Black Lantern Tavern

1 Greenside Way N Suite 4, Plymouth
(508) 273-7127

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jessica Quatromoni

The place and location are great. Service was great. Its the food that needs some tweaking. More sauce, more salt, just more flavor would be huge. High hopes they figure it out because its great having eating establishments in the neighborhood.

Christine Richards

Really loved this place after a not so great experience. The owner gave us a gift certificate to try again. We loved it!!

Kim Juliet Healy

Sydney was our server and she was PHENOMENAL!!! So attentive, friendly and nice. Fish tacos and oysters were 100/10 so delicious. I tried the new addition to the menu; spicy mango cocktail w ghost peppers and it was 🌶️spicy🌶️ in the best way!! Can’t wait to go back ❤️❤️❤️

Ashley

Disappointed with the Mother's Day buffet. Dry tough meat, dry old brownies for dessert, tasteless fruit, cubed carrots for veggies.. overall, embarrassing.

Eric Claiborne

Great atmosphere clean fast service and hot food

Alicia Kearney (A.K.Explorah)

First visit. Cute little place. Drinks, app and meal were tasty especially on a rainy cold day in New England. Worth the visit and don't worry that it's nestled in a neighborhood. It's not just for them.

Rocco Carlino

The food was average at best. Short ribs lacked flavor. Service was very good.

Angelique Picanco

Black Lantern Tavern is a solid local spot that delivers on all fronts. The food is consistent, with hearty favorites that hit the mark every time. The atmosphere is welcoming and relaxed, perfect for a casual night out. Service is friendly and attentive, making for an all-around enjoyable experience. Definitely worth a visit if you're in the area

Jen Corna

Amazing food and drinks. Service was over and above. Very eclectic atmosphere. Can't wait to come back again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rob Lester

Laid back, vibes are good, clean, convenient, always popular but never wait or feel crowded and the food is great!

Parking: Parking in front, don’t forget there is a parking lot in the back by the playground

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings, Wings, Chicken Parm, Caprese Panini, Teriyaki Steak Tips

Charles Roy

Excellent venue at Redbrook... meets and exceeds our expectations...

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pinot Grigio, House Salad, Wings, Pretzel Charcuterie

Nate Gayman

We had brunch and it was amazing! The drinks and the food we're creative and delicious. The staff was excellent-cheerful and attentive. They even had live music! A+

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nicole Dunn

This place was beautiful! Obsessed with the decor and ambiance. Live music on a Sunday brunch! The brunch drinks were 10/10 and a top tier Bloody Mary! The food was fresh and delicious. We went with a large group and everything came out together. Every dish looked better than the next! The French toast with berries was amazing! Brioche bread! The owner greeted each table and was wonderful. This will be a go to anytime we are in the area!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

John Duggan

Exceptional experience! Food was delicious! Carmelized scallops, vegetable risotto, broiled cod and vegetables were fantastic. Staff are welcoming and knowledgeable. Warm vibe topped off our first visit. Will be back soon! Highly recommend!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

d olson

Tried to go. Says they close at 11. Pulled in at 840 and a guy ran and locked the door as we walked up to it and then stared at us from the window. Still plenty of people inside. He could have told us they were closing early rather than just locking the door on us, would have been the polite thing to do. Heard about the bad service but wanted to try it. Unfortunately they lived up to their reputation. Too bad.

Loading...