Stop 3 on our State Rd morning bakery tour! When I say fresh baked goods, I mean warm right out of the oven scones. Great service from who I would assume are the Pie Chicks. Good patio seating area to enjoy their wares. Only complaint was that there wasn’t more to try - was really counting on this place to have an abundance of baked fruit desserts, like small tarts, jam cookies, mini pies for a single serving - the large pies looked excellent but were more than a baked good tourist could manage at this stage in the game.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
S. B.
I am in my 3rd decade of eating gluten free (NOT by choice) and I have to say your gluten free pies and cookies are by far the most DEE-LISH-US I have ever encountered. For me the treat is definitely worth the price! Keep up the good work!
Food: 5
Brad Schwartz
Wish I read Len’s review before visiting. He or she was spot on. It’s very meh. Not going to complain about the ridiculous pricing because that is the way of this island but there are so many other much better bakeries. I recommend you drive further up state road towards west tisbury to the Scottish Bakehouse. Much better stuff.
Can’t reply to you but I did give your service 4 stars because it was great. Glad we can agree on one thing. You be well as well.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 4
Len
I recently tried the pie from Pie Chicks, and I have to say, it was a bit of a letdown, especially considering the $38 price tag. While the pie was decent, it didn't stand out compared to other pies I've had. In fact, Corning's and Stop and Shop pies, which cost only $15, taste just as good, if not better. For nearly three times the price, I expected something exceptional, but unfortunately, Pie Chicks didn't deliver. Save your money and get the same quality for a fraction of the cost elsewhere.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
AMH
Omg yum!!! I’m eating the key lime pie as I write this and I’m absolutely blown away. How do I stop after 1 piece??! It’s beyond tasty. I’ve had just about every pie they sell and they are all extremely good. If you are a pie lover you will appreciate their pies. Not fake nasty glunky stuff… it’s all super high quality ingredients.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tee Eve
Delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kelly Minor
The best pie crust anywhere! Tender, buttery & flakey! That’s without commenting on the delicious fillings!?❤️ Yum! ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Frances Armas Edwards
Whew. Love LOVE this pie. Have stopped buying them one at a time because of the speed at which they disappear. The other baked goods are excellent. But you must try the pie. Probably top three crusts of my life and I am from the south. We also stop by before heading back to the ferry and take a few off island and they freeze well extending the joy for months to come. Treat yourself!
Racquel
Apple pie is nice. The mixture of apple and peach didn't do it for me.
Best blueberry peach pie ever!
Food: 5
Stop 3 on our State Rd morning bakery tour! When I say fresh baked goods, I mean warm right out of the oven scones. Great service from who I would assume are the Pie Chicks. Good patio seating area to enjoy their wares. Only complaint was that there wasn’t more to try - was really counting on this place to have an abundance of baked fruit desserts, like small tarts, jam cookies, mini pies for a single serving - the large pies looked excellent but were more than a baked good tourist could manage at this stage in the game.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
I am in my 3rd decade of eating gluten free (NOT by choice) and I have to say your gluten free pies and cookies are by far the most DEE-LISH-US I have ever encountered. For me the treat is definitely worth the price! Keep up the good work!
Food: 5
Wish I read Len’s review before visiting. He or she was spot on. It’s very meh. Not going to complain about the ridiculous pricing because that is the way of this island but there are so many other much better bakeries. I recommend you drive further up state road towards west tisbury to the Scottish Bakehouse. Much better stuff.
Can’t reply to you but I did give your service 4 stars because it was great. Glad we can agree on one thing. You be well as well.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 4
I recently tried the pie from Pie Chicks, and I have to say, it was a bit of a letdown, especially considering the $38 price tag. While the pie was decent, it didn't stand out compared to other pies I've had. In fact, Corning's and Stop and Shop pies, which cost only $15, taste just as good, if not better. For nearly three times the price, I expected something exceptional, but unfortunately, Pie Chicks didn't deliver. Save your money and get the same quality for a fraction of the cost elsewhere.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Omg yum!!! I’m eating the key lime pie as I write this and I’m absolutely blown away. How do I stop after 1 piece??! It’s beyond tasty. I’ve had just about every pie they sell and they are all extremely good. If you are a pie lover you will appreciate their pies. Not fake nasty glunky stuff… it’s all super high quality ingredients.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The best pie crust anywhere! Tender, buttery & flakey! That’s without commenting on the delicious fillings!?❤️ Yum! ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Whew. Love LOVE this pie. Have stopped buying them one at a time because of the speed at which they disappear. The other baked goods are excellent. But you must try the pie. Probably top three crusts of my life and I am from the south. We also stop by before heading back to the ferry and take a few off island and they freeze well extending the joy for months to come. Treat yourself!
Apple pie is nice. The mixture of apple and peach didn't do it for me.
Restaurantji Recommends
Strawberry Rhubarb PERFECT. Expensive Great taste great crust. Just as that pie should be.
Outstanding ??
To die for key lime pie...perfect for the summer, now the only question is which do we try next?
Friendly staff and great baked goods!
The BEST Key Lime Pie I have had since Key West. PERFECT!
Loading...