Reginelli's Pizzeria

5961 Magazine St, New Orleans
(504) 899-1414

Recent Reviews

Jim Allan

Great service. Average pizza.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Ryanmichaelnyc29

Pizza was ice cold and hard as a rock, wings were overly saucy and inedibleDelivery took forever-at 4pm?!?Maybe dine in is better but this meal was a complete waste of 50.00

Food: 2

J S.

Do not get delivery Pizza was hard as a rock Wings cold Eat in if you want Reginellis Great food Detroit style Sicilian pizza is the best Really wish they would carry ultra or bud light on draft and would have built a bar seating area for those of us that dine alone Strange atmosphere and service is SLOW BUT- All that aside- The food is great!!!!

Home Again of GA

Hey I just passed by this spot and thought I’d stop in for a slice. I was told that they have a Detroit Pizza. I was so excited because I’m originally from Detroit but live in New Orleans for over 20 years. Let me say this “Don’t ever disrespect Detroit by saying you have a Detroit style pizza” This slice is very hard, dry and tasteless! I really wanted it to taste good being that I’m from Detroit. This has got to be the worst pizza I’ve ever had in my life. You definitely need to rename the Pizza. It was terrible! Sincerely, SheldonThanks Heidi for responding. I followed your instructions and never heard back from you. I will accept that as your concern wasn’t genuine.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Brice life

Place was dirty walked in and walked out .they need to mop but always clean after each customer.

Karen V.

I don't give low star reviews very often because I like to give places a chance. But after a terrible and SLOW experience and reading similar reviews, I have to add to it. Probably took over fifteen minutes to ask us for our order. Took another 45 minutes plus to get the pizza. Many employees and not many tables filled. I think online orders interfere with customer service of sit-down customers it seems. Ordered a small. Got a large served to us. Thankfully not charged for the large but got some passive aggressive weirdness from waiter about the mess up THAT WAS ON THEM.

Emily Toops

Came here for the garlic knots (which are buttery little knots of pure heaven), and ended up ordering a Detroit style pizza with BBQ shrimp. I'm from Chicago and have never seen/heard of a shrimp pizza before, but it was absolutely delicious! The shrimp was tender, the savory sauce complimented the shrimp perfectly, and all on top of a pillowy buttery crust.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, BBQ Shrimp Detroit Style Pizza

Shannon Lee

Pizza was great

tyson foley

Great place for a slice of pizza, or a whole pizza, no judgement!

Thomas Sullivan

Enjoyed Taylors service. The Cajun Crawfish Pizza and King Cake Bread Pudding were both really great.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lane Waguespack

The food was bussin. Made a happy plate.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Pepperoni Pizza 10, Custom Pizza 10

Angela Faye Brown

Some of the best pizza in New Orleans. Atmosphere is sort of blah.Dietary restrictions: gluten free pizza is great and they are well aware of other ingredients in their dishes

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Bryce Hamm (EERiE Ln.)

Sorry excuse for a Detroit Style Pizza.Didn't bother to devein shrimp either.Lazy all around.Giving an extra star only because the pizza was properly baked.

Food: 1

bunny rieken

This eggplant is amazingVegetarian options: Eggplant reginellis & hummus sandwich with asparagus with pesto

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Gabriel Akin

Lovely place with great

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Avocado and Asparagus Salad

Load More