Holy Cow Ice Cream Cafe

181 Fort Ave, Salem
(978) 498-4387

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Salted Peanut Butter Oreo
Salted Caramel Brownie
Boston Cream Pie
Mocha Madness
Key Lime Pie
Mintsanity
Smores
Vegan

Menu

Pints
Ritzy AF
2022 North American Ice Cream Association National Flavor of the Year (1st Place) Salted Butter Cracker ice cream loaded with house-made Ritz Cracker Toffee Bark Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy
Wild Blueberry Pie
Wild blueberry ice cream mixed with house-made graham cracker cookie crust Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy
Corner Piece
Brown butter chocolate ice cream mixed with homemade crispy brownie corner pieces Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy
Milk & Cookies
Brown sugar sweet cream ice cream loaded up with homemade chocolate chip cookies Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy
Salted Caramel Brownie
Salted caramel ice cream loaded with house-made brownie pieces & salted caramel swirl Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy
Salted Peanut Butter Oreo
Salted peanut butter ice cream loaded with Oreos Contains: Dairy, Gluten, Peanuts & Soy
Cold Brew Oreo
Our bold cold brew based ice cream loaded up with Oreos! Contains: Dairy, Gluten & Soy
Cookie Dough
Creamy vanilla ice cream mixed with chunks of cookie dough and chocolate chips Contains: Dairy, Gluten & Soy
Mintsanity
Mint ice cream loaded with Oreos, house-made double chocolate cookies, cookie dough chunks, chocolate chips & Golden Oreos Dairy: Dairy, Egg, Gluten, & Soy
Cookies & Cream
Creamy vanilla ice cream loaded with Oreos Contains: Dairy, Gluten & Soy
Cereal Milk
Fruity Pebbles steeped ice cream mixed with colorful cereal marshmallows. Colored with all natural Blue Spirulina! Contains: Dairy & Soy
Cinnamon Churro Dough
Cinnamon brown sugar ice cream loaded with cinnamon churro dough chunks Contains: Dairy, Gluten & Soy
Strawberry
National Award-Winning Strawberry: NAICA Red Ribbon Rich strawberry ice cream made with house-made strawberry reduction Contains: Dairy
Chocolate
National Award-Winning Chocolate: NAICA Blue Ribbon Chocolate ice cream made with premium Dutch chocolate Contains: Dairy
Vanilla
National Award-Winning Vanilla: NAICA Blue Ribbon Classic, creamy vanilla ice cream made with all natural Madagascar Vanilla Contains: Dairy
Xtra Xtra
Iced coffee ice cream. Extra Cream. Extra Sugar. Contains: Dairy
Apple Pie
Apple cinnamon ice cream loaded with house-made graham cracker cookie crust Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy
Brown Butter Cornbread
Brown butter ice cream loaded with house-made cornbread pieces Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten, Soy
Loaded P.S.L.
Pumpkin spice latte ice cream loaded with house-made chocolate chip cookies, cookie dough chunks, fudge chips and Oreos! Contains: Dairy, Gluten, Egg & Soy
Boston Blackout
Black Cocoa ice cream loaded with house-made black cocoa layer cake and black cocoa ganache swirl Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy
Oatmeal Cream Pie
Brown sugar buttercream ice cream loaded with mini oatmeal cream pies Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy
PB Dream Bar
Peanut Butter cookie ice cream loaded with house-made PB Dream Bars & chocolate ganache swirl Contains: Dairy, Egg, Peanuts & Soy
Pumpkin Pie
Spiced pumpkin ice cream mixed with house-made graham cracker cookie crust Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy
Jackpot
2023 North American Ice Cream Association Flavor of the Year (Northeast Region) Salted butterscotch ice cream loaded with house-made caramelized Biscoff bark! Contains: Dairy, Gluten & Soy
Eazy Peazy
2022 North American Ice Cream Association National Flavor of the Year (3rd Place) Lemon curd ice cream loaded with house-made lemon bars Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy
Madagascar Gold
National Award-Winning Vanilla: NAICA Blue Ribbon Vanilla bean ice cream made with pure Madagascar vanilla beans Contains: Dairy
Nina Colada
Cherry piña colada ice cream loaded with house-made pineapple coconut cake Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy
Pistachio Baklava
Roasted pistachio butter ice cream loaded with house-made pistachio baklava pieces Contains: Dairy, Gluten & Tree Nuts
Rocky Neck Road
Chocolate almond ice cream loaded with house-made chocolate chip cookies, candied  walnuts & mini marshmallows  Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten, Soy & Tree Nuts

Topping Pods
Cereal Marshmallows
2oz container of cereal marshmallows *served in a compostable container*
Cherries
2oz container of cherries *served in a compostable container*
Chocolate Sprinkles
2oz container of chocolate sprinkles *served in a compostable container*
Cinnamon Toast Crunch
2oz container of Cinnamon Toast Crunch *served in a compostable container*
Crushed Oreos
2oz container of crushed Oreo pieces *served in a compostable container*
Fruity Pebbles
2oz container of Fruity Pebbles *served in a compostable container*
Gummy Bears
2oz container of gummy bears *served in a compostable container*
Mini M&Ms
2oz container of mini M&Ms *served in a compostable container*
Mini Marshmallows
2oz container of dehydrated mini marshmallows *served in a compostable container*
Mini Reese's Pieces
2oz container of mini Reese's Pieces *served in a compostable container*
Peanut Butter Sauce
2oz container of Reese's Natural peanut butter sauce *served in a compostable container*
Peanuts
2oz container of peanuts *served in a compostable container*
Rainbow Sprinkles
2oz container of rainbow sprinkles *served in a compostable container*
Walnuts
2oz container of walnuts *served in a compostable container*

Sauce Pods
Caramel Sauce
2oz container of caramel *served in a compostable container*
Homemade Hot Fudge Sauce
2oz container of fudge sauce made in house *served in a compostable container*
Peanut Butter Sauce
2oz container of Reese's Natural peanut butter sauce *served in a compostable container*

Beverages
Water

Gift Cards
$10 Gift Card
$25 Gift Card
$50 Gift Card
$100 Gift Card

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
+29 photos
Photo credit: ubereats
+28 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Holy Cow is aptly named as the ice cream is some of the best I have ever had. Someone recommended the award winning flavor with Ritz crackers that combines a salty flavor with the sweet. I thought is was amazing. CJ gave me a sample and I was instantly sold. Wow, I mean Holy Cow, this is awesome ice cream. Thanks CJ!
September 2025
This is the BEST ice cream I’ve ever had! We were there at a particularly busy time and it was well worth the wait. CJ did a great job handling a busy Sunday night with a smile. Delicious ice cream and great service, highly recommend!
September 2025
Holy cow has rotating vegan ice cream flavors. They like to be creative with them which is nice and often have 2-3 vegan flavors. Everything is clearly labeled which is nice! Wish they had vegan cones and would expand the number of vegan flavors offered each day. Updated from previous review on 2025-08-09
August 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Dairy Palace - 187 Fort Ave
Fast Food, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt
Super Taco - 179 Fort Ave
Mexican
Peppy's Pizzeria - 165 Fort Ave
Pizza

Holy Cow Ice Cream Cafe

181 Fort Ave, Salem, MA 01970
(978) 498-4387