We ate inside and received food hot and in a timely manner. Unlimited refills on drinks.Great pb pie!! Yet disappointed at the portion size of the slice, for $8 it was small. Well at least my kid was over joyed at the portion size of the calzone. Unfortunately I deducted a star because there was runny clear liquid coming from the bottom of the crust dripping onto the plate when she would take a bite. Anyway it was pretty good.
Mary Perry
The pizza and wings were amazing, which I was surprised by how good they were.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Homemade Saucy Chicken Wings, Pie
NoBigDeal !!
This is a review, in hopes for this restaurant to turn things around.Two years ago this was the go to place for pizza.In a city such as New Orleans, where food is everything, this establishment has declined at every order this year. Aside, from every delivery driver complaining at our door that this company doesn’t tip them, to consistently cold pizza, and simply no shows.That straw for us today was the $52 pizza made by a toddler. We ordered a thin crust Hawaiian with a king Cake side.We received (after listening to the delivery driver complain about the company tipping issue) a cooked pepperoni pizza with uncooked cold lunch meat and pineapple toppings tossed on top, with out cheese; and no King Cake but instead we received a frozen molten cake. Paying $52 upfront and hoping that your pizza shows up warm and is what you ordered, without grief from delivery drivers has now become a pipe dream with this company. Needless to say we took a family vote, and feel we have trusted this company with enough of our family dinners to figure it out, and they haven’t.This city has too many amazing restaurants, to settle for what now, appears as express laziness.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
R Jen
We liked the pizza so much we went back twice! The All Meat Pie was exactly that lots of meat! Very good, not too much sauce and/or cheese. Food came up quickly. Both visits were late night cravings, had a Margherita pizza and an Italian Combo with Chicken wings. Again good pizza, and the wings were nice size and the Kick'in Bourbon was a tasty sauce not hot to me and I don't hot very well so it was perfect! Definitely a stop when you're in the neighborhood!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: All Meat Pizza, Homemade Saucy Chicken Wings, Italian Pie
Chuck Shubert
Mozzarella sticks and a Caesar salad...will definitely go back
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Kyli C.
Good/okay pizza..price was a little high for the quality. Although the peanut butter pie was very good.
Julie Rhimi
The pizza was awesome! Not so friendly..They had a group of kids come in, and they were so loud. The employees never said anything to them.The reason for the 2 stars is because our pizza came in a box. They gave us plates to eat off of, but they were greasy, and you could see the food that had been left on it. Like it hadn't even been washed, both of them.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Italian Pie
Mark Joschko
Food was tasty and quick. Building is a little dated, which adds to the charm but could use a little TLC. Keep the look and vibe, just a deep clean and some touch
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pie, Salad
Emily Wakefield
Portion sizes were exceedingly small for the charge. No bread which was said to be included in menu. I truly hat to criticize. But I cannot wrap my head around how much we paid for such small portions.
Ryanmichaelnyc29
Processed frozen chicken - why not just use fresh…the chicken parm tasted like cafeteria foodPricy for what you get-Decent tasting but not worth the price at all
Close to hotel. Local joint. Meatball sub, pizza and a couple beers your can't go wrong.
Urania Wynperle
Ordered a 14 inch build your own pizza. Eggplant sausage and seasoned ricotta and it was delicious. Like really good. However we ordered a large Mediterranean salad and barely fed 2 people it was so small. When I called they must asked if it was in a 9x9 takeout container and when I said yes they said that's a large. It's not the container it was the amount that was in it for $15. They just said we'll tell the owner. I just wanted them to charge me for a small. I wasn't asking for anything free. Be careful ordering the large salad, it's not worth the money.
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Italian Pie, Salad
Adan Burlington
As a first-time customer at The Original Italian Pie, I was blown away by the delightful experience. Let me share why this place deserves every star:1. **Pizza Perfection**: I'm not easily impressed when it comes to pizza, but The Original Italian Pie exceeded my expectations. The **Hawaiian pizza** on **thin crust** was a tropical delight. The balance of sweet pineapple, savory ham, and gooey cheese was spot-on.2. **Cheesy Garlic Bread Bliss**: Brace yourself for the **cheesy garlic bread**—it's a game-changer! The warm, garlicky aroma alone had me salivating. But when I took that first bite, I knew I was in love. The crispy edges, the gooey cheese, and the fragrant garlic—it was like a cheesy hug for my taste buds.3. **Couldn't Stop Eating**: I confess—I ate until I couldn't move. The pizza and garlic bread combo was irresistible. Each bite was a little slice of heaven. I might have even done a happy food dance (don't judge!).5. **Reordering Guaranteed**: If I'm ever back in town, you can bet your last slice that I'll be dialing up The Original Italian Pie for another feast. It's a promise!In summary, if you're craving pizza perfection and cheesy garlic bread dreams, look no further. The Original Italian Pie is where it's at. ?❤️
Food: 5
Will Bradford
If you are completely smashed and this is the closest place to your hotel, I imagine it is probably pretty decent. If you aren't you are wasting your
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Jay lopez
They don’t sell pizza by the slice, there chicken parm sandwich and pasta was trash taste like Tyson
We ate inside and received food hot and in a timely manner. Unlimited refills on drinks.Great pb pie!! Yet disappointed at the portion size of the slice, for $8 it was small. Well at least my kid was over joyed at the portion size of the calzone. Unfortunately I deducted a star because there was runny clear liquid coming from the bottom of the crust dripping onto the plate when she would take a bite. Anyway it was pretty good.
The pizza and wings were amazing, which I was surprised by how good they were.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Homemade Saucy Chicken Wings, Pie
This is a review, in hopes for this restaurant to turn things around.Two years ago this was the go to place for pizza.In a city such as New Orleans, where food is everything, this establishment has declined at every order this year. Aside, from every delivery driver complaining at our door that this company doesn’t tip them, to consistently cold pizza, and simply no shows.That straw for us today was the $52 pizza made by a toddler. We ordered a thin crust Hawaiian with a king Cake side.We received (after listening to the delivery driver complain about the company tipping issue) a cooked pepperoni pizza with uncooked cold lunch meat and pineapple toppings tossed on top, with out cheese; and no King Cake but instead we received a frozen molten cake. Paying $52 upfront and hoping that your pizza shows up warm and is what you ordered, without grief from delivery drivers has now become a pipe dream with this company. Needless to say we took a family vote, and feel we have trusted this company with enough of our family dinners to figure it out, and they haven’t.This city has too many amazing restaurants, to settle for what now, appears as express laziness.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
We liked the pizza so much we went back twice! The All Meat Pie was exactly that lots of meat! Very good, not too much sauce and/or cheese. Food came up quickly. Both visits were late night cravings, had a Margherita pizza and an Italian Combo with Chicken wings. Again good pizza, and the wings were nice size and the Kick'in Bourbon was a tasty sauce not hot to me and I don't hot very well so it was perfect! Definitely a stop when you're in the neighborhood!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: All Meat Pizza, Homemade Saucy Chicken Wings, Italian Pie
Mozzarella sticks and a Caesar salad...will definitely go back
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Good/okay pizza..price was a little high for the quality. Although the peanut butter pie was very good.
The pizza was awesome! Not so friendly..They had a group of kids come in, and they were so loud. The employees never said anything to them.The reason for the 2 stars is because our pizza came in a box. They gave us plates to eat off of, but they were greasy, and you could see the food that had been left on it. Like it hadn't even been washed, both of them.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Italian Pie
Food was tasty and quick. Building is a little dated, which adds to the charm but could use a little TLC. Keep the look and vibe, just a deep clean and some touch
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pie, Salad
Portion sizes were exceedingly small for the charge. No bread which was said to be included in menu. I truly hat to criticize. But I cannot wrap my head around how much we paid for such small portions.
Processed frozen chicken - why not just use fresh…the chicken parm tasted like cafeteria foodPricy for what you get-Decent tasting but not worth the price at all
Food: 3
Restaurantji Recommends
Close to hotel. Local joint. Meatball sub, pizza and a couple beers your can't go wrong.
Ordered a 14 inch build your own pizza. Eggplant sausage and seasoned ricotta and it was delicious. Like really good. However we ordered a large Mediterranean salad and barely fed 2 people it was so small. When I called they must asked if it was in a 9x9 takeout container and when I said yes they said that's a large. It's not the container it was the amount that was in it for $15. They just said we'll tell the owner. I just wanted them to charge me for a small. I wasn't asking for anything free. Be careful ordering the large salad, it's not worth the money.
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Italian Pie, Salad
As a first-time customer at The Original Italian Pie, I was blown away by the delightful experience. Let me share why this place deserves every star:1. **Pizza Perfection**: I'm not easily impressed when it comes to pizza, but The Original Italian Pie exceeded my expectations. The **Hawaiian pizza** on **thin crust** was a tropical delight. The balance of sweet pineapple, savory ham, and gooey cheese was spot-on.2. **Cheesy Garlic Bread Bliss**: Brace yourself for the **cheesy garlic bread**—it's a game-changer! The warm, garlicky aroma alone had me salivating. But when I took that first bite, I knew I was in love. The crispy edges, the gooey cheese, and the fragrant garlic—it was like a cheesy hug for my taste buds.3. **Couldn't Stop Eating**: I confess—I ate until I couldn't move. The pizza and garlic bread combo was irresistible. Each bite was a little slice of heaven. I might have even done a happy food dance (don't judge!).5. **Reordering Guaranteed**: If I'm ever back in town, you can bet your last slice that I'll be dialing up The Original Italian Pie for another feast. It's a promise!In summary, if you're craving pizza perfection and cheesy garlic bread dreams, look no further. The Original Italian Pie is where it's at. ?❤️
Food: 5
If you are completely smashed and this is the closest place to your hotel, I imagine it is probably pretty decent. If you aren't you are wasting your
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
They don’t sell pizza by the slice, there chicken parm sandwich and pasta was trash taste like Tyson
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 3