i accidently ordered from the wrong supreme . i called to cancel 4 minutes after i placed my order. It even states in the confirmation email to call and modify or cancel your order. So i called and the owner wouldn't honor the cancellation. he said its already cooking so he will not cancel it.
Patrick OMalley
Owner was very pleasant. He suggested garlic bread meatball sub and nailed it. Best ever.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
laura schmitt
Missing a sub, no cheese on steak and cheese, chicken cutlets lower quality than frozen supermarket and hard as a rock I don’t think they change their oil the onion rings were dark brown mush and the fries were just oil soaked nothing was edible everything went in the trash
Food: 1
Sabrina Healey
Supreme is under new ownership and the new team is a delight! Just got a call from one of their staff members ensuring he got my order exactly right and the food was delicious, would recommend!
Regina Ierardi
I just stopped in for the first time to grab dinner for the family after work. The girl behind the counter told me they just took ownership in July. 1) what nice people! Everyone working was super friendly and nice. 2) loving my dinner! Greek crust style pizza and a great deal for two cheese pizzas. The sauce has seasoning in it which I love. Lots of places have a bland sauce and I have to add crushed red pepper or Frank’s. Not so here. The Greek dressing that came with my salad is delicious and the slice of pita is soft and fresh. Will definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Greek Salad
Curtis Perry Jr
Everything’s fresh owner is awesome. Great food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
James Riley
So I looked up the online menu through Google and noticed a small calzone that I wanted said online it was 11.99 I get to the store to pick up the SMALL calzone and it was 19 dollars.. yeah you got me this time but you will never see me in your establishment ever again. 19 dollars for a small calzone is outrageous.. its smaller than a small pizza... don't waste your time going here.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Igor Drizik
Typical pizza place, a bit slow service, but plenty of parking.
Soloc Luxury
Great pizza clean store and amazing generous owner highly recommended
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cristina Ersilia
Drink prices for new owner are insane… 5.25 for a Gatorade?!
The ownership of Supreme Pizza changed in summer of 2024 and the new owners made the disappointing decision to stop offering gluten free pizza. This was my family's go to place for legitimately good GF pizza and now we will have to go find another pizza place to be our go-to pizza shop.
Mary Shaheen
We had take out last night. 2 subs and a Greek salad. The salad was ok, but had no olives. The chicken parm sub was frozen chicken patty style. My son had the meatball sub, said it was tolerable. Same, premade, frozen type components. The garlic bread sub roll was a nice touch but not enough goodness for the lousy quality ingredients. Oh, I got side cucumbers with a sub and they were dry with a yellow tinge to them, old. For the prices, I expect higher quality. I hope they improve.
Food: 1
Service: 3
Darine Elias
Great place! Awesome new owners! Had a quick lunch with my husband and son, the pizza crust was delicious, definitely recommend for the food and friendly people!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mary Doherty-Tim
New owners are fantastic! When you walk in the door you are greeted by the friendly owners and staff. I have had three wonderful take out meals from Supreme. The chicken parm and ziti was one of the best from a pizza shop I have had. New owner Arz’s sauce is delicious and tastes as fresh as it looks. The homemade fresh hummus is also a MUST try and the garlic bread subs do not disappoint! Give the new owners at Supreme a try and you will not be disappointed!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lourdes Velazquez
The personel is very friendly, but the food needs improvement. Chicken quesadilla was burned, and chicken cutlet didn't have enough meat also had no taste.
i accidently ordered from the wrong supreme . i called to cancel 4 minutes after i placed my order. It even states in the confirmation email to call and modify or cancel your order. So i called and the owner wouldn't honor the cancellation. he said its already cooking so he will not cancel it.
Owner was very pleasant. He suggested garlic bread meatball sub and nailed it. Best ever.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Missing a sub, no cheese on steak and cheese, chicken cutlets lower quality than frozen supermarket and hard as a rock I don’t think they change their oil the onion rings were dark brown mush and the fries were just oil soaked nothing was edible everything went in the trash
Food: 1
Supreme is under new ownership and the new team is a delight! Just got a call from one of their staff members ensuring he got my order exactly right and the food was delicious, would recommend!
I just stopped in for the first time to grab dinner for the family after work. The girl behind the counter told me they just took ownership in July. 1) what nice people! Everyone working was super friendly and nice.
2) loving my dinner! Greek crust style pizza and a great deal for two cheese pizzas. The sauce has seasoning in it which I love. Lots of places have a bland sauce and I have to add crushed red pepper or Frank’s. Not so here. The Greek dressing that came with my salad is delicious and the slice of pita is soft and fresh. Will definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Greek Salad
Everything’s fresh owner is awesome. Great food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
So I looked up the online menu through Google and noticed a small calzone that I wanted said online it was 11.99 I get to the store to pick up the SMALL calzone and it was 19 dollars.. yeah you got me this time but you will never see me in your establishment ever again. 19 dollars for a small calzone is outrageous.. its smaller than a small pizza... don't waste your time going here.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Typical pizza place, a bit slow service, but plenty of parking.
Great pizza clean store and amazing generous owner highly recommended
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Drink prices for new owner are insane… 5.25 for a Gatorade?!
Restaurantji Recommends
The ownership of Supreme Pizza changed in summer of 2024 and the new owners made the disappointing decision to stop offering gluten free pizza. This was my family's go to place for legitimately good GF pizza and now we will have to go find another pizza place to be our go-to pizza shop.
We had take out last night. 2 subs and a Greek salad. The salad was ok, but had no olives. The chicken parm sub was frozen chicken patty style. My son had the meatball sub, said it was tolerable. Same, premade, frozen type components. The garlic bread sub roll was a nice touch but not enough goodness for the lousy quality ingredients. Oh, I got side cucumbers with a sub and they were dry with a yellow tinge to them, old. For the prices, I expect higher quality. I hope they improve.
Food: 1
Service: 3
Great place! Awesome new owners! Had a quick lunch with my husband and son, the pizza crust was delicious, definitely recommend for the food and friendly people!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
New owners are fantastic! When you walk in the door you are greeted by the friendly owners and staff. I have had three wonderful take out meals from Supreme. The chicken parm and ziti was one of the best from a pizza shop I have had. New owner Arz’s sauce is delicious and tastes as fresh as it looks. The homemade fresh hummus is also a MUST try and the garlic bread subs do not disappoint! Give the new owners at Supreme a try and you will not be disappointed!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The personel is very friendly, but the food needs improvement. Chicken quesadilla was burned, and chicken cutlet didn't have enough meat also had no taste.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Loading...