Antonio's Pizza

31 N Pleasant St, Amherst
(413) 253-0808

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Margaret

Food at this place was outstanding. I went here during lunch break on my drive back to my clinical shift which is a 2 hour drive. Was greeted by Olivia and Bill. Both provided excellent customer service with a smile. Gave great recommendations for pizza and prices were affordable. Olivia was a sweetheart very bubbly and kind energy. Her boss Bill was friendly and made me laugh. I will always return when in Amherst. Best pizza in town!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brittany Morin

Tiny pizza shop with fantastic pizza and terrible service

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 1

Erica Larner

TERRIBLE delivery experience. I had to put my pizza in the oven the second it got here, and it ruined all the toppings. The manager Ashley was rude and condescending. They hide the fact that they use Door dash to make their deliveries and then refuse to refund anything, including just the tip for delivery, when the food is cold and ruined. I didn't pay DoorDash for delivery, I paid Antonios, and they didn't deliver edible food

Food: 1

Service: 1

Savya Virmani

Fantastic pizza. Great topping selection. Run by people who love to be there. I tried slices of: spicy chicken and veggie, pesto with tomato, pesto with tortellini, and a pepperoni sausage. Would recommend everything!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Logan

I usually go to this place a few times a month and will never be back after the service tonight. I called in a pizza 1/2 sausage tortellini 1/2 honey mustard chicken…I had to repeat my order over 10 times - whatever no big deal I’d rather them understand what I want. The call ended with the guy saying it would be 30-45 minutes. I show up 45 minutes later and he claims I hung up on him and he didn’t get my phone number so he couldn’t throw in the pizza… he never asked me for my phone number and said bye. He told me it would take another 30 minutes and smiled in my face. I called back to ask to speak with a manager and he laughed at me. Very very bad service. Very disappointed. Told them not to worry about it and left.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Odette Rakk

Best pizza in Western Massachusetts! The portion is great for the price.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Pedro Quinones

I absolutely love the taco pizza. My favorite and what I order every time.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

S Parent

It's always good, depending on the time and day, be prepared to wait.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 5

Daniel Fox

Decent pizza for a quick bite.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 5

Christian Monterroso

Amazing selection of pizza topping combinations. It's a little pricey, but worth it for me. Enjoyed a slice of seafood (shrimp and lobster) and a slice of steak and mushroom. Delicious.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Seafood Pie

Isaias Rodrigues

Always a favorite and go to place for me. The avocado quesadilla and the black bean avocado are my favorites as a vegetarian. The pineapple chicken and was once my favorite as a youngin

Vegetarian options: Definitely some worthwhile vegetarian options to try: avocado quesadilla and black bean quesadilla. You can thank me now.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Black Bean Avocado, Avocado Quesadilla

Peter Skolnick

Great Pizza! Don't miss it!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

j baker

Went there around 645 pm on 7/7 for a slice theplace was not busy at all this cashier with the pink hair and glasses Olivia announces “ if anyone hasn’t ordered I’ll take you at the counter” I go to the counter she asks me what I want, I pay with a 5 she gives me my change. So now I’m noticing people coming in ordering after me getting their food so I tell her I’ll be right back I gotta go to cvs. I go there come back new people are sitting down eating my slice isn’t ready. So after a couple more people get their food I ask for a refund now she’s “so sorry and says for future reference you have to order by the glass window” I told her I know because I’ve been multiple times and reminded her she specifically told me to order bat the counter and I watched 5 people who came after me order AT the counter and get their food before me. She immediately gets defensive and starts arguing with me saying she would never tell me that etc. so Ramon, who I later was told is manager, comes over and says he’ll “toss a slice in real quick.” Olivia is still trying to argue so I just laugh and told her w.e just give me my money I’m not gonna argue. She tells me “yelling at her won’t make he get my money any faster” (I was 100% not yelling) and said she was trying to calculate what I got. While she’s doing that Ramon puts the slice he warmed up for like 30 seconds on the counter between us so I told her it was a single slice of pepperoni and I paid with a 5 so she tries to hand me $1.06. I told her I wanted my full refund because I lost my appetite and was kinda upset now. So she gives me my money stil defending herself under breath shaking her head. Idk if it was because I was the only black person in there or if it was too hot in there with no a/c or what but it was terrible customer service. Not to mention they don’t take good care of the place I noticed flies, dirty tables, no a/c,can barely turn around in the place without hitting a chair, I get it’s a college town but school has been out for months and they are way less busy.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Matteo Recchi

Pizza is amazing!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

J_perez

There pizza is amazing but I had been calling for 5 weeks for the seafood pizza I get it they said they don't have it every weekend I'm coming from Springfield Massachusetts finally today was yes the seafood pizza is in I said good let me get the large thinking again it's the seafood pizza to get there open it and it's a shrimp taco pizza I paid 27 for something unfortunately I will not eat I was specific on the phone to the lady I spoke too ?

Recommended dishes: Seafood Pie

Loading...