder was the standout today. A generous selection of Italian meats, cheeses, lettuce, tomato and sweet banana peppers dressed with a flavorful, homemade vinaigrette on a delicious roll and finished in the oven. It was excellent! This family owned business is inviting and feels like home with very good food. We will be back!
Parking: 12
Kid-friendliness: A great, relaxed atmosphere to bring the family. Plenty of food options for children.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Grinder, Cheese Steak Done Right
Restaurantji Recommends
Great food and great staff!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Place was good. I liked that they toasted my hot hogie just enough to melt the cheese and make the crispy which I liked. Waiter told us that they used peanut oil to cook with and the difference’s between the hot and cold items which was nice to know.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Grinder
Tasty sandwiches and thoughtful service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Grinder, Sandwich
Critics Choice, located in the heart of Downtown Alexandria, Louisiana, is a culinary gem offering a delightful array of hors d'oeuvres, sandwiches, dinners, and desserts that cater to every taste and preference.One of the standout features of Critics Choice is its commitment to quality and health-conscious cooking. They fry their delectable offerings in 100% cholesterol-free peanut oil, ensuring a guilt-free indulgence for patrons.The hors d'oeuvres menu boasts a variety of battered delights, from crispy string beans and beer-battered onion rings to broccoli cheese balls and mozzarella cheese sticks. Each bite is bursting with flavor and served with a side of nostalgia.For those craving a hearty sandwich, Critics Choice delivers with their Philadelphia steak sandwiches and hoagies. The thinly sliced beef cooked to perfection is served on an Italian roll with sautéed onions, mushrooms, and hot or banana peppers, creating a symphony of flavors that's sure to satisfy any appetite.Diners can also indulge in a variety of other mouthwatering options, including the Parmigiana sandwiches topped with Mom's Italian tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese, and the signature Philly burger served on a NY Kaiser roll with center-cut bacon, lettuce, and tomato.In addition to sandwiches, Critics Choice offers a tempting selection of dinners, from classic Chicken Parmigiana and Spaghetti to savory Chopped Steak and Open-Faced Hot Beef. Each dish is lovingly prepared to order and served with a side of nostalgia.No meal is complete without dessert, and Critics Choice does not disappoint. Indulge in traditional Italian cannoli, New York cheesecake, or decadent chocolate layer cake, each bite a perfect ending to a memorable dining experience.Whether you're dining in or taking out, Critics Choice offers a culinary journey that delights the senses and leaves you craving more. With its diverse menu, friendly service, and commitment to quality, Critics Choice is a must-visit destination for food enthusiasts in Downtown Alexandria.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I highly recommend the Italian Grinder sandwich, it was the absolute best! Calm atmosphere and friendly welcoming staff. Will definitely come back again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Grinder
Loading...