Smitty's Homemade Ice Cream
538 Falmouth Rd, Mashpee
(774) 602-5481
Customers' Favorites
Peppermint Stick
Banana Split
Coffee Chip
Cod Crunch
Sorbet
Oreo
Menu
Photos
+17 photos
+16 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Our daughter was having a bad day. She is autistic and non verbal. We pulled into Smittys at 11:30am and I walked up to see if they were open, not knowing they don’t open until 1pm. There were people there preparing to open for the day and they welcomed me. I asked if they were open and mentioned my daughter was having a rough day and we were trying to cheer her up with an ice cream. Who I assume was the owner, asked me what she would like. A small vanilla soft serve in a dish...
Decided to try this place out because it was one of the most popular ice cream stands in the area. There was a very long line, but the staff did a great job at making it move fast. Unfortunately, once I got my ice cream, which was cookie dough, it was pretty melted and almost like soft serve. Someone else with us also got cookie dough, and it was also pretty much melted, which was disappointing. I guess I'll have to get a different flavor some other time.
We all enjoyed our ice cream at Smitty’s, though out of all of the ice cream we tried on our vacation, it wasn’t anyone’s top pick. The portion sizes were generous and the prices were reasonable.
