Terry's Old Fashion Ice Cream Shop
22 Atlantic Ave, Marblehead
(781) 639-2373
Customers' Favorites
Peppermint Stick
Blueberry Pie
Cookie Dough
Butter Pecan
Coffee Oreo
Hot Fudge
Sundae
Menu
Photos
+38 photos
+37 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
We were in Salem for my friend’s bachelorette weekend, and had a disaster experience with our Air BnB near by and needed to cancel our reservation. We were standing outside in Marblehead trying to figure out where to go for the night at like 11:30 at night, past closing, and this man stayed open so we had somewhere inside to stay while we figured everything out. Truly cannot thank him enough for his kindness.
We didn't even get ice cream and I feel genuinely guilty for it. We came up 2.5 hours for my Bachelorette to find an uncleaned AirBNB, and a man who I assumed was the owner let us hang out in the shop for 20 minutes after close until we could find a place to sleep, just so we could use the bathroom and so we wouldn't have to stand in the cold. Give him your money. He restored some of my faith in humanity tonight.
I am not typically someone to leave reviews on local businesses but I was charged a fee to use a credit card without my knowledge. I contacted the business to inquire about why the charge on my card was so high ($17 for a small and kiddie ice cream)
The ice cream is yummy just beware there’s a charge if you don’t pay with cash!
The ice cream is yummy just beware there’s a charge if you don’t pay with cash!
You May Also Like
Eat Well Kitchen - 12 Atlantic Ave
![]()
Health Food, Cafe, Juice Bar & Smoothies
Mino's Roast Beef - 27 Atlantic Ave
![]()
Fast Food, Burgers
Marblehead House of Pizza Inc - 7 Atlantic Ave
![]()
Pizza, Italian