I grew up in the area and have lived abroad—mostly in Europe—for the past 15 years. Over that time, I’ve become very aware of the differences in ingredients and food quality between Europe and the U.S. When I come back each year to visit family, I often find that a lot of American food leaves me feeling bloated and uncomfortable, likely due to additives, dyes, and lower-quality ingredients that I’m no longer used to.
Blue Moon Bagel Cafe is the one wonderful exception.
I’ve been coming here since high school, and it’s the place I genuinely look forward to eating when I’m back in town. I truly trust their ingredients: the food tastes fresh, clean, and well made, and it doesn’t leave me with that heavy, uncomfortable feeling I get elsewhere. The sandwiches are delicious, everything feels thoughtfully prepared, and the staff is consistently friendly and welcoming. Prices are also quite reasonable for the area, especially considering current inflation in the US.
I’ll admit that some of the desserts are total sugar bombs—but that’s probably just my now very European palate talking! For those who love a sweet treat, they’re clearly doing something right.
All in all, Blue Moon Bagel Cafe is a real gem in Medfield. I’m grateful it’s still here and always make a point to visit when I’m back about once a year. Thank you for staying true to quality and consistency all these years.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Debra DeVaughn
Great baked goods! But it was disappointing to find, after arriving at my office, that the onion bagel with chive cream cheese and lox that I ordered was actually made with a CINNAMON bagel. Ugh...sad...
Susan Rugnetta
Best bagels in Massachusetts. Ginger scone is unique and delicious. Croissants are always fresh.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A. Roberts Frechette
Long wait for order. Not as bagel-oriented as the name would suggest. Average reuben sandwich.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Jess Ehm
Coffee and sandwich were both great! Fast, friendly service! Nice, large indoor seating area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bogdan Znakharchuk
Had a lox bagel sandwich and latte, both were well prepared and tasted great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rashmi R
Love their bagels and spreads.
Cira Fernandez
I love this place. I love love love the cranberry orange load bread, but i do wish they didn’t speinkle all that extra sugar on it, it’s sweet enough on it’s own. I end up wasting the crust and outer edges. Thank you for your service and your service to our local communities as well! Buen Provecho, Godere, Bom Proveito !
Great place! Pleasantly surprised with huge selection of food choices and pastries!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Melissa Hatch
We’ve been getting food here for a very long time and I have nothing bad to say about the food. But I won’t ever come back here again after being lied to. I arrived on Friday afternoon to pick up the 15 cupcakes I had ordered on Wednesday, after having received a text informing me that they were ready. The older gentleman I spoke to could not find any record of my order, So I showed him the receipt that I had been emailed. After standing there for about 5 minutes, I was told that the order had just come through, and that “Internet orders don’t always come through right away” and that it would be 10 more minutes. I repeated to him that I had received a text telling me that my order was done. Five minutes later I was told that my order had been sitting there waiting for me all the time and that this man just simply didn’t know. That’s fine, everybody makes mistakes. But he didn’t know the answer and so just lied to my face. It will be sad to not go to blue moon anymore.
Food: 5
Service: 1
Joan Kirschner
The food is always very good and portions are generous. Baked goods to go are high quality. The service is on the slow side, given how many people are working behind the counter. The atmosphere is average, booths, tables and chairs. It can be very noisy at peak times. It’s nicer to sit at the outdoor tables when weather permits.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Julie Hubbard
Great customer service. There was accidentally an error with our order and the staff went above and beyond to make it right. Great food, great establishment. We go frequently!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Haidar Al-Rubie'y
Place was nice. Food was delicious. A little bit pricey but good food. They take good care of the whole place The place is nice, but their prices are a little expensive, and in general the place is clean Plenty of seats available. Plenty of parking.
Great place to stop for a drink and bagels.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
I grew up in the area and have lived abroad—mostly in Europe—for the past 15 years. Over that time, I’ve become very aware of the differences in ingredients and food quality between Europe and the U.S. When I come back each year to visit family, I often find that a lot of American food leaves me feeling bloated and uncomfortable, likely due to additives, dyes, and lower-quality ingredients that I’m no longer used to.
Blue Moon Bagel Cafe is the one wonderful exception.
I’ve been coming here since high school, and it’s the place I genuinely look forward to eating when I’m back in town. I truly trust their ingredients: the food tastes fresh, clean, and well made, and it doesn’t leave me with that heavy, uncomfortable feeling I get elsewhere. The sandwiches are delicious, everything feels thoughtfully prepared, and the staff is consistently friendly and welcoming. Prices are also quite reasonable for the area, especially considering current inflation in the US.
I’ll admit that some of the desserts are total sugar bombs—but that’s probably just my now very European palate talking! For those who love a sweet treat, they’re clearly doing something right.
All in all, Blue Moon Bagel Cafe is a real gem in Medfield. I’m grateful it’s still here and always make a point to visit when I’m back about once a year. Thank you for staying true to quality and consistency all these years.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great baked goods! But it was disappointing to find, after arriving at my office, that the onion bagel with chive cream cheese and lox that I ordered was actually made with a CINNAMON bagel. Ugh...sad...
Best bagels in Massachusetts. Ginger scone is unique and delicious. Croissants are always fresh.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Long wait for order.
Not as bagel-oriented as the name would suggest.
Average reuben sandwich.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Coffee and sandwich were both great! Fast, friendly service! Nice, large indoor seating area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Had a lox bagel sandwich and latte, both were well prepared and tasted great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love their bagels and spreads.
I love this place. I love love love the cranberry orange load bread, but i do wish they didn’t speinkle all that extra sugar on it, it’s sweet enough on it’s own. I end up wasting the crust and outer edges. Thank you for your service and your service to our local communities as well! Buen Provecho, Godere, Bom Proveito !
very friendly, very clean, lots of GF options :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Great place! Pleasantly surprised with huge selection of food choices and pastries!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We’ve been getting food here for a very long time and I have nothing bad to say about the food. But I won’t ever come back here again after being lied to. I arrived on Friday afternoon to pick up the 15 cupcakes I had ordered on Wednesday, after having received a text informing me that they were ready. The older gentleman I spoke to could not find any record of my order, So I showed him the receipt that I had been emailed. After standing there for about 5 minutes, I was told that the order had just come through, and that “Internet orders don’t always come through right away” and that it would be 10 more minutes. I repeated to him that I had received a text telling me that my order was done. Five minutes later I was told that my order had been sitting there waiting for me all the time and that this man just simply didn’t know. That’s fine, everybody makes mistakes. But he didn’t know the answer and so just lied to my face. It will be sad to not go to blue moon anymore.
Food: 5
Service: 1
The food is always very good and portions are generous. Baked goods to go are high quality. The service is on the slow side, given how many people are working behind the counter. The atmosphere is average, booths, tables and chairs. It can be very noisy at peak times. It’s nicer to sit at the outdoor tables when weather permits.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Great customer service. There was accidentally an error with our order and the staff went above and beyond to make it right. Great food, great establishment. We go frequently!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Place was nice. Food was delicious. A little bit pricey but good food. They take good care of the whole place
The place is nice, but their prices are a little expensive, and in general the place is clean
Plenty of seats available. Plenty of parking.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Loading...