Sibie's Pizza

481 West St, Amherst
(413) 256-6100

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Ken Kleinman

Great New York style pizza-- this from a born and bred New Yorker. Plenty of toppings to choose from. The folks who work there are very friendly. There are a couple of outside places to sit, but nowhere inside.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Usherbonnie

I’ve tried several different listed vegan pizzas, as well as ones where I added the toppings. Have had the Buffalo tempeh and fried tofu. All excellent and I buy extra vegan ranch as they make it so well. Takeaway only, but well worth it. Even my non-vegan family really enjoy the vegan pizza and apps!

Skylar Fried

Incredible Pizza

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jayce J

The nicest people with the greatest service and great quality. Sibie's sustained me through my four years of college and I continue to order from them regularly years after graduation. Tons of toppings and great choices for dietary restrictions. Truly the best.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Samar Misra

Love the vegan pizza and tofu nuggets here. Florentine is amazing style. Adam and Erin are remarkable in hospitality and service. Glad I came here and will spread the word.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

oliviaiarossi

Excellent service, amazing staff and accommodating menu. Their Buffalo tempeh is delicious, along with all of their pizzas/subs and their homemade vegan ranch is to die for!

Matt Smith

Excellent pizza spot. Homemade blue cheese is the best around.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Devin Burg

Amazing pizza, it took them 3 hours to deliver it.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Vegan Cheese, Slice of Cheese Pizza

Grace

Absolutely excellent pizza! Vegan and regular pizzas that can’t be beat anywhere else in the area. I can’t go a month without their food

Vegetarian options: Great vegan options

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

mushroomhater

Was reasonably good. Had vegan options, but were out of some I ordered, which they called to notify me about. Pretty expensive ($20 for pizza and $2 for a tiny side of vegan ranch). Still, happy to have any vegan options at all since I've been craving pizza with cheese. Way too expensive to justify regular purchasing, but I will eat here again in the next few months.

Zachary Figoli

The best! Such nice staff and incredible pizza. Love the wings!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Harrison Raycroft

I have been going here a few times a month for the past couple years and I can definitely say it’s a great spot. Good portions, good quality, and as far as take out prices go I actually think it’s really reasonable. I get a large sub, large fry, and a drink most of the time and it comes out to about $15. Also they have great customer service. Highly recommend this spot it’s a kind of a hidden gem in the area.

Katherine Richter

This is one of the best places for vegan pizza. The dough was amazing and the vegan cheese was delicious. I got the basil and tomato and got another to bring home?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: French Fries

Rachel548

We ordered delivery to our hotel one night while in Hadley. I ordered two pizzas, bread sticks, and two pints of ice cream online. They called almost immediately to say they were out of one of the flavors of ice cream and which I would like as a replacement. Delivery was also about 10 mins earlier than expected! Pizzas were both fantastic, along with the bread sticks. Very pleasant experience with them and great pizza!

Debbie Jennison

Great vegan pizza!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...