Plum Island Kitchen

134 Northern Blvd, Newbury
(978) 572-5265

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Ariel Reches

Best lobster roll you can get

Scott Scheibner

The breakfast sandwiches are amazing and the staff was so friendly. Highly recommended place to go.

Rosemary Mannino

Food was outstanding. Very flavorful and authentic. Fresh and made to order. We had spring rolls and a Tai basil bowl. We will be back.

Noah Fields

Great pizza, easy to order for take out on the phone. Highly recommend

Mahadev Shastri

Arguably the best pizza I've ever had. Ask for the pizza with the white sauce - never tasted anything like it until coming to this place. Can't go wrong with any pizza on their menu though.

Tara Van Skiver

Great little place. Nice food, good staff and a good place to get some great cold brew....er coffee that is.

Monica Maganzini

The food is great and made fresh.

rich groski

Pizza is ok, nothing to rave about. When I called the girl answering the phone put me on hold for 6 minutes to find out if I could order 3 pizzas.What restaurant closes at 7pm? This one!

Michael Rabideau

Best....fish sandwich I have had in 7 years of being on the coast of NH. Haddock, fresh...simple tartar sauce, lettuce etc. The grilled bun made it great!

Juan Robles

Great service, great customer service. The Robles family from Ct. Loves it here. We'll definitely coming back here again & again & again. Thank you guys the food was great aka triple cheeseburger. Happy holidays to you and family from the Robles family. Thank you for everything

luke maccarthy

This place has the best food on the island hands down! The pizza is amazing! Especially the buffalo chicken and the PI Lighthouse pizza! The staff is great and super friendly. Daos Thai food is always a delight! A must try when visiting the island or living here year round. You won’t be disappointed in anything you order here!

Diane Shaw Sawyer

This is a definite go to place on Plum Island if you want to have a great lunch. They also have a cooler full of take-home foods like chicken pot pies, pad thai noodles, amazing stuffed shells with sauce and a creamy delicious mac and cheese. They carry Meats from Tuckaway Tavern that are amazing for grilling! We love the steak tips and the chicken tenders. They have homemade muffins for breakfast and ice creams for dessert. We're so glad that we live close to PI Kitchen during this difficult time with Covid-19. They have been one of our go to places through all of this. And run by the nicest group of people that are following all protocol to keep their establishment sanitized.

Chuck Helin

P.I. Kitchen serving up delicious sandwiches on the fly. If your on the Island and don't stop here it's your loss.

Nicole V

Breakfast, lunch and dinner homemade with love for pickup or order to go. Right in plum island near the beach. Pick up your fresh lunch or breakfast sandwich hit the beach. Or call in pizza or there basil bowl for dinner. Family owned and just a great feel. We were on vacation and I googled breakfast plum island and this didn’t come up I just happened to drive and stop and wow so glad we did. We got dinner the next night and eat it on the beach. Hopefully now more ppl will know this place is here couse it’s delicious and convenient!!

L p

Breakfast sandwich is bangin! I ordered it with the steak and American cheese, 10/10 recommend. Might have to go back for lunch!

Loading...