Can you see the feathers still on these wings? Nasty. I couldn't eat them it grossed me out so much. Gluten free pizza is alright.
Justin Tomasini
Fresh and good ingredients
Niall Gengler
Best pizza in Western MA!
Al Williams
Excellent pizza excellent food. One of the best pizza places in WMass.
David Zellmer
Pizza is delicious, had the Roni and a Philly flyer hero (also delicious). The sandwich was easily a meal for 2 by itself. Just reading some of the previous comments I wish people would keep in mind it’s a small business and staffing is tough. If you have to wait a little extra or they’re not always open when you expect try to have some patience. When you pick the pizza up fresh it’s the best I’ve had in the area no contest.
Garrett Vanasse
I drive past this place all the time but haven’t stopped in. My budget in this economy doesn’t really afford the ability to eat take away very often. It was a short week and short month so I thought what the heck, one pizza won’t break the bank. Turns out all that was broken were my spirits as this place seems out of business. I stopped by on a Friday because their website said they were open and I wanted to try one of their thin and crispy but slightly charred pizzas but they were closed. The hours on the door indicated they were open but there were zero lights on and no one home so I just wandered into the King Mart and got a pizza flavored snack instead. I guess I’ll never know if it was any good after driving past for all these years. Some things just pass ya by
Paula Perusse
My husband and I were in town for a funeral and searched for pizza near our hotel. Fat Tomato popped up and it was delish! We live in OH, authentic pizza is none existent. We also enjoyed salad and an ice cream cookie! We had a lovely visit with the owner, don't miss this gem when you are in the area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rory King
I called to ask exactly what a mozzarella square is; is it fried? Does it come on bread? What is it? When you just repeat the question back to me and tell me, "They're mozzarella squares," you get a 1 star review. Not everyone is from where you're from. We don't all know what a mozzarella square is.
Service: 1
Jill Lueb
Pizza, meatball appetizer and wings were all DELICIOUS! Also splurged on chicken salad which is delicious too. Took a star off because the meatballs said they came with bread, and we got no bread, and they forgot our ranch dip for the wings. Wish I noticed before I got home! Will definitely order again though. So good!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Dave Reilly
This is the highest quality pizza I've had in the area. I'm from NY/NJ, and I've had many great pies. The dough preparation and the caliber of the ingredients here are top notch, and the result is truly excellent pizza.
No clue what's going on with this place. The food is good...when you can get it. I've walked into their store in the middle of the day and no one was there... door unlocked, lights on and no one to be found. Waited a few minutes and just left.
Previously, Ive called to order a sandwich for pick up around lunch later in the week and was told they're not making sandwiches that day. We ordered for delivery over the weekend and got an ETA, followed by a message stating they had an emergency and canceled the order. I called ahead of time today to confirmed that they would be able to fulfill my order, and I was assured it wouldn't be a problem. I placed the order, got an ETA, followed by a message that my order was canceled for an emergency. Called back to find out what's going on and they didn't pick up.
All done.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Jason Niles
Fat Tomatoes has fantastic, high quality pizza and pre prepared dinners and desserts of generous size. There are a few small tables, but it’s mostly a “to go” establishment. It’s the best pizza I have found in western Massachusetts. My family’s favorites are the “Crime Scene” and the “Cali BBQ.” For pre prepared meals, we like the meat sauce over pasta, the eggplant parm, and the tiramisu. Everything we’ve tried has been great. Joe is selective about the ingredients he uses, and the difference is reflected in the taste of his foods. It’s a small business well worth supporting.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Steve Porter
Awesome pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alexander Hamilton
Pizza is made from quality ingredients, you can tell. I got the Wise Guy pizza, Crust was so perfectly evenly crispy on the bottom, lots of diverse ingredients and even uses parm reggiano. The guy was kind of a trip. Tried to chat while waiting, he seemed not so happy with his business and almost seemed to get triggered when I mentioned his pizza cost more than a competitor, but not bad and just kind of a typical Masshole attitude. Probably a good dude but just wants more business. I recommend this spot if you're in the area. Also tried the tiramisu, which was excellent. Looks like it has good prepped meals to just grab and nuke.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Monique Chevygirlss
The lights where you sit were off.. it was sorta vibe with this the glow from outside. The man behind the counter is your typical mass attitude dude .. but the pizza that was served... Phenomenal! Definitely more of a takeout spot than a sit down and eat. Like I said there was no lights on where you sit. It was sort of a vibe though... We ordered your classic cheese pizza.. I ordered the Popeye Pizza and my son got the old school pizza
Your classic cheese, everyone was telling me that that everything was delicious on it between the sauces and cheeses that were used and perfectly cooked
My son got the old school pizza which other people tried and everybody agreed that it was one of the best pizzas around that one had meatballs and cheese double layered
I ended up ordering the Popeyes but added sausage but that came with ricotta and spinach and I had that on a cauliflower crust which was just absolutely delicious
Can you see the feathers still on these wings? Nasty. I couldn't eat them it grossed me out so much.
Gluten free pizza is alright.
Fresh and good ingredients
Best pizza in Western MA!
Excellent pizza excellent food. One of the best pizza places in WMass.
Pizza is delicious, had the Roni and a Philly flyer hero (also delicious). The sandwich was easily a meal for 2 by itself. Just reading some of the previous comments I wish people would keep in mind it’s a small business and staffing is tough. If you have to wait a little extra or they’re not always open when you expect try to have some patience. When you pick the pizza up fresh it’s the best I’ve had in the area no contest.
I drive past this place all the time but haven’t stopped in. My budget in this economy doesn’t really afford the ability to eat take away very often. It was a short week and short month so I thought what the heck, one pizza won’t break the bank. Turns out all that was broken were my spirits as this place seems out of business. I stopped by on a Friday because their website said they were open and I wanted to try one of their thin and crispy but slightly charred pizzas but they were closed. The hours on the door indicated they were open but there were zero lights on and no one home so I just wandered into the King Mart and got a pizza flavored snack instead. I guess I’ll never know if it was any good after driving past for all these years. Some things just pass ya by
My husband and I were in town for a funeral and searched for pizza near our hotel. Fat Tomato popped up and it was delish! We live in OH, authentic pizza is none existent. We also enjoyed salad and an ice cream cookie! We had a lovely visit with the owner, don't miss this gem when you are in the area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I called to ask exactly what a mozzarella square is; is it fried? Does it come on bread? What is it?
When you just repeat the question back to me and tell me, "They're mozzarella squares," you get a 1 star review.
Not everyone is from where you're from. We don't all know what a mozzarella square is.
Service: 1
Pizza, meatball appetizer and wings were all DELICIOUS! Also splurged on chicken salad which is delicious too. Took a star off because the meatballs said they came with bread, and we got no bread, and they forgot our ranch dip for the wings. Wish I noticed before I got home! Will definitely order again though. So good!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
This is the highest quality pizza I've had in the area. I'm from NY/NJ, and I've had many great pies. The dough preparation and the caliber of the ingredients here are top notch, and the result is truly excellent pizza.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
No clue what's going on with this place. The food is good...when you can get it. I've walked into their store in the middle of the day and no one was there... door unlocked, lights on and no one to be found. Waited a few minutes and just left.
Previously, Ive called to order a sandwich for pick up around lunch later in the week and was told they're not making sandwiches that day. We ordered for delivery over the weekend and got an ETA, followed by a message stating they had an emergency and canceled the order. I called ahead of time today to confirmed that they would be able to fulfill my order, and I was assured it wouldn't be a problem. I placed the order, got an ETA, followed by a message that my order was canceled for an emergency. Called back to find out what's going on and they didn't pick up.
All done.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Fat Tomatoes has fantastic, high quality pizza and pre prepared dinners and desserts of generous size. There are a few small tables, but it’s mostly a “to go” establishment. It’s the best pizza I have found in western Massachusetts. My family’s favorites are the “Crime Scene” and the “Cali BBQ.” For pre prepared meals, we like the meat sauce over pasta, the eggplant parm, and the tiramisu.
Everything we’ve tried has been great. Joe is selective about the ingredients he uses, and the difference is reflected in the taste of his foods. It’s a small business well worth supporting.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Awesome pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza is made from quality ingredients, you can tell. I got the Wise Guy pizza, Crust was so perfectly evenly crispy on the bottom, lots of diverse ingredients and even uses parm reggiano. The guy was kind of a trip. Tried to chat while waiting, he seemed not so happy with his business and almost seemed to get triggered when I mentioned his pizza cost more than a competitor, but not bad and just kind of a typical Masshole attitude. Probably a good dude but just wants more business. I recommend this spot if you're in the area. Also tried the tiramisu, which was excellent. Looks like it has good prepped meals to just grab and nuke.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
The lights where you sit were off.. it was sorta vibe with this the glow from outside. The man behind the counter is your typical mass attitude dude .. but the pizza that was served... Phenomenal! Definitely more of a takeout spot than a sit down and eat. Like I said there was no lights on where you sit. It was sort of a vibe though... We ordered your classic cheese pizza.. I ordered the Popeye Pizza and my son got the old school pizza
Your classic cheese, everyone was telling me that that everything was delicious on it between the sauces and cheeses that were used and perfectly cooked
My son got the old school pizza which other people tried and everybody agreed that it was one of the best pizzas around that one had meatballs and cheese double layered
I ended up ordering the Popeyes but added sausage but that came with ricotta and spinach and I had that on a cauliflower crust which was just absolutely delicious
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Loading...