New York Bagel Jefferson

8210 Jefferson Hwy # A, Baton Rouge
(225) 924-5657

Recent Reviews

Gb G.

Great bagels, great service... next trip to Baton Rouge we will stop again. Added bonus nice shopping near by...

Brittany Honore

Very professional and friendly staff. I ordered the Brooklyn bomber. It’s always a great choice!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Brooklyn Bomber

Brandon H.

My girlfriend and I tried this place for the first time the other day and its absolutely delicious! The inside is a cozy ookie nook and the Brooklyn bomber was BOMB.

Michael Friedkin

Great bagels, when they have any.Must come early because demand fluctuates a lot. On weekends, come before 11:00am or you will not have your pick of bagel flavors. Their bagel breakfast sandwiches are great, when they serve them. Last time I went they had stopped serving them around 9:50am....supposed to be at least 10:30am when they stop and begin lunch. A word of warning, they close at 2:30 every day because they cannot make or keep enough bagels to last any longer. Food and especially bagel are great, but management needs to work harder maintaining their bagel inventory a tad longer each day. If they are out of your favorite flavors, buy their bags of bagel chips and flavored cream cheeses. Not as good as fresh baked bagels but will do when you have that desire for bagels and cream cheeses.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Breakfast Sandwich, Brooklyn Bomber, Bagel Chips

Michael Chorazak

Tried to get there when it opened at 6:30am on a Thursday, doors were locked and no one in sight. Waited until 6:45am until I had to leave for work and still nothing. Disappointing.

Service: 1

Tricia Harter

Excellent every time!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Bill Naids

These bagels are just round bread.Don’t waste your time.

Hazel S.

I visited this bagel shop because there were so many comparisons on the yelp page of the Perkins location and I'm glad I did. We ordered the Hell's Kitchen and the Manhattan. The sandwiches were delicious and the bagels were soft and chewy.

Pinoc chio

You must try their breakfast,coffee. Place is so clean for dine in, services is good. You get free toasty bagel chips. Avocado toast was so yummy ?

Van Nguyen

This place has the best bagels I have ever eaten. The service here is friendly and welcoming.

Gregory Allen

Ordered a turkey sandwich on an everything bagel - to go. Got a turkey sandwich on a blueberry bagel. Gross. Not a good lunch. Would not recomend.

Michelle Brooks

This was our most favorite place ever. Unfortunately they changed owners about 3 years ago and it's just not the same. It wasn't awful by any means it just wasn't what it used to be.

Sarah D.

If you are craving a good bagel, look no further. This visit all I had was a pumpernickel bagel with garden veggie cream cheese. It really hit the spot. In precious visits I've had bagel sandwiches and bagel pizzas and they also did not disappoint. The food tastes very fresh. It's a very casual and unassuming place. Order at the counter, and at this location the food was brought to our table (it wasn't busy). It may be that you pick up at the counter at other times (or maybe not but I digress). It's no frills and good value. They don't really advertise so I often forget about it but have always enjoyed what I've ordered. Due to the prices and consistency of the food being good, I recommend giving this place a try. We have been and will continue to be repeat customers.

Robert H.

Hard to find an authentic tasting NY bagel but this place nails it. Great flavor and consistent service.

A D

For starters we should take the name New York out of the title. This place is not in the realm of New York. The vibe feels depressing and as though someone just gave up and they are mid way closing for good. The bagels aren’t on display. The fridge is dark and doesn’t show cream cheese or any other kind of Deli style salads. Example - Potato - Macaroni. They don’t do breakfast after 10:30am and they take the coffee away at 10:30am. These are BASICS of any establishment in New York. What can you get on the bagel? One would never know since there’s no menu. Once you do get the mystery bagel from the back, it’s dry, cakey, and tasteless, unlike the crispy chewy delicious bagels of NY. The only redeeming quality is the nice staff. People who gave this place more than one star have been living in Baton Rouge for too long. Wouldn’t recommend!

Load More