Boston Bay Pizza

515 Montgomery St, Chicopee
(413) 888-3000

Recent Reviews

Javey Music

Food was delicious (Reuben melt) got it out quick for me and they were

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kevin Radawiec

The recent downward turn is disappointing. Ordered three different 16” grinders (chicken souvlaki, steak special, and steak and cheese) all had war-rationing levels of protein buried under a mountain of lettuce. Been ordering from here periodically over the years and the last three orders from Boston bay were sub-standard and not worth the $45 average for 3 people. Banana peppers in the picture where added by me.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 3

Victoria Walker

Despite talking to them a week beforehand to schedule a late delivery, they apparently lied and will not do so. 0/10 will never do business with them in the future.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

M.J. Weagle-Bruso

Ummm... Well this place took a dive.... I can't even cut my calzone (if that's what youwant to still call it) with a chefs knife. These three things never should have left the kitchen. Especially when I spent $55 +tip for them. Boston Bay I'm done with your overpriced garbage and terrible

Food: 2

Service: 2

Shawn Antunes

I went there based on a recommendation. The pizza wasn't cooked all the way. Maybe they need new ovens or something. Not sure if I will go back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 5

Reith Som

I've been ordering like more than one hour, first said 6:30 then 7,:23 then 9:20 after I called they said they never ever get my order online when I called around 7:30 pm. That's very bad.

Service: 1

Savage P.

Wow delicious pizza. Presented very well. A bit pricy and the carry out fee is a bit foolish. Getting in and out of the location is a bit of a drag if traffic hits. I do appreciate the service and the set up of the restaurant.

Alrawaf

I Call to place a delivery order ,the guy who’s supposed to take my order was struggling to find my address . At the end he says place order online and hang up on me how rude is that.

Gina M 3939

Food was horrible. We ordered 2 Honey Dijon paninis which had yellow mustard instead. We didn’t ask for regular mustard. Thankfully I asked for the honey Dijon on the side incase they messed it up. And of course they did. Curly fries and French fries were so over cooked they weren’t edible! They were hard as a rock! The only thing that was good were the sodas because they didn’t make them! We also waited over 35 minutes for our food when they said it wouldn’t take too long. They weren’t busy either.Initially we used to go there once a week about 4-5 years ago. Then service and food started to go down hill dramatically. They even stopped using real bacon. The quantity and quality was horrible and food was way over priced. So we stopped going there. Since so much time had gone by, we decided to give them another try. Well lo and behold, NOTHING HAS CHANGED! Needless to say, we won’t be going back again, not even in another 5 years unless new owners take over. We all work very hard for our money and expect our food to be decent for what we have to pay.This place should just close down. I can’t fathom how it it’s still open.

Food: 1

Service: 3

Richard Kagan

Traditionally really strong specialty pizzas, but things have gone downhill… ordered a large Chicken and Broccoli pizza on a Friday night and was told 25 minutes.. when I got there, they told me they didn’t have my order.. they said I could wait while they made the pizza.. I wasn’t in the mood, and ended up eating frozen DiGiorno’s stuffed crust pizza at home….I discovered air fryers work fabulous with mini frozen pizzas so I guess there was an upside from the experience!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Tammy Mullen

First time there.. was great!!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: French Fries

Cindy Kelliher

Ordered a steak grinder with onions and cheese. Got a cheeseburger grinder. Called and got nothing but a run around. Never again. Don't waste your money on these idiots

Scott Abercrombie

Its not the cleanest place in the world, especially the bathroom, but the subs are very good and the staff is friendly. Overall, I'd come back for the food.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amaral Soccer

We were in the mood for grinders and we were in the Chicopee area so we figured we try this place out. Looked like a nice building from the outside. That was the best part. The inside was dark and dirty. The food was NOT good. Grinders had mushy tomatoes, terrible shredded lettuce and not good quality bread. We bought 3 grinders and none of them were good. The one hit grinder the bread was burnt. Probably the worst grinders we have ever had. The people were nice, but the food was not good.We don’t recommend this place!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 3

Morgan Janee'

I never received my food, the guy was extremely rude and had the audacity to blame me for it. I put in a order online then called the place to verify and updated my phone number. A hour and a half later (it was only supposed to be 40min total) they apparently "tried" to deliver it but had the wrong number SMH (she never updated it after I called to verify). They said they'd be back in a couple minutes but they never came. I called for a refund 30minutes and the lady said she couldn't do it and the manager will call me in a couple minutes to do so. I never got the call for my refund, never got the food. Save yourself the stress.

Food: 1

Service: 1

Load More