The Finicky Fork Catering Co.

199 Main St, Fitchburg

Recent Reviews

Sherry Vaughan

I cannot wait to order my Thanksgiving dinner here. It has been highly recommended to me, and after my experience at their restaurant, Pauper Pantry on Main Street in Fitchburg, I know it will be wonderful!

Erin Lloyd

We worked with Finicky Fork for a catered professional event for about 25 people. The food was good, but after initially securing the dates for our event, the owner was completely out of communication until right beforehand, and then again throughout the event when we encountered issues like late service and general questions. Despite repeated phone calls, emails and a text message, she did not respond to our concerns (until it was time to send us a bill, then she reappeared, with no acknowledgements or apologies for not returning calls/emails). At one of the meals, servers forgot to bring the burners that go beneath the catering pans to keep food hot, which meant that we had to send someone to a nearby grocery store to purchase them ourselves (this cost was not reimbursed to us - it wasn't much, but the good will would have gone a long way). The stress caused by the lack of communication was huge, and we will not work with this caterer again.

Michelle Scornavacca

Yesterday's event using Finicky Fork catering was amazing. Food was outstanding and enjoyed by all. More than enough food for everyone. Favorites were bbq ribs, cornbread, pasta salad and vegan pulled pork. Highly recommended.

Christina Da Silva

June 15 - Received Finicky Fork event proposal/agreement for a July 15th event via email.June 16 - Replied with questions and request for additional catering. (No response)June 20 & 26 - Sent follow up emails requesting a response to inquiry (No response)I get that summer is your busy season (and maybe other things came up), but a quick email letting me know you are no longer interested/available to book the event and/or you are busy and you'll get back to me by a certain date would have gone a long way. Radio silence is just plain sad (and completely avoidable). I would have loved to support a small local business but responding to inquiries in a timely manner is just customer service 101.

Tasha DiNardo

We hired Finicky Fork for my daughter’s baby shower and we’re so happy we did! Dawn worked with my budget so we were able to provide many choices for our guests. Every dish was so tasty and presented like a cascading river of food on the table. Thank you Dawn and Maddi for making our party a huge success!

Diane Lawton

2nd time catering our teacher appreciation lunch and they did not disappoint.

Laura Bessette

As a vegan, I was worried there wouldn't be anything for me to eat at my daughter's baby shower. But it was catered by Finicky Fork, so I had so much DELICIOUS food with roasted veggies, fresh berries, homemade hummus, tabouleh etc. Professional, top notch caterer. Thanks Finicky Fork!

Gina Wheaton Sauvageau

We ordered for Christmas Eve and the food was phenomenal ! Would definitely order from them again and would recommend them for any occasion! Thank youFinicky Fork! 5stars

Midnite Passion

Amazing professional staff. The food is outstanding and by far the best in catering . The event pop ups have to ve the most delicious and creative menus I've ever seen .

Roger Morse

I’ve only had there soups and they’re amazing! The people are very friendly, I would 1 million percent recommend them to anyone

Jaime Bielak

Horrible customer service. Had to reach out many times only to get replies days later if at all. Seemed impossible to simply just get a quote after they confirmed they had the date I needed available.

Mike Makoski

Amazing food and service, they do everything beyond expectations!

Caroline Abely

Absolutely the best caterer around! Food is always perfect!

Nicole Pare

Ordered our Thanksgiving meal from FF. Food was delicious, servings very generous, and super easy to order and pick up! Will definitely order from them again.

Sarah G

Amazing food!! Friendly staff!! You can’t go wrong if you order from Finicky , they’re the best! We’ve used them for holidays and for small take out orders and we’re impressed every time.

Load More

The Finicky Fork Catering Co.

199 Main St, Fitchburg, MA 01420