Poseidon’s Italian Kitchen

I was surprised how good this pizza was. I thought I had tried it a few years back and it was standard lousy pizza that the kids would eat.

Grabbed 2 pies tonight. One cheese and the spicy Sicilian sausage.

The cheese was delicious. Super flavorful. The Sicilian was a huge deep dish pizza. Very filling and tasty.

Right at the Blynman bridge makes it a super convenient choice.

We shall return.

Decent pizza, convenient spot if you are close to the beach. Pizza was fine, a bit greasy, standard for a local pizza spot. Price was not the cheapest but reasonable. Sandwiches seem good, cant comment on pasta dishes

No public restrooms, some seating available inside

Awesome nice place and pizza was so well done.

Fantastic food, service, and a welcoming atmosphere! Would absolutely recommend to anybody. Don't miss out on this gem!

Super friendly service and clean environment! I'm pretty bored with pizza but this place lit that fire again! I asked what to try and an employee suggested the arugula pizza! Wow delicious, authentic flavors! I didn't speak my whole visit as I was in heaven with each slice! Then you can walk the beach after- don't drive by this gem!

Ever since the new owners Posidens Pizza has been a disaster, it has been a price hike with lower quality food, 2 slices of pizza that have been sitting for 6 hours was 10$ and tasted like old wet towel with the consistency of a 1/4 inch pressure treated pine board. Prices up and quality down, don’t know what they are thinking. Would not recommend to any old or new customer.

They make you feel like you’re at home.

Great pizza, large servings, and great service. We just moved to Gloucester and have been trying all the pizza places in town. We love the hand-thrown crust, not too salty and a good chewy edge. We had a Margarita and the Arugula (photo) and both were full of flavor with fresh ingredients. The best part is that this is a new start-up and the owners are 110% invested in making every customer happy - just see how they respond to the comments below. We love giving them our business.

Best pizza outside of NYC.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Best pizza on Island

Prices see outrageous for the quality of food they are serving. Do not go here, you will be disappointed!

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

Food was awesome. The staff was really nice. This is a hidden gem.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Steak Bomb Calzone

Pizza was DELICIOUS, staff was so kind, loved sitting and watching the boats go by near the draw bridge.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Cheese Pizza

Awesome down home style place. We got a large calzone and it was great. Friendly service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

this is 5 minutes after having a couple of slices this is the pizza (we ate as soon as it arrived), ive had better pizza at a chucky cheese then this, we also ordered the mozzarella sticks and the styrofoam was melted along with the sauce container and the mozzarella sticks were cold and rock solid. waste of 52 dollars. five nights at freddy's wouldn't even do me this bad ?‍♀️

Food: 1