Hands down phenomenal ice cream! The staff is always very friendly and appreciative of their customers at pick up. Love their creative flavors. Join the text list for the ice cream drop and you won’t have any issues snatching an order. Love them!
Burnell Jenkins
Love it
Krystal Wilson
All I can say is Amazingly delicious omg I just brought one pint for myself which is rich and yummy 🤤 I let my sister and niece have some and they were blown away i highly recommend I can’t wait to taste 👅 all other flavors
Jamie
Flavors good but my pint felt like there was a lot of salt poured on top. Extremely salty the salt over powered the sweetness. After 3 scoops unedible due to the salt! Cookie Butter Cheesecake
Logan Williams
I’m kind of an ice cream connoisseur - it’s one of my favorite things to eat and I make a point of trying a new ice cream shop everywhere I go! I’ve also bought from several different small batch ice cream shops throughout the country - but nowhere is better than Super Witch! It is genuinely the best ice cream I’ve ever had. They’ve got awesome new flavors every week that are unique and creative and the taste and texture are absolutely fire.
Not to mention, Briggs - the owner/genius behind it all - is a super nice, friendly guy. Go check it out!!!
Sarah Neupert
How do you get this ice cream???? Why so confusing
Samantha Camardelle
Literally the best ice cream I’ve ever had. Gave it a shot with the Crunk Crunch and I’m going to tell you right now, it’s 100% worth the money. You guys now have a lifelong customer.
Maegan
Yes. Everything about it is just, yes.
Creamy, soft, rich and sweet. Loaded with toppings and flavor. We loved this! Definitely fresh and the best ice cream we’ve ever had. I picked up my order within like 2 minutes. My husband said it’s the best dessert he’s ever had.
Venessa Bates
Phenomenal flavors and the friendliest service. Absolutely worth getting in on the online drop and heading over for pick up. Get the soft serve when they have it available!
This is the best ice cream that I have ever had. Anyone that likes ice cream needs to try Super Witch. The quality, flavors, and customer service are consistently outstanding.
William Fernandez
This ice cream is absolutely amazing! Every pint is packed and the flavors are beyond delicious. You can definitely tell they use high-quality ingredients. Whether you're into classic flavors or something more unique, they have something for everyone. If you haven’t tried this local gem yet, you’re seriously missing out!
Karleigh Barkemeyer
Can't say enough good things about this ice cream! The flavors are incredibly rich and creative, with the perfect balance of sweetness and creaminess. You can really taste the quality ingredients in every bite. The pints are packed with flavor, and I love that they offer unique options alongside the classics. Plus, Briggs and Baleigh are top notch! If you're looking for the best local ice cream, this is it! Highly recommend!
Wendi Lagasse
So I’m not the kind of person that usually leaves reviews , but this place has ALWAYS exceeded my expectations, the ice cream is always on point, I have yet to walk away and not be 100 percent satisfied and not only is the ice cream on point , but the customer service is outstanding. I literally will not eat any other ice cream at this point, my whole family is absolutely sold on this place. Keep doing what you do.
Hannah Sensenbrenner
SuperWitch Ice Cream is hands down the best ice cream I’ve ever had—and that’s saying something because I grew up eating ice cream every night for dessert. From the first bite, I was hooked. The texture is absolute perfection: soft, creamy, never icy or hard. Every flavor is so fresh and well-balanced, never overly sweet or artificial-tasting.
One of my favorite things about SuperWitch is the weekly flavor drops because you really never know what’s coming up next! I genuinely get giddy every Wednesday waiting to see what’s new, and I have to pace myself so I don’t devour it all in one sitting. It’s that good. If you love ice cream, this is the real deal—pure magic in every pint!
On top of that, if you have the pleasure of meeting Briggs, the owner, congratulations because your life just got sweeter!!! Briggs is the most kind, humble, hard working, genuine, lovable human you’ll ever cross paths with, and it’s just a bonus that he and his team make the best ice cream on earth.
Also: I have family who live out of town (Alabama) who are also ice cream aficionados, and they are always asking me when I can purchase SuperWitch and bring it across state lines!
Hands down phenomenal ice cream! The staff is always very friendly and appreciative of their customers at pick up. Love their creative flavors. Join the text list for the ice cream drop and you won’t have any issues snatching an order. Love them!
Love it
All I can say is Amazingly delicious omg I just brought one pint for myself which is rich and yummy 🤤 I let my sister and niece have some and they were blown away i highly recommend I can’t wait to taste 👅 all other flavors
Flavors good but my pint felt like there was a lot of salt poured on top. Extremely salty the salt over powered the sweetness. After 3 scoops unedible due to the salt! Cookie Butter Cheesecake
I’m kind of an ice cream connoisseur - it’s one of my favorite things to eat and I make a point of trying a new ice cream shop everywhere I go! I’ve also bought from several different small batch ice cream shops throughout the country - but nowhere is better than Super Witch! It is genuinely the best ice cream I’ve ever had. They’ve got awesome new flavors every week that are unique and creative and the taste and texture are absolutely fire.
Not to mention, Briggs - the owner/genius behind it all - is a super nice, friendly guy. Go check it out!!!
How do you get this ice cream???? Why so confusing
Literally the best ice cream I’ve ever had. Gave it a shot with the Crunk Crunch and I’m going to tell you right now, it’s 100% worth the money. You guys now have a lifelong customer.
Yes. Everything about it is just, yes.
Creamy, soft, rich and sweet. Loaded with toppings and flavor. We loved this! Definitely fresh and the best ice cream we’ve ever had. I picked up my order within like 2 minutes. My husband said it’s the best dessert he’s ever had.
Phenomenal flavors and the friendliest service. Absolutely worth getting in on the online drop and heading over for pick up. Get the soft serve when they have it available!
It’s just too good.
Restaurantji Recommends
This is the best ice cream that I have ever had. Anyone that likes ice cream needs to try Super Witch. The quality, flavors, and customer service are consistently outstanding.
This ice cream is absolutely amazing! Every pint is packed and the flavors are beyond delicious. You can definitely tell they use high-quality ingredients. Whether you're into classic flavors or something more unique, they have something for everyone. If you haven’t tried this local gem yet, you’re seriously missing out!
Can't say enough good things about this ice cream! The flavors are incredibly rich and creative, with the perfect balance of sweetness and creaminess. You can really taste the quality ingredients in every bite. The pints are packed with flavor, and I love that they offer unique options alongside the classics. Plus, Briggs and Baleigh are top notch! If you're looking for the best local ice cream, this is it! Highly recommend!
So I’m not the kind of person that usually leaves reviews , but this place has ALWAYS exceeded my expectations, the ice cream is always on point, I have yet to walk away and not be 100 percent satisfied and not only is the ice cream on point , but the customer service is outstanding. I literally will not eat any other ice cream at this point, my whole family is absolutely sold on this place. Keep doing what you do.
SuperWitch Ice Cream is hands down the best ice cream I’ve ever had—and that’s saying something because I grew up eating ice cream every night for dessert. From the first bite, I was hooked. The texture is absolute perfection: soft, creamy, never icy or hard. Every flavor is so fresh and well-balanced, never overly sweet or artificial-tasting.
One of my favorite things about SuperWitch is the weekly flavor drops because you really never know what’s coming up next! I genuinely get giddy every Wednesday waiting to see what’s new, and I have to pace myself so I don’t devour it all in one sitting. It’s that good. If you love ice cream, this is the real deal—pure magic in every pint!
On top of that, if you have the pleasure of meeting Briggs, the owner, congratulations because your life just got sweeter!!! Briggs is the most kind, humble, hard working, genuine, lovable human you’ll ever cross paths with, and it’s just a bonus that he and his team make the best ice cream on earth.
Also: I have family who live out of town (Alabama) who are also ice cream aficionados, and they are always asking me when I can purchase SuperWitch and bring it across state lines!
Loading...