Captain Dusty's Ice Cream
143 Derby St, Salem
(978) 744-0777
Menu
Photos
+35 photos
+34 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
After checking review I queued in a long line to try their Ice cream. Had a spoon of pumpkin pie without the crust,and blueberry of Main. The pumpkin wasn’t the dominant flavor rather than the cinnamon and the blueberry was more like a bubble gum flavor. It was overly sweet and lack of the full cream flavor. The shop was quirky and what you want from a shop by the sea. Lots of signs and hand writing on the wall. Prices were good but portions were big !!
The shop is small, but the service was quick. Good prices for the sizes. We definitely got more ice cream for the sizes than we thought we’d get. There was a good variety of flavors. I liked that they put topping on the bottom of the cup as well as the top of the ice cream. It was a nice touch. The workers were nice. There are a couple of benches to sit on just outside the shop.
Fantastic ice cream served in huge portions! Loved the mint Oreo and coffee heath bar. Service was excellent, though there was only one person working with a line out the door. Worth the wait!
You May Also Like
Wolf Next Door Coffee - 142 Derby St
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Coffee, Pet Friendly
Mercy Tavern - 148 Derby St
![]()
American, Comfort Food, Gastropubs, Music Venues, Vegan
Maitland Farm Kitchen & Spirits - 84 Derby St
![]()
American, Salad, Soup