We went here to have take out dinner with a relaxing view of the sunset. I had the warm lobster roll which did not hold together well, but was quite tasty.
Matt Mccaffrey
Best place ever… Let Stanley do the cooking for you
Matthew McCaffrey
The freshest Seafood in New England…. So good, let them do the cooking🦞🦞🦞
Jack Phillips
Go here and ask about the time Stan caught a 20 foot 3000 lb 9 foot diameter great white shark! Excellent. Such great service and fresh fish.
Nicolle Dananberg
Love coming here for some seafood and the view. Iv been coming here at least a couple of times a year for the last 4 years and unfortunately I think the quality has gone down some. I tried my first ever oyster here and I fell in love but now I'd put them at the bottom of my list for oysters as they don't even serve them on ice so they are just room temperature which is off putting. The lobster roll could be filled a bit more. But service is always great and vibes are always immaculate!
Michael Christopher
Fresh market price fish recommend
Nicole Landers
Delicious oysters right next to the sea! A nice hike 5mins up the road too. You can walk right on the beach as well. They have daily specials. A favorite of ours, and our friends.
Jüri Kiin
I'm very surprised MFM doesn't serve oysters on ice! They were like warm which made the texture pretty gross. It's wild to not serve them on ice!
Lobster roll was flavorful, but you can definitely find better on the island.
Good choice if you live up island, but I wouldn't make the trip specifically for this place.
I've been coming here for a long time, and I'm not sure how often I'll return. The quality definitely is not what it used to be
Peter Vanderford
There is no better clam chowder. I dare you. Go on.
A priceless drive-by food stop. Really try it. Oysters too
Ronnie McCaskill
Menemsha Beach is an absolute must-visit! Grab a hot, buttery lobster roll from Menemsha Fish Market—the best on the island—and settle in to watch the beautiful sunset. The beach offers breathtaking views, making it the perfect backdrop for a memorable evening. Don’t miss this iconic experience, it truly captures the essence of Martha’s Vineyard!
Best place in Menemsha! Cant wait to come back here. They have the best lobster rolls that im obsessed with and so much more delicious food. Stanley is the sweetest guy! Make’s it coming here an even more pleasant visit. I highly recommend.
Brian Tucker
Crowded but exceptional seafood!
Sandy Medeiros
We love their chowder
M S (Sunders ont road)
So was advised to go here by New Zealand Bill. I met him in a bar in Edgartown drinking Guinness. Always trusting a man and his friends who play drinking games with stout i headed down eh next day. It’s on the docks, they load in the lobsters off the boats and cook them there. I only had the Lobster roll, hot with butter, but it was delicious. One of the best I have tasted. Sat on a concrete pole eating off a cable drum and fighting off the seagulls. Couldn’t have enjoyed it more.
We went here to have take out dinner with a relaxing view of the sunset. I had the warm lobster roll which did not hold together well, but was quite tasty.
Best place ever… Let Stanley do the cooking for you
The freshest Seafood in New England…. So good, let them do the cooking🦞🦞🦞
Go here and ask about the time Stan caught a 20 foot 3000 lb 9 foot diameter great white shark! Excellent. Such great service and fresh fish.
Love coming here for some seafood and the view. Iv been coming here at least a couple of times a year for the last 4 years and unfortunately I think the quality has gone down some. I tried my first ever oyster here and I fell in love but now I'd put them at the bottom of my list for oysters as they don't even serve them on ice so they are just room temperature which is off putting. The lobster roll could be filled a bit more. But service is always great and vibes are always immaculate!
Fresh market price fish recommend
Delicious oysters right next to the sea! A nice hike 5mins up the road too. You can walk right on the beach as well. They have daily specials. A favorite of ours, and our friends.
I'm very surprised MFM doesn't serve oysters on ice! They were like warm which made the texture pretty gross. It's wild to not serve them on ice!
Lobster roll was flavorful, but you can definitely find better on the island.
Good choice if you live up island, but I wouldn't make the trip specifically for this place.
I've been coming here for a long time, and I'm not sure how often I'll return. The quality definitely is not what it used to be
There is no better clam chowder. I dare you. Go on.
A priceless drive-by food stop. Really try it. Oysters too
Menemsha Beach is an absolute must-visit! Grab a hot, buttery lobster roll from Menemsha Fish Market—the best on the island—and settle in to watch the beautiful sunset. The beach offers breathtaking views, making it the perfect backdrop for a memorable evening. Don’t miss this iconic experience, it truly captures the essence of Martha’s Vineyard!
Restaurantji Recommends
Best place in Menemsha! Cant wait to come back here. They have the best lobster rolls that im obsessed with and so much more delicious food. Stanley is the sweetest guy! Make’s it coming here an even more pleasant visit. I highly recommend.
Crowded but exceptional seafood!
We love their chowder
So was advised to go here by New Zealand Bill. I met him in a bar in Edgartown drinking Guinness. Always trusting a man and his friends who play drinking games with stout i headed down eh next day. It’s on the docks, they load in the lobsters off the boats and cook them there. I only had the Lobster roll, hot with butter, but it was delicious. One of the best I have tasted. Sat on a concrete pole eating off a cable drum and fighting off the seagulls. Couldn’t have enjoyed it more.
Wonderlust
Loading...