Sophie T's Pizza
7 Dave St, Nantucket
(508) 325-6265
Customers' Favorites
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Bacon Chicken Pizza
Caesar Salad
Menu
Photos
+53 photos
+52 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
The best place to a VERY good pizza with out the insane prices seen at every other pizza place on the island. Sometimes a family just wants a pizza and not a gastronomic experience. This seems like a family owned and friendly spot. Strongly recommend.
Pleasantly surprised! They really do serve the closet thing to NY style pizza on the island. The Greek pizza was superb and well- worth the wait. We went back the next day for their chicken Caesar salads, which were also excellent.
Don't come here expecting NY pizza, lol.
Came here and got a couple of slices. Make sure the cashier knows you only want one slice of 2-meat pizza or call it pep/sausage instead. I didn't realize her mistake until I had left; just figured the prices island-high.
In any case, the crust is very doughy, but soft. Plenty of sauce, cheese, and topping. It's about $5/slice, which I think its the going price these days.
Goes...
Came here and got a couple of slices. Make sure the cashier knows you only want one slice of 2-meat pizza or call it pep/sausage instead. I didn't realize her mistake until I had left; just figured the prices island-high.
In any case, the crust is very doughy, but soft. Plenty of sauce, cheese, and topping. It's about $5/slice, which I think its the going price these days.
Goes...
You May Also Like
Wicked Island Bakery - 7 Bayberry Ct
![]()
Bakery, Pet Friendly, Gluten-Free, Vegetarian
The Chicken Box - 16 Dave St
![]()
Bar, Dive Bar
Island Kitchen | Restaurant & Catering - 1 Chins Way
![]()
American, Seafood, Healthy, New American, Vegetarian