Steamboat Wharf Pizza
10 Broad St, Nantucket
(508) 228-1131
Order Online
Recent Reviews
No frills pizza spot but this is the closest to "NYC style" pizza on the island. Cash only if you go in person but you can pay via cc if you order for pick up online. Toppings are expensive and aren't the best quality (ex. canned mushrooms) but that won't stop me from ordering a plain pizza when the craving hits.
I'll eat just about any pizza, and it's all good in its own way, but I really didn't care for the pizza I had here. Good things: generous with the toppings, and ready fairly quickly when other places couldn't even take any more orders.
This very close to Long Island pizza spot is not far from the Steamship Authority ferry dock. It is take away only and we had slices twice. If we knew then what we know now about their “Buy two slices and save” special we’d have gotten a few more! This is a no frills pizza place with an apparently large following of regulars. Need a quick snack, a slice here will fit the bill!