City Slice Pizza and Pints

Our waitress was great - Kitchen needs help. We order all at the same time but my kids finished both their 10” pizzas before mine made it to the table. Way under cooked. Had to take it home to finish cooking it. Cheese wasn’t melted and the topping was room temp. Made the wrong flavored wings too. My kids pizzas were great.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 5

Thursday night Karaoke was great! I sang until my voice was hoarse. Good drinks and vibes all around.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

My husband and I went on our first date to City Slice when it was on E. Chimes. We were obsessed with City Slice and would go back often to enjoy the Flying Pig pizza. We visited the new location on Nicholson and we were so incredibly disappointed to the point we will not be going back. I am not sure if it is under new ownership or what changed. But the pizza was sub par and this is coming from two people who used to rave about how good City Slice was. The crust wasn’t the same, the menu is very different, the service was not good, and the atmosphere was like I was still at pluckers. It isn’t the same City Slice and might have been better calling it something different so that the expectations weren’t there.
I write this review with hopes to go back and that something changes for the better. Because we sure do miss that delicious pizza.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

The GOAT pizza was burnt on the bottom along with an enormous amount of cornmeal while the top was under cooked. We tried eating it but threw away over half of the pizza. The pepperoni pizza was better but still undercooked on top but less burnt on bottom

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 5

Pizza was good, not the very very best still good pizza for the kids and family to enjoy!! Went for the first time and enjoyed the time there. Got to watch LsU soccer on the tv with sound!! That’s perfect for me! Staff was very nice and we have plenty of left overs! Will be back for sure

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

This was my previous review: Yummy. The Italian margarita was delish. I had the pizza with all the meats. I was not able to eat more than 1 slice of my personal pizza. Our waitress was great. Definitely coming back.
Current review: whatever changes that were made in the move, have ruined it. Will not be back. Pizza is tasteless. Huntsbrothers has more taste. They have removed the majority of the menu. The pizza dough is not good. They are stingy with the toppings. My pictures from previous times and today are drastically different. Completely disappointed.

Food: 1

Pizza was so bland had no flavor wings rubbery like they needed to be cooked longer spent almost $40 on some BS honestly

Best thing I can say about City Slice is the service is okay. The inside is drab and unexciting, pizza is a half notch better than Digiorno and the floors looked like they could use a good cleaning. Tried the cheese sticks with purple sauce and it tasted like the charred crust they were baked on. Do yourself a favor, travel a quarter mile further and order out at Howie's it's a step up.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 3

How you comment on the good reviews that shows no pictures but when it comes to your bad reviews that show evidence of what happening to their food you by pass them that really explains your character and how you handle your business. Shame on you need to do better as an owner. Never gonna order from here again

loved the old one thought it was the best pizza in BR

new one on nicholson is nothing comparable. would rather get pizza from a bowling alley

r.i.p. to a formerly great spot

They use to have a really good pizza but the one I got tonight was burnt on the bottom and 3/4 cooked on top hardly any toppings and doesn't taste anywhere close to the last one I had !!! Not good at all !!! Gas station quality

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 4

I had basic pepperoni pizza and it was delicious. I love the not too thin crust with just the right crunch, good sauce, perfect amount of pepperoni and lots of cheese. I also ordered cheesy bread and at the suggestion of my server Caroline, I 'made it Italian ' with in house roasted garlic. So good, can't wait to try something else from City Slice

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Food was excellent- will come back on game day to watch the game.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: 16 Pepperoni Pizza, Chicken Wings

the new location rocks!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I loved City Slice when it was near campus on E Chimes. Went there most afternoons for lunch. Now that they have relocated the pizza is mediocre sadness. First off, no more $6.50 slice. No more slice at all actually. Just 10” and 16” pizzas. Also it doesn’t have that Smokey taste with bits of crispy burnt thin crust that was fantastic. Kinda reminds me a Chuck E Cheese pizza now and stingy with the toppings. Was the palest pizza ever and almost had a playdough texture.I hope they decide to go back to how the pizza was. As it is now, I won’t be returning