Steel & Rye

95 Eliot St, Milton
(617) 690-2787

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Carolina

The restaurant is beautiful with its decor, lights and comfortable seating. It has a nice and lively sound level. The price point is way too high for what is offered. Some of the food choices were odd and felt experimental. The pizza came to us cold (not even warm) despite having a wood burning oven on site. The wine tasted skunked. We have been here a few times and want to like it, given the great ambiance, but the prices are way too high and the food is mediocre at best.

Diane

This is a very nice neighborhood restaurant that I frequent often. Their food is very good, especially the pizza. Their red wine by the glass is limited, I do wish they would add more of a selection. Their staff is generally very good and friendly. However, Last night the waiter we had was not the best, he could have been more polite and personable.

James

My family dines at the restaurant often either dining in or take out since we live down the street. The gentleman that was our server this evening was the worst server I have ever had. I never take time to write reviews but this experience was an awful one. We had a 5 pm reservation because we have 2 young children (3 and 5) and the restaurant is never that busy at that time. My daughter (3) accidentally spilled her drink, we cleaned it up with our napkins and when asked for new ones were only given 2 for the 4 of us. When our food did come out at separate times first my pasta dish so I waited until the kids pizza finally came out. I had asked our server where the appetizer was that I ordered (steak tartar) he told me that he didn't know I wanted that and that i mumbled. It was the first thing ordered and I said it could come out at anytime. What if I had a speech impairment or disorder. Is this something you tell a customer?? He should have said I am sorry I missed that would you still like me to out that in. On top of that he had an attitude and was cheeky. Its not a rip on the restaurant rather the server they hired as staff is important in hospitality. We will be back but if this person is our server we will definitely ask to move tables or request another server.

Gregory

We had the Sausage and Fennel pizza, Fried Chicken Sandwich and the Burrata and White truffles. Everything was delicious.

Ellen McNulty

Always a great meal here! Staff is great too!! Went for girls night out shared a bunch of starters (fried olives are a must!), had meals and shared a dessert and also took some cookies to-go. Recommend making reservations, definitely will be returning (again)!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Joshua Freed

Great place. Good food, good service

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Joseph Saucier

The sandwich, the Italian was lackluster. I call it a wishy sandwich. Wished I had more meat. Not the same. As the golden years. The Bartender was boring. No personality.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

Kevin

Great Pizzia and wine night. Staff was very friendly and on top of everything. Pizzia is soo good.. must try !

jing

Staff is very friendly and environment is very good. Kids menu comes with color page and crayons which is very thoughtful. Food taste good, less variety for dinner.

Leslie

Food was delicious! The staff was welcoming and attentive throughout our dinner. We'll definitely be back.

Vyvyan

It was cold sitting by the windows. Food was great, but the service was slow. We really wanted dessert, but ran out of time because the entrée took so long.

Cathy Speicher

Great brunch

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Matt Coughlin

Great brunch here, love the industrial look inside and most importantly the food was good

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Igor

Our favorite restaurant. The food is amazing, the service is excellent. Small but top notch wine and beer menu.

Robert

Great food and a menu with a variety of choices regarding sizes and servings. A great wine list with a range of prices. My date shared some of her kale pizza (sounds weird, but it was delicious) while I had the rigatoni. Great all around. It was almost a full house so the noise level is a bit much, but that is dining in the US these days. A very comfortable, casual atmosphere otherwise.

Loading...