Boy do I love Pi! Best kept secret is their steak and cheese for lunch. And the Steak and Gnocchi for dinner is simply amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Robert Coulter
This place is the bomb so that being said summertime it’s crazy. Even spring and fall are busy! Been here dozens of times if you like Italian food, I highly recommend it treat yourself to an awesome meal! Believe me, I have tried almost everything on their menu it’s awesome. Just give them a little patience when it’s super busy, thank you PI Pizzeria!
Buckeye Blitz
Small pub, pizza place, offers pickup as well as sit down. Had shrimp pizza and clam pizza, they gave us a cheese by mistake but corrected it fast. Huge cheese sticks.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
TJ Jackson
Gem pizza place with great Italian focused entrees.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Philip T
Very good pizza. Gluten free pizza!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Kay-Kay M.
Very quick and friendly service. The pepperoni pizza was great. We also got the Sicilian sub, which was good, but definitely could've used a bit more meat or at least a thinner bread. Overall, we enjoyed our time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Roy Root
Random pick for a place to eat on Nantucket, and it turned out to be a fantastic choice. Pizza was one of the best I have tried.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kristen D.
Pizza - 3 stars. Service - 1 star. Worst service on the island. Rude, inattentive server (Friday lunch) who couldn't be bothered to do her job.
Jon F
Best pizza in Nantucket. Delicious pasta too.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Greg King
This is what they call a Margherita pizza….???? For 25$$$$????Soggy, mushy, underbaked mess.Where’s the basil, the cheese?? This is a tomato sauce pie not Margherita…Pretentious pizza shop with no customer service skills.Nice job on ruining our pizza night…
Best Pie on the Island ? Must try to appreciate. Best steak on the island, I like how it’s cooked !
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
NBKFamilyOfFour
Our friends suggested Pi, and so glad they did. We arrived about 7:45 and waited about 20 minutes in the bar area, but the drinks were good. Once seated, we shared a couple pizzas (Rustica and Great Italian), an eggplant parm, and spaghetti with ragu sauce. All were great. Service was friendly and prices weren't bad considering you're on Nantucket. I'm sure we will return on a future visit!
Jane D.
We love the crust -- which is a true NYC-style crust, glutinous, thin and yes, foldable! -- but the toppings leave something to be desired. A Margherita ($21) came with no tomatoes, a thick slather of sauce (actually of good quality, but just in too high of a ratio), and almost no mozzarella. The little mozzarella on the pie was "fresh" as in it came in brick form rather than in shredded form -- but it wasn't tender as it ought to've been. And there may have been three 1/2 mm slivers of basil present. Pepperoni pizza ($23) included the most minute amounts of pepperoni, cut into thin strips and nearly invisible on the pie. Man. The crust does a lot for us -- but it can't go all the way!
Mark Mintman
It was a rainy day on the island. Came here with my wife and had a great time at the bar and ate some delicious pizza. Staff was great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
my_red_dress
Hubby and I went here for dinner. The waiter recommended a wine that we both liked. Hubby had pizza and I had the lasagna. The lasagna had spinach in it but the menu didn’t mention that and if I would have known I would have ordered something else. It wasn’t bad but I feel the spinach made the dish more watery and that is not my preference. The garlic bread was good and a good value with multiple pieces. Cute little spot with a cozy bar.
Boy do I love Pi! Best kept secret is their steak and cheese for lunch. And the Steak and Gnocchi for dinner is simply amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place is the bomb so that being said summertime it’s crazy. Even spring and fall are busy! Been here dozens of times if you like Italian food, I highly recommend it treat yourself to an awesome meal! Believe me, I have tried almost everything on their menu it’s awesome. Just give them a little patience when it’s super busy, thank you PI Pizzeria!
Small pub, pizza place, offers pickup as well as sit down. Had shrimp pizza and clam pizza, they gave us a cheese by mistake but corrected it fast. Huge cheese sticks.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gem pizza place with great Italian focused entrees.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very good pizza. Gluten free pizza!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Very quick and friendly service. The pepperoni pizza was great. We also got the Sicilian sub, which was good, but definitely could've used a bit more meat or at least a thinner bread. Overall, we enjoyed our time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Random pick for a place to eat on Nantucket, and it turned out to be a fantastic choice. Pizza was one of the best I have tried.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza - 3 stars. Service - 1 star. Worst service on the island. Rude, inattentive server (Friday lunch) who couldn't be bothered to do her job.
Best pizza in Nantucket. Delicious pasta too.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
This is what they call a Margherita pizza….???? For 25$$$$????Soggy, mushy, underbaked mess.Where’s the basil, the cheese?? This is a tomato sauce pie not Margherita…Pretentious pizza shop with no customer service skills.Nice job on ruining our pizza night…
Restaurantji Recommends
Best Pie on the Island ? Must try to appreciate. Best steak on the island, I like how it’s cooked !
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Our friends suggested Pi, and so glad they did. We arrived about 7:45 and waited about 20 minutes in the bar area, but the drinks were good. Once seated, we shared a couple pizzas (Rustica and Great Italian), an eggplant parm, and spaghetti with ragu sauce. All were great. Service was friendly and prices weren't bad considering you're on Nantucket. I'm sure we will return on a future visit!
We love the crust -- which is a true NYC-style crust, glutinous, thin and yes, foldable! -- but the toppings leave something to be desired. A Margherita ($21) came with no tomatoes, a thick slather of sauce (actually of good quality, but just in too high of a ratio), and almost no mozzarella. The little mozzarella on the pie was "fresh" as in it came in brick form rather than in shredded form -- but it wasn't tender as it ought to've been. And there may have been three 1/2 mm slivers of basil present. Pepperoni pizza ($23) included the most minute amounts of pepperoni, cut into thin strips and nearly invisible on the pie. Man. The crust does a lot for us -- but it can't go all the way!
It was a rainy day on the island. Came here with my wife and had a great time at the bar and ate some delicious pizza. Staff was great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hubby and I went here for dinner. The waiter recommended a wine that we both liked. Hubby had pizza and I had the lasagna. The lasagna had spinach in it but the menu didn’t mention that and if I would have known I would have ordered something else. It wasn’t bad but I feel the spinach made the dish more watery and that is not my preference. The garlic bread was good and a good value with multiple pieces. Cute little spot with a cozy bar.