Not sure what's worse, paying $27 for a subpar cocktail with questionable ingredients or watching the bartender pick up our water glasses with her fingers inside them - before she filled them for our use. The "Italian" pizza was overly oily and salty; toppings were scant - a few paper-thin slices of pepperoni and a very small amount of what appeared to be sausage crumbs. The restaurant does not take reservations.
Marcus Zimmerman
The food was very good! Atmosphere was quite cozy & friendly but was on the loud side. I realize that is hard to control but just saying. Had a great chat with our neighbor at the next table. Would definitely return.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Bob Primmer
First time to Pi after 27 years coming to Ack. The pizza was great and service was even better. It's a really nice spot and now I understand why it of so popular. The outside dining on their garden is beautiful. They have a great bar as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
J Smith
Pizza was okay, but have a few complaints. First when we walked in we said hello to the bartender who just gave us a dirty look without saying anything. Then the hostess/waitress came up and she was nice but very quiet. We ordered a pizza, meatballs and garlic bread. The meatballs were tasty but for $16 3 tiny meatballs does not cut it especially when the meatball sub comes with 6 for $1 less. The garlic bread was priced at $7 on the menu but we were charged $8 and it was only partially seasoned with garlic and butter. The pizza was good but the crust was definitely passed the point of being well done and was actually burnt. Also adding pepperoni each slice had less than 1 actual pepperoni cut into strips. With how many amazing food options there are on the island there's really no point in giving them another try.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Xiris Durrant
Good, but not as good as past years. Also, finding a plastic bread clip in our food wasn't ideal. Fantastic pizza and eggplant parm. Been going here for the past 10 years. The quality has gone downhill this year though while the prices have increased dramatically. The last time we were there we found a plastic bread clip in my dad's Gnocci and they didn't even refund the dish. Just gave us some free cannolis. It's overall good, but not as good as it was.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Alan J. Trinkle
Kids and I voted this one of the best cheese pizzas we’ve had. Great service and wonderful outdoor table to enjoy it all at!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Larry Bean
Waited 2 hours for my takeout pizza to get a completely burnt pie and horrible assistance when I called to notify the restaurant.
Food: 1
Service: 1
Elicia Evans
Worst management. Rude staff, doesn’t care about the service. If I would have wanted to deal with rude staff and long lines, I would have gone to the Hamptons.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Mark Haller
Usually I am not a person that leaves reviews, but I would love some answers on this.
The pizza itself is a decent run of the mill pizza. Obviously for the price, I would love a bit more out of it, but I understand that prices on Nantucket can be a bit inflated.
With that being said, I really just need some answers on the Family Size salad. Once we saw the price of $90 for a salad, we were already perplexed by seeing that, but were optimistic on what the salad would be like.
For $90, you get a small tin tray of approximately 1 large grocery store bag of romaine, about 1 slice of bread cut up into strips for garlic bread, 3 lemon slices, and a soup cup bowl that was 1/3 full with dressing. Yes, I get the “it’s just Nantucket” with some inflated pricing, but this is something you can recreate for yourself over at the grocery store for maximum $10-15. I know we can sit here and say that we just shouldn’t have ordered it, but we were hoping we would at least get something that would satisfy us, but instead were given one of the saddest salads for the price I have ever seen.
I would love some sort of reasoning for the pricing on this. For $90 on a caesar salad, I would hope this thing would have blown me out of the water, but I would hope every single person moving forward would PLEASE save their money.
nhmom27
They say this is the best pizza place on the island and it was excellent. It was thin crust and the toppings were creative including clams and other unique offerings. It's a small place that fills up fast so I would go early if you are going for dinner.
Had heard good things about the restaurant. Was told to get there early since it is small and fills up quickly. We were seated by 5:15. We ordered a clam pizza to start then an eggplant parmigiana and lasagna for our main course. First the pizza came out lukewarm at best with dried up clams on top of the crust. There was no flavor and tasted like day old bad pizza. Which it could have been given we were the first clients of the evening. We had a delicious glass of super tuscan wine. Both main courses were lukewarm except the side of pasta which was overcooked but hot. The eggplant was mushy as was the lasagna. Neither had any flavor. Our waitress was lovely and attentive. Sadly it was ahuge disappointment.
Tom Paskell
They were recommended by out Lyft driver. Glad he did. Pizza was great and Brian L is an awesome bartender.
galen hauth
We grabbed two seats at the bar. Melisa took care of us and we had an amazing time. Great food, good conversation and a cozy atmosphere. What more can you ask for?
Terry Arn
One of the best pizza’s I have ever had. Great crust and unique, fresh toppings. Service by Greg was also fantastic! $7 per coke/ice tea, AND an additional $7 per refill is absolutely wild work though!
Ryan Eby
Calamari tasted frozen and was greasy and breaded poorly. Pizza was good however
Not sure what's worse, paying $27 for a subpar cocktail with questionable ingredients or watching the bartender pick up our water glasses with her fingers inside them - before she filled them for our use. The "Italian" pizza was overly oily and salty; toppings were scant - a few paper-thin slices of pepperoni and a very small amount of what appeared to be sausage crumbs. The restaurant does not take reservations.
The food was very good! Atmosphere was quite cozy & friendly but was on the loud side. I realize that is hard to control but just saying. Had a great chat with our neighbor at the next table. Would definitely return.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
First time to Pi after 27 years coming to Ack. The pizza was great and service was even better. It's a really nice spot and now I understand why it of so popular. The outside dining on their garden is beautiful. They have a great bar as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza was okay, but have a few complaints.
First when we walked in we said hello to the bartender who just gave us a dirty look without saying anything. Then the hostess/waitress came up and she was nice but very quiet. We ordered a pizza, meatballs and garlic bread. The meatballs were tasty but for $16 3 tiny meatballs does not cut it especially when the meatball sub comes with 6 for $1 less. The garlic bread was priced at $7 on the menu but we were charged $8 and it was only partially seasoned with garlic and butter. The pizza was good but the crust was definitely passed the point of being well done and was actually burnt. Also adding pepperoni each slice had less than 1 actual pepperoni cut into strips. With how many amazing food options there are on the island there's really no point in giving them another try.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Good, but not as good as past years. Also, finding a plastic bread clip in our food wasn't ideal. Fantastic pizza and eggplant parm. Been going here for the past 10 years. The quality has gone downhill this year though while the prices have increased dramatically. The last time we were there we found a plastic bread clip in my dad's Gnocci and they didn't even refund the dish. Just gave us some free cannolis. It's overall good, but not as good as it was.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Kids and I voted this one of the best cheese pizzas we’ve had. Great service and wonderful outdoor table to enjoy it all at!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Waited 2 hours for my takeout pizza to get a completely burnt pie and horrible assistance when I called to notify the restaurant.
Food: 1
Service: 1
Worst management. Rude staff, doesn’t care about the service. If I would have wanted to deal with rude staff and long lines, I would have gone to the Hamptons.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Usually I am not a person that leaves reviews, but I would love some answers on this.
The pizza itself is a decent run of the mill pizza. Obviously for the price, I would love a bit more out of it, but I understand that prices on Nantucket can be a bit inflated.
With that being said, I really just need some answers on the Family Size salad. Once we saw the price of $90 for a salad, we were already perplexed by seeing that, but were optimistic on what the salad would be like.
For $90, you get a small tin tray of approximately 1 large grocery store bag of romaine, about 1 slice of bread cut up into strips for garlic bread, 3 lemon slices, and a soup cup bowl that was 1/3 full with dressing. Yes, I get the “it’s just Nantucket” with some inflated pricing, but this is something you can recreate for yourself over at the grocery store for maximum $10-15. I know we can sit here and say that we just shouldn’t have ordered it, but we were hoping we would at least get something that would satisfy us, but instead were given one of the saddest salads for the price I have ever seen.
I would love some sort of reasoning for the pricing on this. For $90 on a caesar salad, I would hope this thing would have blown me out of the water, but I would hope every single person moving forward would PLEASE save their money.
They say this is the best pizza place on the island and it was excellent. It was thin crust and the toppings were creative including clams and other unique offerings. It's a small place that fills up fast so I would go early if you are going for dinner.
Restaurantji Recommends
Had heard good things about the restaurant. Was told to get there early since it is small and fills up quickly. We were seated by 5:15. We ordered a clam pizza to start then an eggplant parmigiana and lasagna for our main course. First the pizza came out lukewarm at best with dried up clams on top of the crust. There was no flavor and tasted like day old bad pizza. Which it could have been given we were the first clients of the evening. We had a delicious glass of super tuscan wine. Both main courses were lukewarm except the side of pasta which was overcooked but hot. The eggplant was mushy as was the lasagna. Neither had any flavor. Our waitress was lovely and attentive. Sadly it was ahuge disappointment.
They were recommended by out Lyft driver. Glad he did. Pizza was great and Brian L is an awesome bartender.
We grabbed two seats at the bar. Melisa took care of us and we had an amazing time. Great food, good conversation and a cozy atmosphere. What more can you ask for?
One of the best pizza’s I have ever had. Great crust and unique, fresh toppings. Service by Greg was also fantastic! $7 per coke/ice tea, AND an additional $7 per refill is absolutely wild work though!
Calamari tasted frozen and was greasy and breaded poorly. Pizza was good however
Loading...