Worst management. Rude staff, doesn’t care about the service. If I would have wanted to deal with rude staff and long lines, I would have gone to the Hamptons.
Mark Haller
Usually I am not a person that leaves reviews, but I would love some answers on this.
The pizza itself is a decent run of the mill pizza. Obviously for the price, I would love a bit more out of it, but I understand that prices on Nantucket can be a bit inflated.
With that being said, I really just need some answers on the Family Size salad. Once we saw the price of $90 for a salad, we were already perplexed by seeing that, but were optimistic on what the salad would be like.
For $90, you get a small tin tray of approximately 1 large grocery store bag of romaine, about 1 slice of bread cut up into strips for garlic bread, 3 lemon slices, and a soup cup bowl that was 1/3 full with dressing. Yes, I get the “it’s just Nantucket” with some inflated pricing, but this is something you can recreate for yourself over at the grocery store for maximum $10-15. I know we can sit here and say that we just shouldn’t have ordered it, but we were hoping we would at least get something that would satisfy us, but instead were given one of the saddest salads for the price I have ever seen.
I would love some sort of reasoning for the pricing on this. For $90 on a caesar salad, I would hope this thing would have blown me out of the water, but I would hope every single person moving forward would PLEASE save their money.
Tom Paskell
They were recommended by out Lyft driver. Glad he did. Pizza was great and Brian L is an awesome bartender.
galen hauth
We grabbed two seats at the bar. Melisa took care of us and we had an amazing time. Great food, good conversation and a cozy atmosphere. What more can you ask for?
Terry Arn
One of the best pizza’s I have ever had. Great crust and unique, fresh toppings. Service by Greg was also fantastic! $7 per coke/ice tea, AND an additional $7 per refill is absolutely wild work though!
Ryan Eby
Calamari tasted frozen and was greasy and breaded poorly. Pizza was good however
Philip Ross
Warm, friendly bar, restaurant and takeaway! Great Italian entrees and pizza as well as the best secret dish, strip steak with gnocchi!
Giuseppe Aprile
I'm Italian living in Italy and after spending a week in Nantucket with local food at the end of September I felt the urge to have a nice pizza and this is the place to be!
Crunchy, tasty and delicious! ???
Bravi ragazzi! ??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
matt davis
Love always coming back to this place. The food is awesome. the staff is awesome. Can't say enough good things about this place
Excellent Eggplant Parmagiana! Wonderful fire roasted pizza crust. Excellent attention by hostess who visited, took our order while waiting for a table, so all we needed was drinks and our food came quickly! A wonderful experience and Mother Nature provided a full moon!
The pizza had a reasonable crust but toppings were invisible, literally. when I took the large pizza I thought the box was empty and had to check. One piece of pepperoni on the entire pie and sausage so small it was not tastable. What has happened to this place?
Food: 1
Service: 3
antonio aransaenz
Best pizza on the island by far.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nina Brajdic
Nice and cozy restaurant - I really liked the artwork and the details. Warm atmosphere. Ricotta Manicotti were my favorite of our choices
Matthew Geery
The pizza is legit. If you get a chance to sit at the cozy bar- a steadfast bartender will take care of you.
Worst management. Rude staff, doesn’t care about the service. If I would have wanted to deal with rude staff and long lines, I would have gone to the Hamptons.
Usually I am not a person that leaves reviews, but I would love some answers on this.
The pizza itself is a decent run of the mill pizza. Obviously for the price, I would love a bit more out of it, but I understand that prices on Nantucket can be a bit inflated.
With that being said, I really just need some answers on the Family Size salad. Once we saw the price of $90 for a salad, we were already perplexed by seeing that, but were optimistic on what the salad would be like.
For $90, you get a small tin tray of approximately 1 large grocery store bag of romaine, about 1 slice of bread cut up into strips for garlic bread, 3 lemon slices, and a soup cup bowl that was 1/3 full with dressing. Yes, I get the “it’s just Nantucket” with some inflated pricing, but this is something you can recreate for yourself over at the grocery store for maximum $10-15. I know we can sit here and say that we just shouldn’t have ordered it, but we were hoping we would at least get something that would satisfy us, but instead were given one of the saddest salads for the price I have ever seen.
I would love some sort of reasoning for the pricing on this. For $90 on a caesar salad, I would hope this thing would have blown me out of the water, but I would hope every single person moving forward would PLEASE save their money.
They were recommended by out Lyft driver. Glad he did. Pizza was great and Brian L is an awesome bartender.
We grabbed two seats at the bar. Melisa took care of us and we had an amazing time. Great food, good conversation and a cozy atmosphere. What more can you ask for?
One of the best pizza’s I have ever had. Great crust and unique, fresh toppings. Service by Greg was also fantastic! $7 per coke/ice tea, AND an additional $7 per refill is absolutely wild work though!
Calamari tasted frozen and was greasy and breaded poorly. Pizza was good however
Warm, friendly bar, restaurant and takeaway! Great Italian entrees and pizza as well as the best secret dish, strip steak with gnocchi!
I'm Italian living in Italy and after spending a week in Nantucket with local food at the end of September I felt the urge to have a nice pizza and this is the place to be!
Crunchy, tasty and delicious! ???
Bravi ragazzi! ??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love always coming back to this place. The food is awesome. the staff is awesome. Can't say enough good things about this place
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meatball Parmesan Sub, Arincini, Garlic Bread, Italian, PI Pizza
Excellent Eggplant Parmagiana! Wonderful fire roasted pizza crust.
Excellent attention by hostess who visited, took our order while waiting for a table, so all we needed was drinks and our food came quickly! A wonderful experience and Mother Nature provided a full moon!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: PI Pizza, Margherita Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
Great pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza had a reasonable crust but toppings were invisible, literally. when I took the large pizza I thought the box was empty and had to check. One piece of pepperoni on the entire pie and sausage so small it was not tastable. What has happened to this place?
Food: 1
Service: 3
Best pizza on the island by far.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nice and cozy restaurant - I really liked the artwork and the details. Warm atmosphere.
Ricotta Manicotti were my favorite of our choices
The pizza is legit. If you get a chance to sit at the cozy bar- a steadfast bartender will take care of you.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: PI Pizza
Loading...