The ice cream was great! It was thick, creamy and they gave you a good size amount. However, (I apologize for a lack of better words) the big older looking woman with darker pink hair was impatient and was giving me a foul attitude. Once she finished rushing my father through his order, and I began with mine she cut me off before I could finish my sentence with “what size?” + attitude. I politely told her I would’ve told her my size if she’d let me finish getting the words “two scoops” out after waffle cone. The same pink haired, big woman then proceeded to make four other people’s order behind mine and then she gave me a hot cone which melted my ice cream and turned the cone into mush (fyi, I watched this other girl make a waffle cone and let it cool.. the big woman purposely chose to do that). I couldn’t finish it because it was so gross. It’s not packed like a god damn Starbucks at 7am, you can chill out. You work at an ice cream parlor so it’s cold enough to chill out right? ..Sorry I’m a little pissy because I’m taking forever to write this damn review with sticky fingers.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
Duke “Galland” B
Ice cream was good and the prices were very reasonable.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Blaine W
First off, the ice cream is amazing. I got the pumpkin Oreo and was blown away by the flavor and creaminess of the ice cream. The lady working the counter was very nice…
HOWEVER! I kindly requested to use the WiFi since my cell service was not allowing my picture of the menu to go through to my family group chat. I literally wanted to buy more ice cream. But, the lady working the counter explained that they don’t allow use of the WiFi. It was the business’ loss since I wasn’t able to order ice cream for my family.
Definitely will go back just for how good the ice cream was, but I thought it was strange to now allow use of the WiFi for paying customers…
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Andrew Bennett
I've never had Cranberry Crunch before. It's my new favorite flavor!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mary Delano
Excellent
Kathie Kelly
Love this place!!!! Their ice cream is to die for!?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Homemade Waffle Cone
Ethan Neal
Disclaimer: read this review with a grain of salt. This was my favorite ice cream place when I was a kid and I have a lot of great memories here. including sitting at the window eating ice cream and saw my friend rear end a car. You might ask why he didn't break in time... Well he was head banging of course. (A form of distracted driving before cellphones existed) Soo ya a lot of great memories
Review: The place is awesome!
AJ Mulvey
Best of the best!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chrissy O
We have been going to the Whistle Stop regularly for over a year now and we love it! The owner and staff are very friendly and the service is quick. Prices are comparable to other ice cream places on the cape, and you get great portions. Ice cream is delicious and my husband raves about the waffle cones year round (says they’re the best he’s ever had). They also have a fridge full of yummy looking ice cream cakes and treats for sale. We do wish that the hours were open a little later during the off season as we sometimes aren’t able to make it in time after dinner, but absolutely recommend the Whistle Stop.
THIS is the homemade ice cream I'd been searching for all week!! Most of the places we'd been going to all week just resell pre-made Hershey's or other brands you can just get at the store, but you can taste the delicious difference between Whistle's and the others'. The service was also excellent, and the prices were very clear, unlike at other spots. Between the two of us, these were our thoughts on the 4 flavors we tried...Vanilla: 8/10 (vanilla flavor could have been stronger)Coffee Heath Bar: 8.5/10 (says it's super strong coffee flavor, but even kid's would like this; it's like the sweetest latte with bits of toffee)Chocolate PB: 9/10Almond Joy: 7/10 (not as coconutty as I'd want; the coconut flavor was super faint)We'll be back next time we're on The Cape!!
Cheryl Mann
Great homemade ice cream
Myles Walsh
Family favorite for decades!
Christine Benjamin
Great homemade ice cream! Good variety of flavors.
Steve
Great place to eat there but some workers that worked there are very mean and rude need to learn manners grow up seriously I dont care what u think of me steve f.
The ice cream was great! It was thick, creamy and they gave you a good size amount. However, (I apologize for a lack of better words) the big older looking woman with darker pink hair was impatient and was giving me a foul attitude. Once she finished rushing my father through his order, and I began with mine she cut me off before I could finish my sentence with “what size?” + attitude. I politely told her I would’ve told her my size if she’d let me finish getting the words “two scoops” out after waffle cone. The same pink haired, big woman then proceeded to make four other people’s order behind mine and then she gave me a hot cone which melted my ice cream and turned the cone into mush (fyi, I watched this other girl make a waffle cone and let it cool.. the big woman purposely chose to do that). I couldn’t finish it because it was so gross. It’s not packed like a god damn Starbucks at 7am, you can chill out. You work at an ice cream parlor so it’s cold enough to chill out right? ..Sorry I’m a little pissy because I’m taking forever to write this damn review with sticky fingers.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
Ice cream was good and the prices were very reasonable.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
First off, the ice cream is amazing. I got the pumpkin Oreo and was blown away by the flavor and creaminess of the ice cream. The lady working the counter was very nice…
HOWEVER! I kindly requested to use the WiFi since my cell service was not allowing my picture of the menu to go through to my family group chat. I literally wanted to buy more ice cream. But, the lady working the counter explained that they don’t allow use of the WiFi. It was the business’ loss since I wasn’t able to order ice cream for my family.
Definitely will go back just for how good the ice cream was, but I thought it was strange to now allow use of the WiFi for paying customers…
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
I've never had Cranberry Crunch before. It's my new favorite flavor!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent
Love this place!!!! Their ice cream is to die for!?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Homemade Waffle Cone
Disclaimer: read this review with a grain of salt. This was my favorite ice cream place when I was a kid and I have a lot of great memories here. including sitting at the window eating ice cream and saw my friend rear end a car. You might ask why he didn't break in time... Well he was head banging of course. (A form of distracted driving before cellphones existed) Soo ya a lot of great memories
Review: The place is awesome!
Best of the best!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We have been going to the Whistle Stop regularly for over a year now and we love it! The owner and staff are very friendly and the service is quick. Prices are comparable to other ice cream places on the cape, and you get great portions. Ice cream is delicious and my husband raves about the waffle cones year round (says they’re the best he’s ever had). They also have a fridge full of yummy looking ice cream cakes and treats for sale. We do wish that the hours were open a little later during the off season as we sometimes aren’t able to make it in time after dinner, but absolutely recommend the Whistle Stop.
Great ice cream and setvice
Restaurantji Recommends
THIS is the homemade ice cream I'd been searching for all week!! Most of the places we'd been going to all week just resell pre-made Hershey's or other brands you can just get at the store, but you can taste the delicious difference between Whistle's and the others'. The service was also excellent, and the prices were very clear, unlike at other spots. Between the two of us, these were our thoughts on the 4 flavors we tried...Vanilla: 8/10 (vanilla flavor could have been stronger)Coffee Heath Bar: 8.5/10 (says it's super strong coffee flavor, but even kid's would like this; it's like the sweetest latte with bits of toffee)Chocolate PB: 9/10Almond Joy: 7/10 (not as coconutty as I'd want; the coconut flavor was super faint)We'll be back next time we're on The Cape!!
Great homemade ice cream
Family favorite for decades!
Great homemade ice cream! Good variety of flavors.
Great place to eat there but some workers that worked there are very mean and rude need to learn manners grow up seriously I dont care what u think of me steve f.
Loading...