This would rate five stars if it had parking. Otherwise terrific food with a limited menu. Also the dining area is nice but basic. Lacks the ambiance due to its location but the open kitchen helps. Service was excellent with dutiful knowledge of wines and pairings. I would go there again and again. Thoroughly enjoyed the food as usual; no unpleasant surprises.
Ash
a regular favorite for my family and i. incredible food and service in a tiny hole in the wall spot. you can see the chefs cook while you dine. the chicken saltimbocca is incredible! couldn't recommend tuscany tavern enough.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Peteie M.
Food is very good ambience is cool, especially with the piano player. unfortunately they do not have enough staff to operate.First time we went and there was only one person in the front of the house who also had to tend bar. That was our first time and felt it was out of the norm. We felt bad for the person left to hang out to dry. Where was management to come and help? second time we had a nice dining experience at the bar. third time we went at 530 bar was open but they couldn't seat us because they had staffing issues. Food is good but massive management issues. Plymouth has too many good restaurants to waste time and money on a place with no service. Get it together.
Susan L.
the food and service was impeccable. The restaurant was delightful,a small , quiet spot reminiscent of local neighborhood restaurants in cities around the country. it had old world charm with Frank Sinatra (who else) playing in the background. The kitchen was visible to the dining room which gave it a homey feel. This is a spot that could be a regular for many dates. overall, delicious and quiet.
Chris Oreilly
Very nice dinner. Tight space, but that's part of the charm.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
James P.
Great italian food. Small and not too busy. Will go again. Yelp requires more characters
Chris B.
Wife's Birthday Dinner in Plymouth, started with some Fresh Bread and Olive Oil, we had Caesar Salad for an Appetizer, our Main Dishes were the Wife had: PENNE ALLA SICILIANA and the Husband had: PENNE ALLA BOSCAIOLA, also for Dessert we had a Cannoli to split, sorry no picture of the Dessert, everything was fresh, delicious, and very reasonable price too, we will definitely be going back to eat there again, great little Italian Restaurant in Downtown North Plymouth...small in there but really good!!!!
Frank V.
The food and service are excellent but the ambiance is lacking. So long as you are not making this a celebration dinner you should be very happy with your experience. It is a VERY small dining area (6-8 tables) due to the fact it shares its space with the kitchen which is in full view in the rear. So everything feels a bit tight/cozy. So call ahead and make a reservation if for no other reason than to avoid a long wait outside.
Stephen S.
First time visit to the Tuscany Tavern. A very quaint location in North Plymouth. Reservations recommended due to its size. TT has been around for a long time and has been serving tremendous Italian food to the community. Food was delicious and the service was friendly and good. I'll add photos at a later time.
Celebrated my dads birthday here and it was a perfect night from beginning to end. Staff was attentive and the food was amazing. Took us right back to Italy! The waitress even brought a bowl of ice cream with a candle in it, after my father said he was too full for dessert (but apparently not too full for ice cream!!)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Susan Polyard
HUGE DISAPPOINTMENT to say the very least. It was my suggestion for a party of 5 and a true embarrassment. I’ve had kids meals offering more food. I’ve had signature dining in N.Y, L.A, Chicago, Orlando and this was not signature dining. The price is WAY out of range for the offering. This was an absolute one and done. If I was at the restaurant rather than ordering to go I would’ve walked out. Save your hard earned money!! You want actual plate details we’ll be happy to share including the missing items. After forking over $150.00 family is now heading out for food!!
Amy Golden
I was taken to the Tuscany Tavern on my birthday, and based on reviews, I was excited. We walked into a partially draw curtain and waited at what we thought was a hostess station. After about 5 minutes, I poked my head in the dining area, which was sort of awkward because I felt like I was intruding on the diners that were sitting at that table. I was then asked, "Do you have a reservation" from across the dining area from the person standing in the kitchen. She then pointed to the table in the corner and said, "That's your table," so we sat ourselves down. We ordered the Caprese Salad $13.95, which was very basic and lacked salt. The soup of the day was Pasta e fagioli, I was excited to try this because I've been to many Italian restaurants and love tasting the chefs version of this soup. Well, it was a clear broth with a few diced carrots and did not have any beans in the soup. My husband said it tasted like Progresso Soup from a can, and I actually agree. My husband ordered the SPAGHETTI ALLE VONGOLE, $22.95 and he liked it. My daughter ordered FETTUCCINE ALLA BOLOGNESE, $24.95 and we would say it was OK. I ordered the SPAGHETTI ALLA CARBONARA $20.95. The dish that was placed in front of me was awful. It had what I believe were shallots that were partly raw and still crunchy, the sauce that coated the pasta was not a creamy sauce it was bits of scrambled egg with rubbery bacon and not flavor of mascarpone or parmesan cheese that was in the menu's description. The one waitress did a decent job, considering she was waiting on 6 out of the 8 tables herself. I would not personally recommend this restaurant. The prices they are charging for food that is mediocre at best.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 3
Dean Fossella
They don’t know the difference between chicken and veal and when they serve you veal and you tell them that’s not what you ordered they purposely make you wait to prove a point that the customer is always wrong.
Wayne J.
Food is perfect . Atmosphere is great always a good meal . We have been here on many date nights waitresses are nice and attentive
This would rate five stars if it had parking. Otherwise terrific food with a limited menu. Also the dining area is nice but basic. Lacks the ambiance due to its location but the open kitchen helps. Service was excellent with dutiful knowledge of wines and pairings. I would go there again and again. Thoroughly enjoyed the food as usual; no unpleasant surprises.
a regular favorite for my family and i. incredible food and service in a tiny hole in the wall spot. you can see the chefs cook while you dine. the chicken saltimbocca is incredible! couldn't recommend tuscany tavern enough.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food is very good ambience is cool, especially with the piano player. unfortunately they do not have enough staff to operate.First time we went and there was only one person in the front of the house who also had to tend bar. That was our first time and felt it was out of the norm. We felt bad for the person left to hang out to dry. Where was management to come and help? second time we had a nice dining experience at the bar. third time we went at 530 bar was open but they couldn't seat us because they had staffing issues. Food is good but massive management issues. Plymouth has too many good restaurants to waste time and money on a place with no service. Get it together.
the food and service was impeccable. The restaurant was delightful,a small , quiet spot reminiscent of local neighborhood restaurants in cities around the country. it had old world charm with Frank Sinatra (who else) playing in the background. The kitchen was visible to the dining room which gave it a homey feel. This is a spot that could be a regular for many dates. overall, delicious and quiet.
Very nice dinner. Tight space, but that's part of the charm.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Great italian food. Small and not too busy. Will go again. Yelp requires more characters
Wife's Birthday Dinner in Plymouth, started with some Fresh Bread and Olive Oil, we had Caesar Salad for an Appetizer, our Main Dishes were the Wife had: PENNE ALLA SICILIANA and the Husband had: PENNE ALLA BOSCAIOLA, also for Dessert we had a Cannoli to split, sorry no picture of the Dessert, everything was fresh, delicious, and very reasonable price too, we will definitely be going back to eat there again, great little Italian Restaurant in Downtown North Plymouth...small in there but really good!!!!
The food and service are excellent but the ambiance is lacking. So long as you are not making this a celebration dinner you should be very happy with your experience. It is a VERY small dining area (6-8 tables) due to the fact it shares its space with the kitchen which is in full view in the rear. So everything feels a bit tight/cozy. So call ahead and make a reservation if for no other reason than to avoid a long wait outside.
First time visit to the Tuscany Tavern. A very quaint location in North Plymouth. Reservations recommended due to its size. TT has been around for a long time and has been serving tremendous Italian food to the community. Food was delicious and the service was friendly and good. I'll add photos at a later time.
Nice local place but food was only average
Restaurantji Recommends
Celebrated my dads birthday here and it was a perfect night from beginning to end. Staff was attentive and the food was amazing. Took us right back to Italy! The waitress even brought a bowl of ice cream with a candle in it, after my father said he was too full for dessert (but apparently not too full for ice cream!!)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
HUGE DISAPPOINTMENT to say the very least. It was my suggestion for a party of 5 and a true embarrassment. I’ve had kids meals offering more food. I’ve had signature dining in N.Y, L.A, Chicago, Orlando and this was not signature dining. The price is WAY out of range for the offering. This was an absolute one and done. If I was at the restaurant rather than ordering to go I would’ve walked out. Save your hard earned money!! You want actual plate details we’ll be happy to share including the missing items. After forking over $150.00 family is now heading out for food!!
I was taken to the Tuscany Tavern on my birthday, and based on reviews, I was excited. We walked into a partially draw curtain and waited at what we thought was a hostess station. After about 5 minutes, I poked my head in the dining area, which was sort of awkward because I felt like I was intruding on the diners that were sitting at that table. I was then asked, "Do you have a reservation" from across the dining area from the person standing in the kitchen. She then pointed to the table in the corner and said, "That's your table," so we sat ourselves down. We ordered the Caprese Salad $13.95, which was very basic and lacked salt. The soup of the day was Pasta e fagioli, I was excited to try this because I've been to many Italian restaurants and love tasting the chefs version of this soup. Well, it was a clear broth with a few diced carrots and did not have any beans in the soup. My husband said it tasted like Progresso Soup from a can, and I actually agree. My husband ordered the SPAGHETTI ALLE VONGOLE, $22.95 and he liked it. My daughter ordered FETTUCCINE ALLA BOLOGNESE, $24.95 and we would say it was OK. I ordered the SPAGHETTI ALLA CARBONARA $20.95. The dish that was placed in front of me was awful. It had what I believe were shallots that were partly raw and still crunchy, the sauce that coated the pasta was not a creamy sauce it was bits of scrambled egg with rubbery bacon and not flavor of mascarpone or parmesan cheese that was in the menu's description. The one waitress did a decent job, considering she was waiting on 6 out of the 8 tables herself. I would not personally recommend this restaurant. The prices they are charging for food that is mediocre at best.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 3
They don’t know the difference between chicken and veal and when they serve you veal and you tell them that’s not what you ordered they purposely make you wait to prove a point that the customer is always wrong.
Food is perfect . Atmosphere is great always a good meal . We have been here on many date nights waitresses are nice and attentive