Not recommended. We finally left after an hour and forty minutes without seeing food other than first courses which were lukewarm, under seasoned and underwhelming. They have suits walking around schmoozing their favorites but not paying attention and reacting to real service issues in the rest of the room. When we got up to leave, I stopped at the host stand to ask for a check for what little they did bring us — now, of course, here comes the suit apologizing and telling me she will contact me so we can come back and give them another chance. Days have now passed and we have heard nothing. We have now left the area and can only urge others to avoid this situation.
My husband and I had a great evening at Stars. It is expensive but for us it was worth it. The food was delicious and the view was amazing. A special shout out to all of the people who work at Stars, they made our evening very special.
GoodExperience
Our recent visit to Stars, despite its fine dining reputation, left much to be desired. Although the food was decent, it didn't quite live up to the exceptional standard one would expect from such a high-end establishment. While enjoyable, it lacked the innovative flair and outstanding quality that would justify the steep price tag. Furthermore, the demeanor and professionalism of our server were disappointing. Their overly relaxed posture and casual behavior, such as resting a knee on a chair, detracted from the sophisticated ambiance we had anticipated. In fine dining settings, attentive and polished service is paramount in enhancing the overall experience. Additionally, external factors marred the restaurant's ambiance, notably the intrusion of guests from an adjacent meeting room. Their casual attire and disruptive movement through the dining area disrupted the refined atmosphere expected of a fine dining establishment. Overall, while our experience wasn't disastrous, it fell short of our expectations considering the hefty price we paid. We had hoped for a more seamless and refined dining experience. It's evident that there's room for improvement in both the service and ambiance aspects of Stars to truly justify its premium pricing.
rwasirius
This was a lovely special birthday and everyone made it a memorable evening, even the other diners who were celebrating events, for us the room not being full was a plus, less so for the hotel I suspect
Ned Adams
I can not fathom the hatred of this place. This was easily one of the better meals I’ve had the last few years and the service was impecable. From chef to manager to server all was excellent.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loved our meal here! Four of us were celebrating my sister's 40th birthday. We started with the burrata and the duck fat rolls - so good! The scallops were delicious, served with risotto. For dessert we had the cheesecake and the s'mores - both were fantastic! The view is breathtaking. Very memorable experience!
Food was amazing! They helped us pick a lovely bottle of wine & every we ate was absolutely delicious. Service was wonderful & professional, they paid attention to all the small details. At the end of the evening they sent the rest of our wine & our dessert back to our room for us to finish it in the comfort of our bathrobes.... A truely amazing night!
RobertH
Very attentive service and excellent water/beach view. The crudo was fresh and flavorful! Kitchen was really helpful working with allergies and went out of their way to make sure everything was right.
Worldtraveler
A creative menu and beautiful setting. We appreciated the mix of traditional and innovative choices, plus the team worked to make sure we had a great, personalized experience. We have been here several times, and will be happy to return.
Beautiful setting and great waiter. Food was barely warm and pretty much tasteless. Scallops looked as though they were plated the day before and warmed in the oven. Way overpriced for the product. Disappointing.
Stars delivered an unforgettable Valentine's Day experience. From delectable dishes to divine deserts, every bite was a culinary delight. The attentive customer service added a touch of warmth to the evening. It's a perfect destination for any special occasion.
DavidB
This is our favorite place for a special night out. Yes, it's a bit pricey, but that allows them to maintain the highest level of quality, service, and ambiance that is not available in other local restaurants.
EileenC
The dining room is beautiful. Restrained elegance at its best. The cocktails were perfect. Chatham oysters are superb. The entrees were sublime. Who knew that kabuche squash could be a subtle dessert.
Moma
This is our favorite restaurant. The food, cocktails, wine list, service, ambience and view are all outstanding. Our server Victoria was very efficient and nice. I highly recommend for special occasions.
Not recommended. We finally left after an hour and forty minutes without seeing food other than first courses which were lukewarm, under seasoned and underwhelming. They have suits walking around schmoozing their favorites but not paying attention and reacting to real service issues in the rest of the room. When we got up to leave, I stopped at the host stand to ask for a check for what little they did bring us — now, of course, here comes the suit apologizing and telling me she will contact me so we can come back and give them another chance. Days have now passed and we have heard nothing. We have now left the area and can only urge others to avoid this situation.
My husband and I had a great evening at Stars. It is expensive but for us it was worth it. The food was delicious and the view was amazing. A special shout out to all of the people who work at Stars, they made our evening very special.
Our recent visit to Stars, despite its fine dining reputation, left much to be desired. Although the food was decent, it didn't quite live up to the exceptional standard one would expect from such a high-end establishment. While enjoyable, it lacked the innovative flair and outstanding quality that would justify the steep price tag. Furthermore, the demeanor and professionalism of our server were disappointing. Their overly relaxed posture and casual behavior, such as resting a knee on a chair, detracted from the sophisticated ambiance we had anticipated. In fine dining settings, attentive and polished service is paramount in enhancing the overall experience. Additionally, external factors marred the restaurant's ambiance, notably the intrusion of guests from an adjacent meeting room. Their casual attire and disruptive movement through the dining area disrupted the refined atmosphere expected of a fine dining establishment. Overall, while our experience wasn't disastrous, it fell short of our expectations considering the hefty price we paid. We had hoped for a more seamless and refined dining experience. It's evident that there's room for improvement in both the service and ambiance aspects of Stars to truly justify its premium pricing.
This was a lovely special birthday and everyone made it a memorable evening, even the other diners who were celebrating events, for us the room not being full was a plus, less so for the hotel I suspect
I can not fathom the hatred of this place. This was easily one of the better meals I’ve had the last few years and the service was impecable. From chef to manager to server all was excellent.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loved our meal here! Four of us were celebrating my sister's 40th birthday. We started with the burrata and the duck fat rolls - so good! The scallops were delicious, served with risotto. For dessert we had the cheesecake and the s'mores - both were fantastic! The view is breathtaking. Very memorable experience!
Food was amazing! They helped us pick a lovely bottle of wine & every we ate was absolutely delicious. Service was wonderful & professional, they paid attention to all the small details. At the end of the evening they sent the rest of our wine & our dessert back to our room for us to finish it in the comfort of our bathrobes.... A truely amazing night!
Very attentive service and excellent water/beach view. The crudo was fresh and flavorful! Kitchen was really helpful working with allergies and went out of their way to make sure everything was right.
A creative menu and beautiful setting. We appreciated the mix of traditional and innovative choices, plus the team worked to make sure we had a great, personalized experience. We have been here several times, and will be happy to return.
Beautiful setting and great waiter. Food was barely warm and pretty much tasteless. Scallops looked as though they were plated the day before and warmed in the oven. Way overpriced for the product. Disappointing.
Restaurantji Recommends
Freaking amazing. Not sure why this only has 3.5
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stars delivered an unforgettable Valentine's Day experience. From delectable dishes to divine deserts, every bite was a culinary delight. The attentive customer service added a touch of warmth to the evening. It's a perfect destination for any special occasion.
This is our favorite place for a special night out. Yes, it's a bit pricey, but that allows them to maintain the highest level of quality, service, and ambiance that is not available in other local restaurants.
The dining room is beautiful. Restrained elegance at its best. The cocktails were perfect. Chatham oysters are superb. The entrees were sublime. Who knew that kabuche squash could be a subtle dessert.
This is our favorite restaurant. The food, cocktails, wine list, service, ambience and view are all outstanding. Our server Victoria was very efficient and nice. I highly recommend for special occasions.