Wonderful treats, atmosphere. My friend and I enjoy lunch at Bertucci and go to Gaetano's for coffee and dessert!!!
David Burrows
This place is a gem! The owner is the nicest guy you can meet and his amazing pastries speak for themselves! Truly top tier service!And the espresso is a must have ? ☕️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Emma C.
Valentine's Day surprise made my week!! I love sweets, especially cannolis, so when my boyfriend gave me this (with a beautiful bouquet of lilies) I almost screamed with joy! I have been on a mission to try all the bakeries in the vicinity of Boston, so you could call me a bakery expert. Gaetano's blew my socks off! Not only was the shell of the cannoli nice and crisp, but the cream was delicious. I really loved the cookies as well, which surprised me! When I am back in Holliston, you will for sure see me at Gaetano's Bakery with a crumb trail following me wherever I go.
Lori B.
Great selection. Very nice employees. Cannoli dip and cookies are very good! Highly recommend.
Roberta Weiner
The pistachio macaroons are addictive!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kara Luzi
We went there last night to pick up some birthday treats for my stepson and the owner graciously offered some cookies to the 3 kids while they waited. Not only are their treats delicious and fresh, but every time we go there they are very friendly and welcoming. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cannolis
Carol “cbell” Bellinghausen
Amazing service and pecan pie and pistachio cookies beyond delicious! We are so grateful to have found Gaetano’s Bakery, just in time for the holidays! Grazie Mille?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Catherine Logan
I called to order a tray of baked goods as a condolence gift to be sent to the home of a close friend who had lost her husband . It was delivered very quickly. It turned out it was the husbands favorite bakery. The service was excellent and very warm and considerate.
Food: 5
Service: 5
J9 j3
excellent sweets and confectionery. Glad to see it back in business. Hopefully just as good as 15 years ago. We used to visit it weekly when we lived in the area.
Den Correia
Great staff fantastic coffee and outstanding authentic Italian pastry
OMG!! There are just no words to explain how amazing this bakery is and how they came through for me. I had heard of them through friends who were equally impressed so I decided to give them a try. However, I did not have time to make the trip prior to my dinner party so I whispered a prayer to the dessert gods and with Guy and Amber's help, selected a number of items for an end of season outdoor Italian dinner party. We decided on a tiramisu, Italian cookies and an assortment of cannoli both with and without chocolate chips and some dipped in chocolate. When I opened up the boxes (had someone pick them up for me since I was busy prepping and cooking), I was stunned at not only the smell of chocolate, cream, cinnamon and dough but also the elegance. This was not your standard square tiramisu; this was a huge cake with ladyfingers all around the border and a perfectly spread top. It was gorgeous and tasted better than anything I cooked. The cookies were a huge hit especially with the cappuccino flowing and the cannolis were so good, I greedily hid two for myself for later! LOL. I cannot recommend them enough. They were prompt, helpful with suggestions and the end result shows the care and quality they put into their creations. They are now the official dessert provider for any dinner I plan. Go as soon as you can even if it is for a decadent treat with your morning coffee. Why have a donut when you can have a proper Italian confection!!!
Mobile57467204304
OMG!! There are just no words to explain how amazing this bakery is and how they came through for me. I had heard of them through friends who were equally impressed so I decided to give them a try. However, I did not have time to make the trip prior to my dinner party so I whispered a prayer to the dessert gods and with Guy and Amber's help, selected a number of items for an end of season outdoor Italian dinner party. We decided on a tiramisu, Italian cookies and an assortment of cannoli both with and without chocolate chips and some dipped in chocolate. When I opened up the boxes (had someone pick them up for me since I was busy prepping and cooking), I was stunned at not only the smell of chocolate, cream, cinnamon and dough but also the elegance. This was not your standard square tiramisu; this was a huge cake with ladyfingers all around the border and a perfectly spread top. It was gorgeous and tasted better than anything I cooked. The cookies were a huge hit especially with the cappuccino flowing and the cannolis were so good, I greedily hid two for myself for later! LOL. I cannot recommend them enough. They were prompt, helpful with suggestions and the end result shows the care and quality they put into their creations. They are now the official dessert provider for any dinner I plan. Go as soon as you can even if it is for a decadent treat with your morning coffee. Why have a donut when you can have a proper Italian confection!!!
Eddie Meyer
Visiting Milford from the Chicagoland area. We needed a Birthday cake last minute. I found this Gaetanos via Google and off I went. What an AWESOME experience, such amazing owners and amazing sweets. The cake, which the owner customized for the birthday girl for me on the spot was delicious. I also purchased an assortment of cookies/pastries. WOW! The pistachio macarons where out of this WORLD! I would highly recommend this place and I am going back before I fly back to Chicago! Great service, great cake and great pastries! Thank you!
Joanne Fahy
Neat and clean. Fresh baked items, deliciously decadent ricotta pie..the best. Atmosphere very pleasant. So much better than North End. You should try the frozen yogurt, my grandson makes a real pig of himself..as does our family. Must sat the entire experience was like I went to Italy.
Ben A.
I was absolutely horrified to find out that my cookies were very stale with not much flavor I was really hoping that it was taste but was disappointed the cannoli shells were extremely soft and the filling fell on the ground. And when I called to complain he hung up on me. Never going again
Wonderful treats, atmosphere. My friend and I enjoy lunch at Bertucci and go to Gaetano's for coffee and dessert!!!
This place is a gem! The owner is the nicest guy you can meet and his amazing pastries speak for themselves! Truly top tier service!And the espresso is a must have ? ☕️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Valentine's Day surprise made my week!! I love sweets, especially cannolis, so when my boyfriend gave me this (with a beautiful bouquet of lilies) I almost screamed with joy! I have been on a mission to try all the bakeries in the vicinity of Boston, so you could call me a bakery expert. Gaetano's blew my socks off! Not only was the shell of the cannoli nice and crisp, but the cream was delicious. I really loved the cookies as well, which surprised me! When I am back in Holliston, you will for sure see me at Gaetano's Bakery with a crumb trail following me wherever I go.
Great selection. Very nice employees. Cannoli dip and cookies are very good! Highly recommend.
The pistachio macaroons are addictive!
Food: 5
Service: 5
We went there last night to pick up some birthday treats for my stepson and the owner graciously offered some cookies to the 3 kids while they waited. Not only are their treats delicious and fresh, but every time we go there they are very friendly and welcoming. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cannolis
Amazing service and pecan pie and pistachio cookies beyond delicious! We are so grateful to have found Gaetano’s Bakery, just in time for the holidays! Grazie Mille?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I called to order a tray of baked goods as a condolence gift to be sent to the home of a close friend who had lost her husband . It was delivered very quickly. It turned out it was the husbands favorite bakery. The service was excellent and very warm and considerate.
Food: 5
Service: 5
excellent sweets and confectionery. Glad to see it back in business. Hopefully just as good as 15 years ago. We used to visit it weekly when we lived in the area.
Great staff fantastic coffee and outstanding authentic Italian pastry
Restaurantji Recommends
OMG!! There are just no words to explain how amazing this bakery is and how they came through for me. I had heard of them through friends who were equally impressed so I decided to give them a try. However, I did not have time to make the trip prior to my dinner party so I whispered a prayer to the dessert gods and with Guy and Amber's help, selected a number of items for an end of season outdoor Italian dinner party. We decided on a tiramisu, Italian cookies and an assortment of cannoli both with and without chocolate chips and some dipped in chocolate. When I opened up the boxes (had someone pick them up for me since I was busy prepping and cooking), I was stunned at not only the smell of chocolate, cream, cinnamon and dough but also the elegance. This was not your standard square tiramisu; this was a huge cake with ladyfingers all around the border and a perfectly spread top. It was gorgeous and tasted better than anything I cooked. The cookies were a huge hit especially with the cappuccino flowing and the cannolis were so good, I greedily hid two for myself for later! LOL. I cannot recommend them enough. They were prompt, helpful with suggestions and the end result shows the care and quality they put into their creations. They are now the official dessert provider for any dinner I plan. Go as soon as you can even if it is for a decadent treat with your morning coffee. Why have a donut when you can have a proper Italian confection!!!
OMG!! There are just no words to explain how amazing this bakery is and how they came through for me. I had heard of them through friends who were equally impressed so I decided to give them a try. However, I did not have time to make the trip prior to my dinner party so I whispered a prayer to the dessert gods and with Guy and Amber's help, selected a number of items for an end of season outdoor Italian dinner party. We decided on a tiramisu, Italian cookies and an assortment of cannoli both with and without chocolate chips and some dipped in chocolate. When I opened up the boxes (had someone pick them up for me since I was busy prepping and cooking), I was stunned at not only the smell of chocolate, cream, cinnamon and dough but also the elegance. This was not your standard square tiramisu; this was a huge cake with ladyfingers all around the border and a perfectly spread top. It was gorgeous and tasted better than anything I cooked. The cookies were a huge hit especially with the cappuccino flowing and the cannolis were so good, I greedily hid two for myself for later! LOL. I cannot recommend them enough. They were prompt, helpful with suggestions and the end result shows the care and quality they put into their creations. They are now the official dessert provider for any dinner I plan. Go as soon as you can even if it is for a decadent treat with your morning coffee. Why have a donut when you can have a proper Italian confection!!!
Visiting Milford from the Chicagoland area. We needed a Birthday cake last minute. I found this Gaetanos via Google and off I went. What an AWESOME experience, such amazing owners and amazing sweets. The cake, which the owner customized for the birthday girl for me on the spot was delicious. I also purchased an assortment of cookies/pastries. WOW! The pistachio macarons where out of this WORLD! I would highly recommend this place and I am going back before I fly back to Chicago! Great service, great cake and great pastries! Thank you!
Neat and clean. Fresh baked items, deliciously decadent ricotta pie..the best. Atmosphere very pleasant. So much better than North End. You should try the frozen yogurt, my grandson makes a real pig of himself..as does our family. Must sat the entire experience was like I went to Italy.
I was absolutely horrified to find out that my cookies were very stale with not much flavor I was really hoping that it was taste but was disappointed the cannoli shells were extremely soft and the filling fell on the ground. And when I called to complain he hung up on me. Never going again