Centerville Pie Company

I bought a frozen shepherds pie from Centerville Pie CO at Publix. I followed the instructions on the box on how to cook it. Instructions set to cook it for 90 minutes, but it was not done so I cooked it for another 30 minutes while I was waiting for it to be cooked. I start reading the reviews and I got a little scared. Must of the reviews were bad, but to my surprise it was good. I’m not a big fan of shepherds pie but this one I liked. My husband liked it too. I’m pretty sure we will be having it for dinner again. I also bought a chicken pot pie. I hope it is as good as the shepherds pie.

Food: 5

I haven’t been there to comment on their service or atmosphere, but I will say their large home style thanksgiving turkey pie is hands down the best I have ever had ! The perfect chunks of turkey were bite size and nice and moist. You could literally taste every flavor of all the thanksgiving fixings even the cranberry ! The crust was amazing and to be honest I’m a pretty serious crust snob! It was light and crispy with a nice flavor. The crust tasted like they used a broth to make it . I seriously highly recommend this pie !!!

Food: 5

The pies are bland the gravy is tasteless.tho shepherd pie was so bland I bought a container of gravy it really sucked no flavor whatsoever the small chicken pot pie was a little better not not the greatest

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 5

Chicken was not tender.. minimal amount of meat.. dark meat mixed in.. very small pieces of meat.. will never buy again

Food: 2

I literally never do this, but I had to look you guys up because I bought a chicken pot pie from Publix for a BOGO, and I literally couldn’t eat it because it was so salty. I have had Marie Callender that was ten times better. No pretty box can make this garbage taste good. I literally threw it out and had to resort to box macaroni and cheese, and that’s way better, if that tells you anything. I would donate the other one to charity but I would not want to subject anyone to that

I purchased a frozen chicken pot pie from Publix. It took a lot longer than the 90 minutes to bake the frozen pie. Also, the pot pie was just ok and the dark meat in the pie was so bad that i gave it to my dog. Sorry, i was hoping to love it.

Purchased 2 boxes, Chicken Mini Pies at Market Basket. Box claims chicken blended in gravy. 4 pies not a drop of gravy on any. Crust was good, chicken was dry . Purchased the large Shepard's pie in the past, always good.

We were very disappointed with our recent chicken pie. Tiny pieces of chicken and very bland overall. Stark difference from past pies.

Love the cherry pie!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

My son was desperately craving a key lime pie, so we visited the shop and were happy to find one. We got a small peach pie as well for my daughter. The staff was friendly and helpful, but the prices were very high, so I had high expectations for the pies we purchased. The key lime was okay, but I was shocked by how bad the peach pie was. It was definitely undercooked, and it had very few peaches in it. The peaches it did have had no flavor, and I'm pretty sure they came from a can. Really disappointing.

Food: 2

We ordered the buffalo chicken pie from Goldbelly and it is a five star experience. With that said I won’t order this same one again, but I will try others.

The pie crust is buttery and flakey and perfect. Like wow amazingly good. The filling is the problem.

When I want buffalo chicken I was sauce and tang. This has the flavor of buffalo chicken but not enough sauce and a lot of cumin. It was more like buffalo chicken curry than buffalo chicken. Which isn’t a bad thing, just not what I was hoping for. I did enjoy it and am happy with it.

If they would add a jar of sauce or a drizzle to pour over the finished product it would have been perfect. I just heated up a left over piece and today there isn’t as much cumin. Maybe it was just the piece I had yesterday.

I would definitely try their other pies, especially if they do dessert pies because the crust is incredible and they clearly know what they’re doing.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Buffalo Chicken Pie – Absolutely Delicious!
My husband and I just tried the buffalo chicken pie from The Modern Milkman, made by Centerville Pie Company and wow, what a treat! The first thing we noticed was the quality of the chicken real, tender pieces that tasted homemade. The crust was beautifully flaky with a subtle sweetness that balanced the spicy buffalo flavor perfectly.
There was plenty of buffalo sauce, which we loved, and we added a little blue cheese dressing on top highly recommend! It was the perfect combo of spicy, savory, and creamy.
We’ll definitely be buying this again, and we’re already looking forward to trying the breakfast pie next!

Food: 5

Pecan pie was great! Looking forward to the Thanksgiving Pie we got. The two employees working were very kind.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Best pies! Best part of the Cape for us! Love chicken pies, peach and cherry!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Haven't been to the location, but I got the pie for an easy meal on nights when we're too tired to cook. I was expecting processed meat cubes and soggy veggies. This was not that. Actual chicken meat, fresh veggies, and excellent gravy. For once, it looked exactly like the photo on the box. I'm usually a home cooked meat and potato kind of guy and avoid frozen boxed food, but this will be my go to easy meal from now on!
11/10!!

Food: 5