Cape Batter Bakeshop & Cakery

RESIDENTIAL BAKERY NOT WALK IN, 16 Brigantine Cir, Plymouth
(646) 285-7892

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Nicole Bauer

I have used Cape Batter for so many occasions. Initially I found her when looking for cookies for my SIL baby sprinkle, and from there it was multiple birthday parties for my nieces and nephews, and fast forward to using her for our wedding day. Not only is Natasha incredibly talented with what she does, the cookies actually taste PHENOMENAL. You’ve had those decorated cookies before that have no flavor I’m sure. Not here at cape batter. Every cookie is so delicious I could eat all of them. From the taste, quality, design, creativity, presentation she is just absolutely incredible. From decorative cookies for parties, to her macaroons, to the cake pops. You literally cannot go wrong. We are so lucky to have her so close and I literally never order from any other baker since I found her 2/3 years ago!!!

Kaitlyn Frost

Natasha did custom cookies and cupcakes for a bridal shower I was hosting for my sister and they came out amazing! I sent inspiration of what I was looking for she delivered. The whole process was easy and communication was great. I would highly recommend Cape Batter to anyone!

Caroline H

I ordered some treats for Valentine's Day and could not be more pleased. The macarons and the PB trifles are perfection! The rest of Natasha's gallery looks extraordinary. I cannot wait to order more treats from her in the future. Shop small and support small/local businesses!

Courtney Kirschner

Absolutely LOVE everything from Cape Batter! We ordered macarons for my daughter’s 10th birthday and they were amazing. They were delicious but also printed with her name and Happy Birthday. Natasha was wonderful to work with and even made her a Big Mac with candles to celebrate. Completely made her birthday.! Highly recommend.

Denise Pereira

I found Cape Batter on a local social media page. Being from the area I knew I wanted to support a local small business. Boy did she not disappoint. I had the most delicious macaroons and Lambeth Tree Cake: flavor was Coconut Birgadeira! This was my favorite!
Everything was so fresh nothing frozen. If you have an opportunity to buy one thing I’m not the right person to tell you what to order because I want to order her whole menu next time.
10 ⭐️’s from this family!

LUKE DUKE

Wonderful, family owned and operated small business. Get out and support your local small businesses!!!! If we help each other we can rein this stuff back in, let's help AMERICA. SHOP LOCAL, SUPPORT LOCAL COMPANIES AND CLUBS!!!!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cookies

Jessica Lindsay

Natasha crafted our wedding cake and French macarons for our dessert table—they were absolutely beautiful and matched our vision perfectly. Everything was delicious, of course! She was always quick to answer questions and a pleasure to work with. We can't recommend her enough for any sweet treat needs!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lani Riley

We ordered a bunch of mini cheesecakes for our wedding and they were delicious and so cute! Natasha was great to work with. We'll definitely be ordering more treats from her in the future!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mich Scarpone

I HIGHLY recommend cape batter for all of your dessert needs! Natasha was amazing to work with from the start and listened to all my visions that I had for my bridal shower macaron favors! They were incredible and fresh and not to mention the little details on the packaging made my day so special! If you haven’t ordered from here, you are seriously missing out!!!!!! We love cape batter & can’t wait to order again :)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kelsi Viau

Cape Batter has been my go to for special treats, birthday cakes and party favors! I cannot recommend Natasha enough. The design process is always on point & exactly what I want, the delivery is timely and the wrapping is so beautifully done! It is so helpful to have Cape Batter as a reliable source!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lori McConnell

Absolute perfection!!

Sierra Basegio

Natasha with Cape Batter from start to finish was one of the most lovely individuals to work with for our July 22nd wedding in Plymouth, MA. My husband grew up in Plymouth, MA, and planning a wedding from across the country had its own unique stressors. From our first phone call she was kind, thoughtful, and very professional. She had many wonderful suggestions which made decision-making even easier! I don’t think there was ever a time I had to wait to hear from her, she was so on top of everything and even checked in regularly beforehand to see if there were any changes she needed to know about.Now let’s talk about her desserts! I LOVE cookies and cupcakes, and I also love to bake, and let me tell you I was so happy and impressed by the quality and the flavor of the desserts she made for our wedding. She baked cookies for our welcome dinner (chocolate chip sea salt and chip batter) and holy smokes they were fantastic! For our wedding reception, Natasha baked cupcakes (red velvet, carrot cake, and chocolate truffle) as well as French macaroons (lemon and raspberry)… my mouth is drooling just thinking about how delicious it all was. We luckily even managed to save ourselves a couple to enjoy the following day. Every one of our friends and family said how delicious each treat they tasted was. One of my best friends was literally doing a happy dance on the dance floor while holding each of the two flavors of macaroons!I highly recommend you order desserts with Cape Batter. I’m definitely going to look into ordering cookies from her to mail out to California for any parties we throw back home. Thank you Natasha for making this time in our lives even more special. ♥️

Donna Koerner

I had the pleasure of first tasting cape batter's treats at a wedding. When it came to my girls birthday party Natasha was quick to respond to my custom order. I ordered two dozen cookies and they exceeded my expectations. They were decorated beautifully. I provided inspiration pictures and cape batter put there own spin on it which I loved. They not only looked amazing but tasted amazing as well. I live out of state and delivery was easy. I would definitely recommend cape batter for any custom orders.

M Webber

Beautiful and delicious. Easy to order and pick up.

Lauren Horgan

Natasha is amazing! She’s very prompt with emails and communication and the cupcakes and cookies she made for our baby shower were so adorable and yummy! We had a safari themed baby shower and she made the cupcakes and cookies match our theme and colors perfectly! Definitely reach out to her for any upcoming event you may have !

Loading...