Best pesto pizza i ever had and the service is great as well.
Kai Moonlite Davis
Mario's is the best pizza in Boston hands up !
either if its a full pie or a few slices Mario's food will not disappoint you !
Asher P
Probably controversial but I genuinely think this is the best slice of pizza in Boston, undoubtedly JP
Benjamin Alonso
visited this past week, delicious Pizza, great Service, - Will for sure come again !!
Ryan Fite
Phenomenal pizza, hard working crew. Well worth the wait.
Maura Lyons
Really delicious pizza!! Can’t go wrong!
Yvia Pulido
I’ve been a loyal customer of this restaurant as of recent due to my food blogging and reviews, always raving about the food and recommending it to others. Unfortunately, after today’s experience, I can no longer say the same.
I placed an order on DoorDash for delivery, and when the pizza arrived, it was in complete disarray. I called the restaurant to reorder directly from Mario's, intending to pay again but this time bypassing DoorDash. As I spoke with the person who answered the phone, I could hear the owner, Mario, yelling in the background that I would “have to pay again.” I had no issue with paying again, but I was frustrated that this miscommunication had occurred.
I went to the restaurant to pick up the pizza myself. As a loyal customer who has enjoyed the food before, I was determined to resolve the issue. I brought the destroyed pizza with me to show the owner and asked for a replacement, explaining that I was happy to pay for it again. Instead of being met with understanding, Mario began yelling at me once more and told me to leave his restaurant. I calmly explained that I had driven all the way there, and I intended to get my pizza. However, I was treated rudely and disrespectfully, having to wait for another pizza and enduring harsh treatment.
As a lifelong resident of Jamaica Plain, I was shocked and appalled by how I was treated. No paying customer should ever be treated this way, especially over a third party mistake. To be publicly berated by Mario in front of his staff and other customers was completely unacceptable. I waited over 15 minutes for a replacement, and the whole experience was entirely unpleasant.
Added a photo to show I called at 9:18pm to reorder my pizza and pay again. He had his staff call me back at 9:23pm where Mario was again yelling in the background. This is what I heard as the customer. I walked in at 9:25pm. Did not get the food until well after 9:38pm. When I called at 9:18pm I was told the pizza will be done in 10min as he was informing the chef. The owner Mario made me wait there after berating me in front of other customers and staff members. As a food reviewer who had reviewed over 50 establishments I’ll say Great food terrible customer service. Order online to not have to deal staff and owner during hectic hours.
Lesser Birds
Best pizza in JP and one of the best in Boston. In a city known for sub-par pizza, a legit pizzeria will stand out and this place brings IT. A literal savior to the area. Mario's has RISEN. (Rec the veggie or fig*****)
Hailey
Worth a trip on the T to JP just for this pizza. Small place with 3 stools to sit so grab your pizza and find somewhere to eat it. Got the Salsiccia pizza and the pesto sauce was delicious and pizza was cooked well. no soggy slice. It was a 15ish minute wait
Heading there right now!!
Best pesto pizza i ever had and the service is great as well.
Mario's is the best pizza in Boston hands up !
either if its a full pie or a few slices Mario's food will not disappoint you !
Probably controversial but I genuinely think this is the best slice of pizza in Boston, undoubtedly JP
visited this past week, delicious Pizza, great Service, - Will for sure come again !!
Phenomenal pizza, hard working crew. Well worth the wait.
Really delicious pizza!! Can’t go wrong!
I’ve been a loyal customer of this restaurant as of recent due to my food blogging and reviews, always raving about the food and recommending it to others. Unfortunately, after today’s experience, I can no longer say the same.
I placed an order on DoorDash for delivery, and when the pizza arrived, it was in complete disarray. I called the restaurant to reorder directly from Mario's, intending to pay again but this time bypassing DoorDash. As I spoke with the person who answered the phone, I could hear the owner, Mario, yelling in the background that I would “have to pay again.” I had no issue with paying again, but I was frustrated that this miscommunication had occurred.
I went to the restaurant to pick up the pizza myself. As a loyal customer who has enjoyed the food before, I was determined to resolve the issue. I brought the destroyed pizza with me to show the owner and asked for a replacement, explaining that I was happy to pay for it again. Instead of being met with understanding, Mario began yelling at me once more and told me to leave his restaurant. I calmly explained that I had driven all the way there, and I intended to get my pizza. However, I was treated rudely and disrespectfully, having to wait for another pizza and enduring harsh treatment.
As a lifelong resident of Jamaica Plain, I was shocked and appalled by how I was treated. No paying customer should ever be treated this way, especially over a third party mistake. To be publicly berated by Mario in front of his staff and other customers was completely unacceptable. I waited over 15 minutes for a replacement, and the whole experience was entirely unpleasant.
Added a photo to show I called at 9:18pm to reorder my pizza and pay again. He had his staff call me back at 9:23pm where Mario was again yelling in the background. This is what I heard as the customer. I walked in at 9:25pm. Did not get the food until well after 9:38pm. When I called at 9:18pm I was told the pizza will be done in 10min as he was informing the chef. The owner Mario made me wait there after berating me in front of other customers and staff members. As a food reviewer who had reviewed over 50 establishments I’ll say Great food terrible customer service. Order online to not have to deal staff and owner during hectic hours.
Best pizza in JP and one of the best in Boston. In a city known for sub-par pizza, a legit pizzeria will stand out and this place brings IT. A literal savior to the area. Mario's has RISEN.
(Rec the veggie or fig*****)
Worth a trip on the T to JP just for this pizza. Small place with 3 stools to sit so grab your pizza and find somewhere to eat it. Got the Salsiccia pizza and the pesto sauce was delicious and pizza was cooked well. no soggy slice. It was a 15ish minute wait
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Best takeout pizza in the area, no question.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This pizza is INSANE! Drop in for a slice 🤤.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pizza in JP. They make it easy to customize your pizza and they have some great options available. The greco is our standard.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Piri-Piri Chicken Pizza - Large
A welcome addition to the neighborhood. Delicious slices. Pricy though
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good pizza and nice people, not much else one needs in life. Piripiri chicken pizza slapped.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...