Used Guilty for my wedding cake service through the Barker House and it was 10/10! The service with our tasting was amazing. We did a small cake with 5 different flavor cupcakes and so many of our guests raved about how much they loved the dessert. Thank you Guilty Bakery!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ty & Claire
We loved working with the team at Guilty Bakery when looking to create our perfect wedding cake! The tasting process was professional, informative, and we walked out feeling like our voices were heard. We haven't gotten photos back yet, but the cake was gorgeous and delicious. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Jenna
I ordered a cake for my baby shower and the cake I received was not at all what I requested (please see attached photos for reference). The cake was slapped together and that’s putting it nicely. Dying flowers were atop the cake (I didn’t ask for florals) and barely any of the other of details I asked for (I included a picture of the cake I sent guilty). The more I think about it, this may have been a cake that someone else ordered and cancelled and guilty repurposed. I called the business to resolve the issue and whomever I spoke with was defensive and offered no viable solutions. She did say she would call me sometime in the near future to get my cc information and issue me a partial refund…
Samantha Foley
We used Guilty for our wedding and they did a phenomenal job with our cake and dessert bar. Treats were plentiful and so delicious!! They were great to work with from the tasting to delivery and execution. Thanks, Guilty Bakery team!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Madeline Shea
Guilty Bakery did the cake for our wedding. They also made cookie bars and cookie sandwiches. Our guests were raving about them. 10/10 would recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Emily Goodridge
Had a baked good here I still dream about….delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kelly Mitchell
We couldn’t be happier with the wedding cake and cupcakes from Guilty Bakery! From the moment we had our tasting session, we knew we were in good hands. The cake was a true masterpiece—beautifully designed and exactly what we envisioned for our special day. The flavors were incredible; each bite was moist, rich, and perfectly balanced. The cupcakes were a big hit with our guests, who are still raving about how delicious they were. We highly recommend Guilty Bakery for any special occasion. Thank you for making our wedding day even more memorable!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Darcy Randall
We worked with Guilty Bakery for my wedding in April! We got so many compliments on the desserts! They were so delicious!! Guilty Bakery was easy to work with and provided us with an amazing assortment of desserts! Our cake was also gorgeous!
T H
Cake I purchased was really dry. And the cake overall did not taste very good.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Genny Paige
BEST CAKE EVER!!! I got my wedding cake from here and they did an amazing job! Everyone loved the cake and it was perfect. Highly recommend them for weddings! Our wedding cake was carrot cake on top, lemon raspberry in the middle, and chocolate mocha on the bottom!The cake was very moist and the frosting and fillings were perfectly balanced and everything worked together.
This place is awful!!! I got married last August and went for cake tasting at the end of April. The cakes we tried were delicious and we went with the lemon raspberry flavor. During the appointment we discussed visions and inspirations for our cake and the girl said they could totally do it and she said they would get back to us with a quote in a couple of days. I kept checking in week after week to see when she would send that quote because we were running out of time. Finally, it took them an entire month to get back to me. I obviously didn't see the cake bafore the wedding day and when it was time to cut the cake, I saw it and was mortified. For reference, I attached our inspiration pictures and the picture of the cake they made is. Besides the fact that our cake looked NOTHING like the inspo which is fine because it's just an inspiration, it literally looked hideous. The "ruffles" looked like slices of deli meat and cheddar cheese! I was so embarrassed by this cake. I reached out to them for some refund. I paid almost $1300 for this cake and an extra sheet cake, the girl offered me $300 and really didn't care at all that we hated the cake and were so sad that this was the wedding cake we served and were so excited for. I just don't understand why she wasn't honest and said the details I asked for couldn't be done and offered alternatives or gave me suggestions. It honestly looked like they forgot to make the cake and did it last minute and were rushed. If you want a beautiful and professionally made cake, don't go there. Oh and by the way, their macarons look really bad, they're lumpy and big like whoopie pies. That's how you know they're not professional bakers and it really should've been a red flag as soon as I walked in.
Service: 1
Lily Briar
I was quite disappointed by the Mashpee location. The cupcakes were so cold that frosting was frozen! It fell right off when my child bit it. It tasted as though it was in a freezer for quite some time. And there are no labels on any of the items so it makes ordering confusing.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Bisan Alhmood
The driest oldest cake I’ve ever tasted. I was excited to try out the gorgeous cakes they had available. I got the raspberry jam cake for same day gathering, it looked stunning. Served it less than 3 hours of purchasing it and as soon as we made the first cut, the frosting broke off the cake like it was a cast!!! The sponge cake was sooo dry and the buttercream filling was too sweet! It was the biggest disappointment! I wonder how many days was it sitting in the fridge at the store before I purchased it? I would say at least 10 days going off how dry and stone-like it was. I was so embarrassed infront of my guests as if I served them old cake. Never stepping foot in that bakery again.
Food: 1
Kayla Lithgow
My partner and I went in for a last second cake for my birthday, and we were amazed at the selection! There are cakes ready made, sandwich cookies, macarons (and macaroons!), and all sorts of other treats that are displayed perfectly. We ordered one of each macaron, oatmeal cream pies, two cake pops, and a small vanilla/vanilla cake for a party we're hosting. The service was amazing and fast, the prices were totally reasonable, and the baked goods were amazing.If you're looking for a bakery to try out, you have to go to Guilty Bakery! We're so glad that we did stop in and see what kind of selection that they had. The cake is perfectly soft and the frosting is the right amount of sweet. The macarons are baked to perfection with just the right amount of filling. You can taste the care that they put into their products!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brian Egan
Not a fan of places that don’t display prices $$$$ peanut butter cookies fell
Used Guilty for my wedding cake service through the Barker House and it was 10/10! The service with our tasting was amazing. We did a small cake with 5 different flavor cupcakes and so many of our guests raved about how much they loved the dessert. Thank you Guilty Bakery!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We loved working with the team at Guilty Bakery when looking to create our perfect wedding cake! The tasting process was professional, informative, and we walked out feeling like our voices were heard. We haven't gotten photos back yet, but the cake was gorgeous and delicious. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
I ordered a cake for my baby shower and the cake I received was not at all what I requested (please see attached photos for reference). The cake was slapped together and that’s putting it nicely. Dying flowers were atop the cake (I didn’t ask for florals) and barely any of the other of details I asked for (I included a picture of the cake I sent guilty). The more I think about it, this may have been a cake that someone else ordered and cancelled and guilty repurposed. I called the business to resolve the issue and whomever I spoke with was defensive and offered no viable solutions. She did say she would call me sometime in the near future to get my cc information and issue me a partial refund…
We used Guilty for our wedding and they did a phenomenal job with our cake and dessert bar. Treats were plentiful and so delicious!! They were great to work with from the tasting to delivery and execution. Thanks, Guilty Bakery team!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Guilty Bakery did the cake for our wedding. They also made cookie bars and cookie sandwiches. Our guests were raving about them. 10/10 would recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Had a baked good here I still dream about….delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We couldn’t be happier with the wedding cake and cupcakes from Guilty Bakery! From the moment we had our tasting session, we knew we were in good hands. The cake was a true masterpiece—beautifully designed and exactly what we envisioned for our special day. The flavors were incredible; each bite was moist, rich, and perfectly balanced. The cupcakes were a big hit with our guests, who are still raving about how delicious they were. We highly recommend Guilty Bakery for any special occasion. Thank you for making our wedding day even more memorable!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We worked with Guilty Bakery for my wedding in April! We got so many compliments on the desserts! They were so delicious!! Guilty Bakery was easy to work with and provided us with an amazing assortment of desserts! Our cake was also gorgeous!
Cake I purchased was really dry. And the cake overall did not taste very good.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
BEST CAKE EVER!!! I got my wedding cake from here and they did an amazing job! Everyone loved the cake and it was perfect. Highly recommend them for weddings! Our wedding cake was carrot cake on top, lemon raspberry in the middle, and chocolate mocha on the bottom!The cake was very moist and the frosting and fillings were perfectly balanced and everything worked together.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
This place is awful!!! I got married last August and went for cake tasting at the end of April. The cakes we tried were delicious and we went with the lemon raspberry flavor. During the appointment we discussed visions and inspirations for our cake and the girl said they could totally do it and she said they would get back to us with a quote in a couple of days. I kept checking in week after week to see when she would send that quote because we were running out of time. Finally, it took them an entire month to get back to me. I obviously didn't see the cake bafore the wedding day and when it was time to cut the cake, I saw it and was mortified. For reference, I attached our inspiration pictures and the picture of the cake they made is. Besides the fact that our cake looked NOTHING like the inspo which is fine because it's just an inspiration, it literally looked hideous. The "ruffles" looked like slices of deli meat and cheddar cheese! I was so embarrassed by this cake. I reached out to them for some refund. I paid almost $1300 for this cake and an extra sheet cake, the girl offered me $300 and really didn't care at all that we hated the cake and were so sad that this was the wedding cake we served and were so excited for. I just don't understand why she wasn't honest and said the details I asked for couldn't be done and offered alternatives or gave me suggestions. It honestly looked like they forgot to make the cake and did it last minute and were rushed. If you want a beautiful and professionally made cake, don't go there. Oh and by the way, their macarons look really bad, they're lumpy and big like whoopie pies. That's how you know they're not professional bakers and it really should've been a red flag as soon as I walked in.
Service: 1
I was quite disappointed by the Mashpee location. The cupcakes were so cold that frosting was frozen! It fell right off when my child bit it. It tasted as though it was in a freezer for quite some time. And there are no labels on any of the items so it makes ordering confusing.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
The driest oldest cake I’ve ever tasted. I was excited to try out the gorgeous cakes they had available. I got the raspberry jam cake for same day gathering, it looked stunning. Served it less than 3 hours of purchasing it and as soon as we made the first cut, the frosting broke off the cake like it was a cast!!! The sponge cake was sooo dry and the buttercream filling was too sweet! It was the biggest disappointment! I wonder how many days was it sitting in the fridge at the store before I purchased it? I would say at least 10 days going off how dry and stone-like it was. I was so embarrassed infront of my guests as if I served them old cake. Never stepping foot in that bakery again.
Food: 1
My partner and I went in for a last second cake for my birthday, and we were amazed at the selection! There are cakes ready made, sandwich cookies, macarons (and macaroons!), and all sorts of other treats that are displayed perfectly. We ordered one of each macaron, oatmeal cream pies, two cake pops, and a small vanilla/vanilla cake for a party we're hosting. The service was amazing and fast, the prices were totally reasonable, and the baked goods were amazing.If you're looking for a bakery to try out, you have to go to Guilty Bakery! We're so glad that we did stop in and see what kind of selection that they had. The cake is perfectly soft and the frosting is the right amount of sweet. The macarons are baked to perfection with just the right amount of filling. You can taste the care that they put into their products!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Not a fan of places that don’t display prices $$$$ peanut butter cookies fell
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Loading...