Millie's Mid-Island (Coffin Rotary)

Went here for lunch. Not too many people there, but had the best shrimp po’boy ever.

Food is always excellent, but that’s about it. Priced for table service, but everything is served in to go containers. Kiosks ask for a tip. Food has to be picked up at an outside window. This whole cost cutting concept feels incredibly lazy and a cash grab

We came in early may and it was chilly outside. So we sat in the covered patio with heaters, it made the experience 10/10 because we got very warmed up. I got the shrimp po’boy and my mom got the Mahi tacos both delicious and great size! We both shared the clam chowder also yum! Everyone was kind and food came fast. We had our little dog with us on the patio. Will come back.

My friends and I went here a few months ago when we were visiting Nantucket, not realizing it was only their 2nd day open! They were still working out a few kinks and we had to wait a bit to place our order, but the staff were very friendly and we didn't mind once we learned they had just opened! The tacos were delicious and the atmosphere is cute and close to where we were staying! I would definitely go back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Fast, fresh, tasty.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Good experience I've tried their sister restaurant and enjoyed it two, pulling up parking is a challenge they only have a certain amount of spaces allocated for the restaurant. They also have spaces allocated for pickup orders. They have an ice cream place attached or at least close by. I enjoyed the soup I gave the option to the cashier to choose. Play Stillwater and got my food in 15 minutes. Chowder was actually tender tasty the corn was sweet. This location is brand new this year and it seems to be going rather well

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

So glad we have a Millie's closer to home. Have stopped in a multiple times and the food is as expected - always great. Staff is friendly and engaging. Will keep going back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Love Millie’s and the new location is great as well. Adorable outdoor setup and cute ice cream truck in the lot as well.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Food and drinks were 5/5… on par with the original Millie’s.

Service was 5/5… No actual servers (waiting staff). TAKE OUT ONLY. Orders came out fast! Our group of 7 were in and out of this location faster than we’ve been able to get a table at the original location. One patron had an issue with her takeout while I was here and was irrationally upset. Staff was patient and handled the situation well.

Atmosphere was 4/5… nice aesthetics. Obvious that work was put into making the restaurant look nice. -1 for being on the edge of a busy rotary BUT the location serves it’s purpose for a convenient takeout location.

OVERALL, 5/5 takeout spot. It serves its purpose. The food was of high quality and staff was good. BUT if you are looking for a traditional sit down restaurant experience where you can relax and be waited on, just go to the original Millie’s.

Not many reviews on this new location yet so I thought confirmation should be provided this is strictly a TAKEOUT spot but you can eat here! Also a bit pricey for a takeout spot.

Parking: There were just enough parking spots on arrival but they were also probably at 10% capacity.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Brant Point, 40th Pole

Whatever they used to clean plates in the kitchen that rag they used, the fabric from the rag was all over my food. I picked out 10 pieces of fuzzy cotton from a napkin or rag used from the kitchen. That was all over my food. I didn’t even end up eating it I threw it in the trash respectfully where it belongs. First and last time

Food: 1

Love the expansion! The lobster roll was delicious, sweet chunks of lobster and tasty rice salad on the side. The standards - The Brant Point etc - were excellent as always.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Brant Point, Salsa Chips

$26 for 2 tacos at Rotary. You must be kidding!

This is one of the best places on the island to eat. The view is outstanding. The food is delicious and the service was fantastic.

Group of six of us biked here (ample bike parking), and had a fantastic lunch! Service from Matt was excellent. I highly recommend the grilled shrimp tacos.

We had great service and food—the chicken quesadillas, the steak tacos, and the fried shrimp sandwich! All were freshly made, delicious, and delivered as ordered! The view of the ocean from upstairs was fabulous!