3-WAY SCOOPS

57 Old South Rd, Nantucket

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Rafal Orzelek

Downside NO STRAWBERRY TOPPING FOR THE

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

sam faulkner

I know this place is new so I want to be fair and reasonable, but ice cream is an important product these days, as it allows us a rare escape into childlike whimsy from the harsh, hateful, polarising political reality we find ourselves submerged in against our will. Even on a hot day like today, we expect that modern ice cream technology would allow us a robust, reliable scoop that retains its shape for at least a few minutes after being handed over the counter, but instead I was presented with a dripping, liquid, mess that reminded me of the bleak unpredictable reality I was trying so hard to ignore for a precious 5 minutes. I must admit I was already in a state of mild anxiety as I was trying pink peppermint stick for the first time, and as a die hard mint choc chip lover I felt like I was cheating on my husband with his best friend, but I don’t want this to weaken my position on the unacceptable consistency of the ice cream, because it was really bad, plus it was dripping down the ice cream technician’s hands so he knew it was dead on arrival. My (actual) partner, on the other hand, was delivered an ice cream of beautiful consistency, but near absent flavour. We took a calculated risk, discussing the distinct possibility of açai ice cream tasting of nothing, but ignored political and cultural influences of the moment and led with curiosity and not fear. But no, be fearful, the açai tastes like diluted dog milk. All-in-all, not the place for us, although it did have nice outside tables for me to drip my peppermint ice cream all over so that was a plus. Oh and it’s like $20 for 2 ice creams…

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

FAJ films

The best service

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nina Brajdic

Generous scoops. I really liked the chocolate flavor (I also tried acai), but there were pieces of ice inside the ice cream.
Also, really appreciate the bamboo cup

Michael Fritz

It was great

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mindy Ernst-Fournier

Great value, generous portions, convenient location and really good ice cream. I love the pistachio!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Banana Split, Homemade Waffle Cone, Waffle Bowl, Build Your Own Waffle

Ginny Macaulay

Great creamy ice cream. The young woman that waited on me was very pleasant.Worth a ride or walk out of town to indulge and enjoy creamy ice cream.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ruth Cadet

Great service, no line, good ice cream. Lots of flavors, you can mix and match. They sale the ice cream by the scoop and they have freshly made waffle bowls/cones. Nice treat after getting my eyebrows done right next door ?

Just Nixon

Great service and tasty ice cream. Can't go wrong!

Alexander Crowe

My kid’s favorite ice cream spot on the island, very friendly staff

Bill Christopher

Better than the Juce Bar, no line and lower price IF they’re open. Been there twice this week and they’ve been closed way before posted 7 pm closing time. :(

Gregory Scaffidi

Amazing ice cream. Try the whip cream!

Nguyen Jacky

Great service and tasty ice cream. Can't go wrong!

Jeremy Abbott

I loved the M&M Cookie Ice Cream Sandwich. It was huge, messy, and yummy!

Alicia paz

Beautiful

Loading...