I placed an order for pick up and spent about $70 on 3 apps and 2 chicken parm Sandwiches. I’d give zero stars if I could. Nothing had any taste or flavor. It was awful. The worst food I’ve ever ordered at a pizza place. I asked for hot peppers on the sandwiches and got green bell peppers. You’re in the wrong business if you don’t know the difference.
Gelly Petit
I can’t give zero stars so i give it a one. The food is horrible and pizza was burnt. Also it took a very long time to receive food.
Brock
Got sat, no drink order taken, I guess lost in the rotation of the Wednesday night discount pizza craze
Mark Shaffer
Great Pizza. Cool vibe. Luckily, we went on $8 pizza night!!
Charles Conti
Fun place for kids of all ages!. Great pizza at reasonable prices. Fast and friendly service in a festive atmosphere.
Jesse Mueller
Came to Olde Towne Pizza in Slidell after a Little League game and sat outside on the back patio. The setup was great—fans, lights, music, and a nice open-air vibe that made it a perfect place to relax. Our waitress was friendly and attentive, and service was quick.
We started with the meatball appetizer—delicious. Then we ordered a cheese pizza and a margherita pizza. Both were really, really good—nice large size, great flavor, and exactly what you'd expect from a classic Old Town-style pizza joint.
Definitely a solid spot if you're in the area and craving some quality pizza.
Side note: I’ve submitted nearly 600 reviews, and my photos and videos have over 17 million views on Google Maps. If this helped, give me a follow—it’s always appreciated!
Nancy Valentine
Great little spot. The pizza was great. I had the Caprese salad and I really enjoyed it a lot!
OneHonestReviewer
Okay spot for a quick bite. I tried the garlic parm, bourbon molasses,caribbean jerk, and lemon wings. The garlic parm was good, bourbon molasses could have done with more sauce, and the other 2 flavors were just ok to me.
Ready2 Retire
A great place to go for pizza. We often get a salad and a pizza. Ask what the daily special is since they have some good pizza combinations. The slices are large and enough for a regular appetite. After dinner you can take the kids for ice cream at the soda shop or have a drink in the nearby bars.
Ten Pin
First time trying OTP - was impressed. Good pizza for the price. Crust was a little overdone for a NY style, but I'm not going to hold it against them when this tastes 1000x better than any of the chains. Just have to convince them to ditch that NY Yankees flag!
This place is completely unorganized! I waited nearly two hours, only to receive a half-burnt pizza. To make matters worse, while I was standing in line, another customer walked in after me and was allowed to cut ahead, pay, and leave with their order immediately. I understand the deal is great, but when customer service is this poor—on top of receiving burnt food—it really brings down the whole experience.
Amanda Foster
went to Olde Towne Pizza Company last night… Shoutout to our server, Brennen, cool vibes and great personality! 😎 He made sure we had THE BEST rum punch🍹from Dakota, the pretty and sweet bartender. She definitely knows how to make a drink! And shoutout to whoever was in the kitchen, the calzone and pizza were amazing! 🍕 Thanks for turning on the game for us and listening to us be crazy. 🏀 We will definitely be back! 🫶🏻
Andrew Benfield
We got there about an hour before closing and had our food pretty speedy. We had a good, atentive server named Angel, 4.5/5 for her. Very informative about ingredients, so one of us 4 didn't have an allergic reaction.
We ate, cleaned up a little bit, and put a tip on our table. After we left this restaurant, we walked across the street to put our To-go boxes in the car and walk around a bit.
Upon walking past this establishment, a cook (about 6 feet, glasses, camo ball cap, white shirt, green jacket) came out of the restaurant after closing to confront us about the tip we gave. He tried to say there was no tip, then walked back into the restaurant.
When one of us went in to confront him about it, he went into the back and refused to communicate anything. This is very unprofessional and a massive safety hazard to have a grown man walk up to customers in the middle of the night for a verbal altercation.
I hope that whatever caused this grown man to act this way is resolved, and he does not behave like this in the future.
carter O’Shaughnessy
Took them 40 minutes to bring my food without anyone in the restaurant. They lollygagged in the kitchen and need to lose customers. I hate old town pizza.
Dane Stickney
Avoid. Place has gone down hill. Pizza is OK. Service is a joke. Rude. Long wait.
I placed an order for pick up and spent about $70 on 3 apps and 2 chicken parm
Sandwiches. I’d give zero stars if I could. Nothing had any taste or flavor. It was awful. The worst food I’ve ever ordered at a pizza place. I asked for hot peppers on the sandwiches and got green bell peppers.
You’re in the wrong business if you don’t know the difference.
I can’t give zero stars so i give it a one. The food is horrible and pizza was burnt. Also it took a very long time to receive food.
Got sat, no drink order taken, I guess lost in the rotation of the Wednesday night discount pizza craze
Great Pizza. Cool vibe. Luckily, we went on $8 pizza night!!
Fun place for kids of all ages!. Great pizza at reasonable prices. Fast and friendly service in a festive atmosphere.
Came to Olde Towne Pizza in Slidell after a Little League game and sat outside on the back patio. The setup was great—fans, lights, music, and a nice open-air vibe that made it a perfect place to relax. Our waitress was friendly and attentive, and service was quick.
We started with the meatball appetizer—delicious. Then we ordered a cheese pizza and a margherita pizza. Both were really, really good—nice large size, great flavor, and exactly what you'd expect from a classic Old Town-style pizza joint.
Definitely a solid spot if you're in the area and craving some quality pizza.
Side note: I’ve submitted nearly 600 reviews, and my photos and videos have over 17 million views on Google Maps. If this helped, give me a follow—it’s always appreciated!
Great little spot. The pizza was great. I had the Caprese salad and I really enjoyed it a lot!
Okay spot for a quick bite. I tried the garlic parm, bourbon molasses,caribbean jerk, and lemon wings. The garlic parm was good, bourbon molasses could have done with more sauce, and the other 2 flavors were just ok to me.
A great place to go for pizza. We often get a salad and a pizza. Ask what the daily special is since they have some good pizza combinations. The slices are large and enough for a regular appetite. After dinner you can take the kids for ice cream at the soda shop or have a drink in the nearby bars.
First time trying OTP - was impressed. Good pizza for the price. Crust was a little overdone for a NY style, but I'm not going to hold it against them when this tastes 1000x better than any of the chains. Just have to convince them to ditch that NY Yankees flag!
Restaurantji Recommends
This place is completely unorganized! I waited nearly two hours, only to receive a half-burnt pizza. To make matters worse, while I was standing in line, another customer walked in after me and was allowed to cut ahead, pay, and leave with their order immediately. I understand the deal is great, but when customer service is this poor—on top of receiving burnt food—it really brings down the whole experience.
went to Olde Towne Pizza Company last night… Shoutout to our server, Brennen, cool vibes and great personality! 😎 He made sure we had THE BEST rum punch🍹from Dakota, the pretty and sweet bartender. She definitely knows how to make a drink! And shoutout to whoever was in the kitchen, the calzone and pizza were amazing! 🍕 Thanks for turning on the game for us and listening to us be crazy. 🏀 We will definitely be back! 🫶🏻
We got there about an hour before closing and had our food pretty speedy. We had a good, atentive server named Angel, 4.5/5 for her.
Very informative about ingredients, so one of us 4 didn't have an allergic reaction.
We ate, cleaned up a little bit, and put a tip on our table. After we left this restaurant, we walked across the street to put our To-go boxes in the car and walk around a bit.
Upon walking past this establishment, a cook (about 6 feet, glasses, camo ball cap, white shirt, green jacket) came out of the restaurant after closing to confront us about the tip we gave.
He tried to say there was no tip, then walked back into the restaurant.
When one of us went in to confront him about it, he went into the back and refused to communicate anything.
This is very unprofessional and a massive safety hazard to have a grown man walk up to customers in the middle of the night for a verbal altercation.
I hope that whatever caused this grown man to act this way is resolved, and he does not behave like this in the future.
Took them 40 minutes to bring my food without anyone in the restaurant. They lollygagged in the kitchen and need to lose customers. I hate old town pizza.
Avoid. Place has gone down hill. Pizza is OK. Service is a joke. Rude. Long wait.
Loading...