Run away from this place. Hostess and server were unbelievably rude, the price is high for what you get. This place is pretends to be something its not (a place worth going).
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Georgiy Pitman
The food was wonderful as always . The service felt rushed and inattentive after discounting for the fact that it was Tuesday night and off-season . Have tried reaching out to the restaurant but received no response .
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 1
Paggie Tan
We made a Saturday 830pm reservation and still wasn’t seated by 9pm. Kept getting told “table is getting cleared” but watched it go to other people. Same lady kept asking for our names when we asked about our table. She told us we should just go somewhere else if we wanted to, and that the more I asked about my table, the more time I am taking away from her to do something else? 😂 we ended up going somewhere else, which sucked because we were a family celebrating an engagement
Seems like waiting for your rezy is a thing here? TLDR be prepared to wait if you’re thinking of a group dinner on a a weekend
Service: 1
Chris Fournier
We had a large party so it took a while to prepare our table, but we were able to squeeze into the tiny bar area for a drink while waited. The wait was worth it as the appetizers and entrees were delicious. Would recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Shutao Wang
Excellent food and service! Best in Nantucket!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
PIPER
If you need an espresso Martinez, fix this is your spot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lois Romano
This is hands down our favorite restaurant on the island. Food is spectacular. They need to get some of the service kinks out. But lately, one of the owners has been on hand to quickly rectify any issues- which goes a long way. Thank you, Cheryl! We will always be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Christopher Wolfe
Another fabulous dinner with friends at American Seasons
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Thomas Lloyd
Amazing food and lovely atmosphere. Our waiter forgot to enter one members food and then lied about it when confronted. Aside from that - the owner handled the situation appropriately. Ensure you double check when ordering your food that they have everything
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 1
Michelle Eby
We LOVE everything about Seasons...food is excellent, meticulously prepared, visually appealing and tantalizing to the taste buds. We ate here two nights in a row on our Na tucket visit just to enjoy most of the menu before leaving the island. Love the patio and the quaint seating by the window. Staff was so friendly and attentive. Fave dishes: whipped ricotta, gazpacho, risotto, buratta, roast scallops, beef strip loin with braised beef cheek, halibut, giannone chicken and the sticky pudding for dessert is outstanding! Servings are quite plentiful.
As sick as I have ever been in my life from food poisoning after eating at American Seasons on 7/1/2025! Based on this experience cannot recommend!
Chelsea Handegan
Very slow service. Waited at the host stand for several minutes and waited nearly 20 minutes to order despite only a handful of occupied tables. Ordered the “roasted carrots” as an appetizer and received exactly one carrot, cut in half, buried beneath endive. Outrageously expensive for the quality of food and service. I had for many years passed this charming building, but the interior leaves much to be desired
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Yana Belskaya
I liked the restaurant, it was my first time there, I had good impressions. Great dishes, beautiful atmosphere, polite staff
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Billie Monahan
We had Great meals. Meena was absolutely wonderful in helping us decide what to choose, from the main course, wine and desert. We will definitely be back.
Jessica Corr
Tried so hard to get this place a great review – service and everyone was A+ but paid $55 for food that didn’t really have any lobster and so the manager care much either - so just come here for drinks !
Run away from this place. Hostess and server were unbelievably rude, the price is high for what you get. This place is pretends to be something its not (a place worth going).
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
The food was wonderful as always . The service felt rushed and inattentive after discounting for the fact that it was Tuesday night and off-season . Have tried reaching out to the restaurant but received no response .
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 1
We made a Saturday 830pm reservation and still wasn’t seated by 9pm. Kept getting told “table is getting cleared” but watched it go to other people. Same lady kept asking for our names when we asked about our table. She told us we should just go somewhere else if we wanted to, and that the more I asked about my table, the more time I am taking away from her to do something else? 😂 we ended up going somewhere else, which sucked because we were a family celebrating an engagement
Seems like waiting for your rezy is a thing here? TLDR be prepared to wait if you’re thinking of a group dinner on a a weekend
Service: 1
We had a large party so it took a while to prepare our table, but we were able to squeeze into the tiny bar area for a drink while waited. The wait was worth it as the appetizers and entrees were delicious. Would recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Excellent food and service! Best in Nantucket!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
If you need an espresso Martinez, fix this is your spot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is hands down our favorite restaurant on the island. Food is spectacular. They need to get some of the service kinks out. But lately, one of the owners has been on hand to quickly rectify any issues- which goes a long way. Thank you, Cheryl! We will always be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Another fabulous dinner with friends at American Seasons
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing food and lovely atmosphere. Our waiter forgot to enter one members food and then lied about it when confronted. Aside from that - the owner handled the situation appropriately. Ensure you double check when ordering your food that they have everything
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 1
We LOVE everything about Seasons...food is excellent, meticulously prepared, visually appealing and tantalizing to the taste buds. We ate here two nights in a row on our Na tucket visit just to enjoy most of the menu before leaving the island. Love the patio and the quaint seating by the window. Staff was so friendly and attentive.
Fave dishes: whipped ricotta, gazpacho, risotto, buratta, roast scallops, beef strip loin with braised beef cheek, halibut, giannone chicken and the sticky pudding for dessert is outstanding! Servings are quite plentiful.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sticky Toffee Pudding, Roast Sea Scallops, Salad
Restaurantji Recommends
As sick as I have ever been in my life from food poisoning after eating at American Seasons on 7/1/2025! Based on this experience cannot recommend!
Very slow service. Waited at the host stand for several minutes and waited nearly 20 minutes to order despite only a handful of occupied tables. Ordered the “roasted carrots” as an appetizer and received exactly one carrot, cut in half, buried beneath endive. Outrageously expensive for the quality of food and service. I had for many years passed this charming building, but the interior leaves much to be desired
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
I liked the restaurant, it was my first time there, I had good impressions. Great dishes, beautiful atmosphere, polite staff
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had Great meals. Meena was absolutely wonderful in helping us decide what to choose, from the main course, wine and desert. We will definitely be back.
Tried so hard to get this place a great review – service and everyone was A+ but paid $55 for food that didn’t really have any lobster and so the manager care much either - so just come here for drinks !
Loading...