I ordered 4 dozen cupcakes for my son’s graduation party. Easy curb side pick up, friendly owner and really good cupcakes.
Jovonsia Taylor
Very disappointed with the quality of this bakeries product. The brownies were dry and unflavored. The pie had no form to it, making it soupy and incredibly hard to serve to guests. Out of everything ordered, the carrot cake and yellow cake (pictured) were good. The cost is expensive which is insulting due to the quality of the products I ordered. Although the cakes had a descent flavor, they were on the dry side. I’m not a resident of MA and I chose this bakery for their 4.9 rating. That was truly misleading. Her customer service was very good however and she accommodated us and delivered our order to our hotel when we were unable to arrive in time for our curbside pickup.
Adele Paquin
Lemon Bakery made me an incredible pair of gluten-free/vegan birthday cakes - one carrot cake, one chocolate with raspberry! Everyone commented about the lovely edible flower decoration, and how delicious the cakes were (including non-vegan and non-gf folks). Rori got right back to me when I reached out with a question. 10/10 recommend this gem of a bakery <3
Delia McHale
Ordered a lemon cake with raspberry jam back in April for my mom''s birthday and I couldn't come up with something negative to say about it if I tried. Both the cake and the packaging it came in were beautiful. The cake was delicious and exactly what my mom wanted. Pickup was very easy and stress free. I have lived in Amherst on and off my whole life and have never found a better cake in the area or elsewhere for that matter. If you're looking for something special, delicious, and made with care and expertise I cannot recommend Lemon Bakery enough.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lemon Celebration Cake
Willow L
Rori was incredibly accommodating and pleasant over email and made my dad a delicious and beautiful carrot cake. Carrot cake is his favorite, but not mine at all, and I still thought it was delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
cynthia meadows
Wonderful cakes, made to order. Absolutely delicious.
Vegetarian options: Many of the cakes can be made vegan, too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
Rita Liberti
Got a "flight of cakes" today from Lemon Bakery today for my birthday! These cute "lunch box" cakes are extraordinary. The hummingbird cake (can't believe it was even on the menu, since few people even know what it is) is the best I've had (and I've had some). The raspberry icing on the made-to-order chocolate/raspberry cake tasted like I was eating fresh berries. I didn't know what to expect with the apple crisp cake - it was so delicious. The coconut cake gets the "most adorable" award for sure. Prices were more than reasonable and order/and pick up was seamless. I will be back - long before my next birthday!
Sarah Wennemyr
Delicious and moist cake ? thank you!! cant wait order again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Make Your Own Cake
Kevin Gibbons
Anything if you like it or have a sweet tooth or massive sugar rush
Marei
I have ordered a surprise cake for my husband and it was absolutely amazing. The PB&J cake had a perfect taste and texture. Order, payment, contact, delivery - everything without any issues. I would definitely order anytime again.
I have ordered a surprise cake for my husband and it was absolutely amazing. The PB&J cake had a perfect taste and texture. Order, payment, contact, delivery - everything without any issues. I would definitely order anytime again.
3BigTacos
It was trash we thought it was cornbread with raspberry syrup. It was for my sisters graduation and she cried. Thanks a lot.
A Lundeberg
I live in Georgia and my son is a UMass student. Wanted to order a cake for his 21st and stumbled across this bakery. Reviews were good so decided to order. The cake was amazing! We ordered the Lemon celebration and everyone enjoyed it. Easy to order and very easy to pick up. Would highly recommend.
Eleonora Mattiacci
We ordered a blackout cake in May 2023. Ordering was a breeze, and so was pick up. A fantastic cake: moist, flavorful, with wonderful texture. They are pros at Lemon Bakery! Some of the very, very best in the whole Pioneer valley. 10 out of 10. We already look forward to placing our next order.
I ordered 4 dozen cupcakes for my son’s graduation party. Easy curb side pick up, friendly owner and really good cupcakes.
Very disappointed with the quality of this bakeries product. The brownies were dry and unflavored. The pie had no form to it, making it soupy and incredibly hard to serve to guests. Out of everything ordered, the carrot cake and yellow cake (pictured) were good. The cost is expensive which is insulting due to the quality of the products I ordered. Although the cakes had a descent flavor, they were on the dry side. I’m not a resident of MA and I chose this bakery for their 4.9 rating. That was truly misleading. Her customer service was very good however and she accommodated us and delivered our order to our hotel when we were unable to arrive in time for our curbside pickup.
Lemon Bakery made me an incredible pair of gluten-free/vegan birthday cakes - one carrot cake, one chocolate with raspberry! Everyone commented about the lovely edible flower decoration, and how delicious the cakes were (including non-vegan and non-gf folks). Rori got right back to me when I reached out with a question. 10/10 recommend this gem of a bakery <3
Ordered a lemon cake with raspberry jam back in April for my mom''s birthday and I couldn't come up with something negative to say about it if I tried. Both the cake and the packaging it came in were beautiful. The cake was delicious and exactly what my mom wanted. Pickup was very easy and stress free. I have lived in Amherst on and off my whole life and have never found a better cake in the area or elsewhere for that matter. If you're looking for something special, delicious, and made with care and expertise I cannot recommend Lemon Bakery enough.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lemon Celebration Cake
Rori was incredibly accommodating and pleasant over email and made my dad a delicious and beautiful carrot cake. Carrot cake is his favorite, but not mine at all, and I still thought it was delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wonderful cakes, made to order. Absolutely delicious.
Vegetarian options: Many of the cakes can be made vegan, too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
Got a "flight of cakes" today from Lemon Bakery today for my birthday! These cute "lunch box" cakes are extraordinary. The hummingbird cake (can't believe it was even on the menu, since few people even know what it is) is the best I've had (and I've had some). The raspberry icing on the made-to-order chocolate/raspberry cake tasted like I was eating fresh berries. I didn't know what to expect with the apple crisp cake - it was so delicious. The coconut cake gets the "most adorable" award for sure. Prices were more than reasonable and order/and pick up was seamless. I will be back - long before my next birthday!
Delicious and moist cake ? thank you!! cant wait order again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Make Your Own Cake
Anything if you like it or have a sweet tooth or massive sugar rush
I have ordered a surprise cake for my husband and it was absolutely amazing. The PB&J cake had a perfect taste and texture. Order, payment, contact, delivery - everything without any issues. I would definitely order anytime again.
Restaurantji Recommends
I have ordered a surprise cake for my husband and it was absolutely amazing. The PB&J cake had a perfect taste and texture. Order, payment, contact, delivery - everything without any issues. I would definitely order anytime again.
It was trash we thought it was cornbread with raspberry syrup. It was for my sisters graduation and she cried. Thanks a lot.
I live in Georgia and my son is a UMass student. Wanted to order a cake for his 21st and stumbled across this bakery. Reviews were good so decided to order. The cake was amazing! We ordered the Lemon celebration and everyone enjoyed it. Easy to order and very easy to pick up. Would highly recommend.
We ordered a blackout cake in May 2023. Ordering was a breeze, and so was pick up. A fantastic cake: moist, flavorful, with wonderful texture. They are pros at Lemon Bakery! Some of the very, very best in the whole Pioneer valley. 10 out of 10. We already look forward to placing our next order.
I'd give this place 6 out of 5 Stars if I could
Loading...