Peel Pizza Company

73 South St, Hingham
(781) 740-2775

Recent Reviews

Susan Carey

This is thin crust pizza at its best!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

John H

Great ? pizza and cheesy ? ? , the staff is friendly and service is fast. I go there for lunch, and the dudes that work there weekdays are top-notch dudes. Keep up the great work. ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza Slice of Pie

Lauri C.

Pizza is delicious the crust is thin and ingredients are fresh. Just check your box when picking up your order to be sure you're getting the right one.

Gregory P.

Place was great. I prefer a thicker crust, and this is super thin, but still had a good crunch and great flavor. Great selection, I opted for the Arrabiata with parm cheese and no motz. Really, really good. The wings were also great. They serve them plain so they can crisp them up nicely and it works well.

Sheryl L.

Worst customer service, even though pizza is good. We called at 7:25 pm (they close at 8) and no one picked up the phone. We were close, so arrived at 7:32 to place an order in person. They were wrapped up for the night. Cleaned up and done. We counted on picking up food on the way home from a meeting that ended at 7:20. If you say you're open until 8, be open until 8. If you're going stop taking orders at 7:30, then say so.

John M.

Ordered through door dash and was beyond disappointed. Pizza came burnt, not crisp, not charred with seasoning from a brick oven, it was burnt. It was burst no bad it was so hard to chew I hurt my teeth. On top of the the top of the pizza was undercooked somehow. To add to this disaster, I asked for a white pizza in my instructions and they sent one with red sauce which did not at all work with the toppings I asked for. Gross! Ordered wings and got a box full of flats. Sending blend had potential but was screaming for salt. Maybe try brining the wings or something to add salt if you don't want to improve your blend. But seriously, what's up with the only flats? Is that normal? I happen to like a mix and like drums. Overall we were super disappointed in a place with a good reputation. Maybe it's because we did DoorDash and they didn't care... just sad.

Danny primo

Best pizza around.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Adam B

2016: I gotta say best pizza in this area. Try the chicken pesto or the spicy panchetta. Both are amazing! Eggplant one is pretty good tooOct 2023: Updating. They don't seem to offer spicy panchetta any longer. Also got the chicken pesto today and it was definitely different than 7 years ago. I remember it being better. Pizza is still good, but different somehow. Picture is as of now.

Tristan Hope

The best chicken parm calzone I've ever ate in my life .

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Thomas Duggan

It's thin crust Italian style pizza. It's a little expensive but the pizza is definitely worth it.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza

John R.

Great picture, huge selection, and a little pricey, but the pies are enormous. Highly recommend this if you want a healthy pizza

Matt G.

They have new staff and the rotten apple is no longer there. This is without question the best pizza out of Hingham. Nothing else in the area compares and I've tried everything. Perfect thin crust and just the right amount of sauce and toppings. They don't over load it and the flavor is always on point. Super friendly staff as well. They're always busy but they do a great job. OH and their calzones are just as good if not better.

Welty W.

Tried this place recently, the pizza was really good, thin crust, toppings distributed evenly and in good portions. The wings left much to be desired, very basic, not seasoned at all and very pricey. The floor, tables were dirty, and the staff was not very friendly overall disappointing experience.

Alicia DiGiammarino

This pizza was really good! Nice that you can order pies and slices in case anyone’s tastes are out of sync with the rest of the group. A large pie could feed four hungry people easily. We can recommend the aloha, the tailgate, and the Irish riviera no bacon.

Michael W.

How do you forget a topping on a Margherita pizza, which only has the THREE? One might argue it's the most crucial of the three. I mean for instance, they dedicate a whole subsection of their menu to tomato sauce-less pies, but never do they forget the cheese. Except on mine :( This might have less to do with them and more to do with delivery -- but it wasn't hot when it arrived and the crust/dough had hardened to the point of assaulting my gums

Load More