Plum Tomato Pizzeria

The food is okay, typical town pizza place. Whatever time they tell you to pick up your food plan on hanging around for at least 15 minutes longer than they say. Tonight it was 25 minutes. We got a meatball calzone there were hardly any meatballs in it and the dough wasn't cooked all the way.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 1

Fantastic food and everyone who works there is so kind! They make out of this world gluten free pizzas and their gourmet grilled cheese is delicious.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I love the chicken broccoli Alfredo, the best !

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Good pizza n salads

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great place to get a delicious and fresh pizza, the also have calzones and sandwiches too. They have a great variety to choose from, I would definitely recommend stopping by and giving them a try, you won't be disappointed.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Plum tomato has become our go to take out spot. They have lots of options and everything is delicious. When ordering online, they actually read the comments, which a lot of places do not. When we placed our order tonight, we mentioned a peanut allergy. One of the items we ordered contained almonds, which we knew about and wasn't an issue. But out of precaution they put the almonds in a separate container on the side. As a family with allergies, we appreciate the extra care when preparing food.

Very fresh food - excellent salads, chicken salad sandwich & chicken stir fry (peppers, mushroom & onion with provolone) sandwich! such a gem of a local restaurant. They have friendly and accommodating staff. We should have come in sooner!

This place is solid. The crust is crisp but still has a nice chew, and the sauce and cheese actually taste like they care. The pepperoni is a standout — just the right amount and cooked perfectly.

It’s a chill, no-frills spot. Service is friendly, and the vibe is relaxed. It can get busy sometimes, but the wait usually isn’t too bad.

If you just want good, classic pizza without the gimmicks, Pretty Good Pizza delivers. Simple, satisfying, and definitely worth coming back for.

Best food in town! Great staff.

I loved my Greek salad at Plum Tomato! It was carefully presented in a large ceramic salad bowl and was filled with fresh greens (not Iceberg lettuce, thankfully), a variety of crisp vegetables and just the right amount of feta cheese. A nice piece of pita bread and Greek dressing on the side completed the yummy meal. I enjoyed every sumptuous bite! 🥰

Food is always great, restaurant is clean and staff is friendly. The owner is a great guy who cares about the quality of his product.

They honestly have the best takeout that you can get! Sauces are all made from scratch and you can tell almost all the food is. Vast menu and the staff is amazing! Highly recommend,.

Best we’ve had when it comes to pizza and subs. Unsure why I can’t select more stars!

First time ordering from here and it did not disappoint! Front staff were amazing and efficient. We ordered the BBQ chicken pizza, chicken broccoli alfredo and some appetizers. Everything was amazing, highly recommend!

I ordered the Chicken bacon and ranch pizza and it was phenomenal, the lady working there was super nice and the service was quick