Plum Tomato Pizzeria

This place is solid. The crust is crisp but still has a nice chew, and the sauce and cheese actually taste like they care. The pepperoni is a standout — just the right amount and cooked perfectly.

It’s a chill, no-frills spot. Service is friendly, and the vibe is relaxed. It can get busy sometimes, but the wait usually isn’t too bad.

If you just want good, classic pizza without the gimmicks, Pretty Good Pizza delivers. Simple, satisfying, and definitely worth coming back for.

Best food in town! Great staff.

I loved my Greek salad at Plum Tomato! It was carefully presented in a large ceramic salad bowl and was filled with fresh greens (not Iceberg lettuce, thankfully), a variety of crisp vegetables and just the right amount of feta cheese. A nice piece of pita bread and Greek dressing on the side completed the yummy meal. I enjoyed every sumptuous bite! 🥰

Food is always great, restaurant is clean and staff is friendly. The owner is a great guy who cares about the quality of his product.

They honestly have the best takeout that you can get! Sauces are all made from scratch and you can tell almost all the food is. Vast menu and the staff is amazing! Highly recommend,.

Best we’ve had when it comes to pizza and subs. Unsure why I can’t select more stars!

First time ordering from here and it did not disappoint! Front staff were amazing and efficient. We ordered the BBQ chicken pizza, chicken broccoli alfredo and some appetizers. Everything was amazing, highly recommend!

I ordered the Chicken bacon and ranch pizza and it was phenomenal, the lady working there was super nice and the service was quick

Place is killer. Great prices great food.

Just ordered two special order pizzas for delivery. Driver was incredible and the pizzas were freaking delicious. Thank you!!!

Top tier pizza and subs. After searching for years in this town, this is the one. My whole family has enjoyed everything we've bought here. It's cleaner than most pizza places. It's cheaper than most pizza places. It's much better food than the surrounding places. They've earned my business.

Kid-friendliness: Good kids menu. Kids meals come with a juice.

Wheelchair accessibility: Accessible.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Italian, Pepperoni Pizza

This was the 1st time I ate at this place. The GF pizza looked great and the mozzarella sticks were tasty but I asked for a buffalo chicken quesadilla and got just chicken no buffalo sauce. That was disappointing.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Ordered a chicken parm pasta dish.
A very generous plate. for most people it's 2 meals easy.
Came with a really nice artisan garlic bread super soft great for dipping in that sauce.
Sweet potatoes fries,,,yum
Fast and friendly service.Stop in and share the love✌️

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

We just had this pizza for the first time tonight. It was absolutely delicious. We got cheese and bacon waffle fries and garlic parmesan bread sticks as well. Everything was fabulous and super fast delivery also. The girl on the phone was so helpful and friendly too. We will definitely be back!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fries, Pepperoni Pizza

We tried the chicken Sriracha pizza it was awsome ! Also the sauce for the marinara is good. Will have to order a plain cheese to give a true test. But we look forward to ordering again. Also delivery time wasn't bad either.