Re The worst ice cream I have ever had. They call this creamy? You can soften it and it’s still not creamy. This ice cream is so grainy it’s like sand. The price is ridiculous. If they were to churn it slower it might be palatable. Snows ice cream is also lousy. Every time I have bought it , it has had ice crystals in it. One star is to many.
Paul Copeland
Tried to visit during hours listed as open on Google Maps but it was closed.
Shawn Portwood
I changed this from one star to three stars. The hours showed OPEN on Google so I clicked to place an order and the ordering system defaulted to the current time that I placed my order. I ordered, they charged my card and I walked over only to find it not open. Nobody there, no lights on, nothing. Come to find out that the ordering system defaulted to the following day which apparently they will be open then. They promptly reached out and refunded me. Which I appreciate. However, because of the frustration I am keeping this as 3-star for now.
Kelley Bennett
Just bought a pint of the maple cream from Atkins Farm. ATE THE WHOLE THING IN ONE SITTING.
Anthony Schiappa
Delicious ice cream. Lots of assortments of flavors and options. They also sell smoothies and other fun items. It's super quality ice cream and not like your standard Friendly's you'd get at a supermarket. I stop here every time I get the chance while in Amherst! Staff are also friendly and helpful. Plenty of seating. Parking is street only.
Bob M.
Delicious ice cream in a quaint downtown setting. Prices are fair and service is good. The store is clean and there is ample seating.
Rizwan shinwari
it is a wonderful ice cream, slightly cheaper then others.
Heather Gentry
Oh my gosh the ice cream was waaay too good. Many choices, very busy Sat afternoon, staff was awesome. Thank you
Steve James
A couple of wonderfully creative flavors, in addition to many great standards. Expect a wait, one you'd make again.
Good stuff. My partner is allergic to nuts/treenuts and the lady behind the coubter went extra step to make sure nothing was contaminated for her.
Le G.
I purchased a custom ice cream cake from here a couple days ago. They made it exactly the way I asked them to. It tasted amazing and everyone who tried it agreed with me! I also come here often for some scoops of ice cream or a milkshake and have always loved it. They have some unique and tasty flavors, all of which I have loved so far. The service here is great too, they let me try whatever flavors I was interested in tasting. Overall, I always have a great experience here and I will definitely be back.
John F.
Great ice cream. Always love coming here for a sweet treat. They have a wide variety of delicious flavors and they let you try whatever you want
Alex Clavel
Came in yesterday. There was only 1 person working, so I waited about 30 minutes before I even got to order—and the store wasn’t even busy. I completely understand being understaffed, but their system for taking and filling orders is really inefficient. People who came in after me got their orders taken and served before me. I finally ordered my strawberry smoothie, got it 10 minutes later, and it had no taste. Literally tasted like nothing. Their ice cream is good, but terrible service—and don’t order a smoothie.
Aman J.
This place serves people completely out of line and the workers generally stand around doing nothing. When they did get to us, the $8 small cup of ice cream had whipped cream that had gone bad. Insomnia had better service and food than this.
I didn't go to Barts Ice Cream.
Re The worst ice cream I have ever had. They call this creamy? You can soften it and it’s still not creamy. This ice cream is so grainy it’s like sand. The price is ridiculous. If they were to churn it slower it might be palatable. Snows ice cream is also lousy. Every time I have bought it , it has had ice crystals in it. One star is to many.
Tried to visit during hours listed as open on Google Maps but it was closed.
I changed this from one star to three stars. The hours showed OPEN on Google so I clicked to place an order and the ordering system defaulted to the current time that I placed my order. I ordered, they charged my card and I walked over only to find it not open. Nobody there, no lights on, nothing. Come to find out that the ordering system defaulted to the following day which apparently they will be open then. They promptly reached out and refunded me. Which I appreciate. However, because of the frustration I am keeping this as 3-star for now.
Just bought a pint of the maple cream from Atkins Farm. ATE THE WHOLE THING IN ONE SITTING.
Delicious ice cream. Lots of assortments of flavors and options. They also sell smoothies and other fun items. It's super quality ice cream and not like your standard Friendly's you'd get at a supermarket. I stop here every time I get the chance while in Amherst! Staff are also friendly and helpful. Plenty of seating. Parking is street only.
Delicious ice cream in a quaint downtown setting. Prices are fair and service is good. The store is clean and there is ample seating.
it is a wonderful ice cream, slightly cheaper then others.
Oh my gosh the ice cream was waaay too good. Many choices, very busy Sat afternoon, staff was awesome. Thank you
A couple of wonderfully creative flavors, in addition to many great standards. Expect a wait, one you'd make again.
Restaurantji Recommends
Good stuff. My partner is allergic to nuts/treenuts and the lady behind the coubter went extra step to make sure nothing was contaminated for her.
I purchased a custom ice cream cake from here a couple days ago. They made it exactly the way I asked them to. It tasted amazing and everyone who tried it agreed with me! I also come here often for some scoops of ice cream or a milkshake and have always loved it. They have some unique and tasty flavors, all of which I have loved so far. The service here is great too, they let me try whatever flavors I was interested in tasting. Overall, I always have a great experience here and I will definitely be back.
Great ice cream. Always love coming here for a sweet treat. They have a wide variety of delicious flavors and they let you try whatever you want
Came in yesterday. There was only 1 person working, so I waited about 30 minutes before I even got to order—and the store wasn’t even busy. I completely understand being understaffed, but their system for taking and filling orders is really inefficient. People who came in after me got their orders taken and served before me. I finally ordered my strawberry smoothie, got it 10 minutes later, and it had no taste. Literally tasted like nothing. Their ice cream is good, but terrible service—and don’t order a smoothie.
This place serves people completely out of line and the workers generally stand around doing nothing. When they did get to us, the $8 small cup of ice cream had whipped cream that had gone bad. Insomnia had better service and food than this.